APID is strange!

8 views
Skip to first unread message

Connie Marks

unread,
Feb 3, 2023, 6:24:50 PM2/3/23
to t2...@googlegroups.com

Per Johns tips at https://www.tmgtogedcom.com/en/apid.htm

I  converted  https://search.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll?indiv=1&dbid=60901&h=810195671 to a APID and got : 60901::810195671     

I added this number to the Reference field for my dad's Death tag and ran T2G telling it to only look at Reference fields and then generated a GEDCOM

It produced:  

1 DEAT Constant Roberts Marks III died on 26 July 1994 in Houston, Harris Co., Texas, USA, at age 87.

2 DATE 26 JUL 1994

2 PLAC Houston, Harris Co., Texas, USA

2 SOUR @S2@

3 _APID 1,60901::810195671

3 NOTE https://search.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll?indiv=1&dbid=60901&h=810195671

3 _CREF 60901::810195671

I send the Gedcom to Ancestry.com to produce a new tree, it read the gedcom and for the Death Record it reports :

Note:

_APID: 1,3693::0

 

Which does indeed allow the ancestry.com source record to be viewed.  Some  records view the source records without the need for the APID.  


--
Connie Marks

John Cardinal

unread,
Feb 7, 2023, 6:30:35 PM2/7/23
to t2...@googlegroups.com

Connie,

 

  1. I do not know why Ancestry converts the Note to the _APID: 1,3693::0 text. I have not seen that before. I doubt it is the Note value by which Ancestry makes the link. It’s the _APID record that does that.

 

  1. You wrote, “Some  records view the source records without the need for the APID.” I have never seen that. That would imply that Ancestry finds something in the citation/source that allows it to find the record in the its collection. That seems quite difficult to me, and I am surprised they would do that work when they have already provided the _APID mechanism to create a link to the record.

 

John Cardinal

 

Products: ORA, GedSite, Gedcom Publisher, Second Site, TMG Utility, TMG to GEDCOM

Web Hosting for Genealogists: Family History Hosting

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages