Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Is PowerDesigner available in Linux?

2,354 views
Skip to first unread message

Jamali

unread,
Nov 30, 2005, 6:09:55 PM11/30/05
to
Is PowerDesigner available in Linux? If so, what version,
and is it a separate purchase?

Thanks!

Karel van der Walt

unread,
Dec 1, 2005, 2:32:59 AM12/1/05
to
As far as i know, nobody ever checked if PD would run under Cross-over
office(WINE) under LINUX - it may very well do...


<Jamali> wrote in message news:438e3143.be...@sybase.com...

Mike Nicewarner

unread,
Dec 1, 2005, 9:41:48 PM12/1/05
to
PowerDesigner was never designed for Windows. They used the Microsoft
C++ foundation classes, and specifically did not work on a Linux
version, although some of us did ask for it. If enough users
asked/demanded a Linux version, they might be inclined to do something
about this, but otherwise, not.

Now, the Wine idea from Karel might be an option. I don't have a Linux
box to play with. Can anyone out there test this? I'd love to hear
what happens.

--
Mike Nicewarner [TeamSybase]
http://www.datamodel.org
mike[at]datamodel[dot]org (can you figure what to change?)
Sybase product enhancement requests:
http://www.isug.com/cgi-bin/ISUG2/submit_enhancement

Jim Egan

unread,
Dec 2, 2005, 12:59:22 AM12/2/05
to
Mike Nicewarner <"mike[at]datamodel[dot]org"> wrote...

> PowerDesigner was never designed for Windows.

Really? Must be something other than Windows I'm running on my laptop here. <G>
--
Jim Egan [TeamSybase]

Mike Nicewarner

unread,
Dec 2, 2005, 11:43:42 PM12/2/05
to
OK, answering questions while watching Southpark is probably not the
best idea. :-)
I meant "Never designed for Linux", or "Only designed for Windows."
Whichever sounds smarter and/or cooler.

--
Mike Nicewarner [TeamSybase]
http://www.datamodel.org
mike[at]datamodel[dot]org (can you figure what to change?)

Sybase product enhancement requests:
http://www.isug.com/cgi-bin/ISUG2/submit_enhancement

zp

unread,
Dec 5, 2005, 12:09:16 AM12/5/05
to
hehe,you got it,a funny mistake.

"Mike Nicewarner" <"mike[at]datamodel[dot]org"> ????
news:43912094$1@forums-2-dub...

Jim Egan

unread,
Dec 6, 2005, 1:00:45 AM12/6/05
to
Mike Nicewarner <"mike[at]datamodel[dot]org"> wrote...
> OK, answering questions while watching Southpark is probably not the
> best idea. :-)
> I meant "Never designed for Linux", or "Only designed for Windows."
> Whichever sounds smarter and/or cooler.

Or maybe that's why some feature work in an odd way. They were designed for something
other than windows. <g>
--
Jim Egan [TeamSybase]

Knut Behrends

unread,
Dec 8, 2005, 12:15:25 PM12/8/05
to
Mike Nicewarner wrote:
> PowerDesigner was never designed for Windows. They used the Microsoft
> C++ foundation classes, and specifically did not work on a Linux
> version, although some of us did ask for it. If enough users
> asked/demanded a Linux version, they might be inclined to do something
> about this, but otherwise, not.
>
> Now, the Wine idea from Karel might be an option. I don't have a Linux
> box to play with. Can anyone out there test this? I'd love to hear
> what happens.
>

I gave it a try with wine...

...with PD 10 that is included with the Sybase ASE 15 PC client , and
with PD 12 b2.
Both versions *cannot* be installed on my linux box.

PD 12 b2 while running the installer, after Agreeing to the License
PD 10.1 fails after the installer is almost finished

The error message is always a raw alert box "this program was compiled
to run under unicode" Setup will now terminate
I think this must be an error message from the PD installer

snippet of wine error message :

err:module:LdrInitializeThunk "PDCORE11.dll" failed to initialize, aborting
err:module:LdrInitializeThunk Main exe initialization for L"C:\\Program
Files\\Sybase\\PowerDesigner 11\\pdshell11.exe" failed, status c0000142


Maybe PD 9.5 runs under wine but I don't have the time to try some more.

A "wine expert" ;-) might figure it out to get it installed. Seems to be
a minor issue... maybe with the next release when wine has better
unicode support, or some other trick (getting wine to use native
libraries... or whatever it's called)


Knut

wine 0.9.2 running under ubuntu linux 5.10, i386 k7-smp Kernel
all linux software installed as binaries from the repositories

Knut Behrends

unread,
Dec 16, 2005, 5:30:56 AM12/16/05
to
I gave it another try with wine...

...with PD 11 that is included with the Sybase ASE 15 PC client
If wine is configured to emulate winxp
the PD version *can* indeed be installed and now runs on my linux box.

PD will not run under an emulated Windows 98 .
This was the pretty basic error I made the first time ... as wine does
no longer use a config file,
instead since release 20050725 wineconfig must be used to do this.

So models can be edited but some tasks such as adding ODBC data sources
will need more fine-tuning of the wine configuration and the emulated
windows.


Knut

wine 0.9.3 running under ubuntu linux 5.10, i386 k7-smp Kernel

0 new messages