Re: [Sunset Un-Limited] Group Moderation and Rules for Discussion

8 views
Skip to first unread message
Message has been deleted

jhsu...@comcast.net

unread,
Mar 26, 2008, 12:02:29 PM3/26/08
to Sunset Un-Limited, Matthew Melzer
Well Put Matt. Hope we meet face to face sometime, but it will have to be well east of New Orleans.

Jerry Sullivan
-------------- Original message ----------------------
From: Matthew Melzer <mjme...@gmail.com>
>
> On behalf of NARP, I am now the designated moderator of the SMART
> online discussion forum. In order to help facilitate effective
> teamwork towards the original purpose of this group, the following
> rules are now in force.
>
> The golden rule from which all others flow is the need to limit all
> conversation on this forum to official matters pertaining to the work
> of SMART, and to converse in a civilized, diplomatic manner.
>
> NARP originally convened this group to foster a coordinated effort to
> build local political and business support for the Sunset Limited
> route. As crafted by you, the membership of SMART, the mission of
> SMART is to preserve, restore, and expand Amtrak passenger train
> service along Amtrak's original transcontinental Sunset route. That
> encompasses our desires for a variety of outcomes (such as improved
> stations, a return to Phoenix, restored connections, daily service,
> and east-of-NOL service), none more important than another. These are
> achievable only if we work within our communities to build bridges,
> rally citizens, and make political and business leaders aware of the
> asset they already have and the potential for making it more valuable,
> and fire their enthusiasm for helping us achieve our goals.
>
> Please use this group to facilitate team-building and share strategies
> ("best practices") as you work to locally organize. Don't hesitate to
> come to NARP if you need help getting started or crafting your
> message.
>
> Discussions of abstract service and schedule issues, while potentially
> relevant, are not germane to the SMART's core work at this early point
> in our existence. But feel free to discuss news, rumors, or ideas for
> improvements that are immediately achievable.
>
> Off-topic discussions are strongly discouraged. There are a variety
> of other online forums available for general topics of railroading and/
> or politics. This is not it.
>
> Personal attacks of any kind will not be tolerated. Offending posts
> by any member of SMART will be deleted without notice and the member
> will be warned. If such behavior continues, the member will be
> permanently banned. Group morale and our reputation outside (and
> inside) the group will be in serious jeopardy if we do not act with
> the utmost mutual respect. We will demonstrate the highest regard for
> the work of other rail advocates within and outside SMART regardless
> of their age, sex, race, disability, background, geographical
> location, manner of speaking, political tendency, or other
> affiliation. I cannot overstate the importance of respect.
>
> Finally, a word about in-person SMART meetings: Everyone has a
> different idea of how to conduct the ideal, most efficient meeting.
> If SMART is to seriously organize, it must act with order and
> deliberation. Nobody likes red tape, but meetings must be conducted so
> that everyone's voices are heard and respected and a democratic
> process prevails.
>
> Remember: The world is watching. NARP is touting the work of SMART in
> our literature and presentations to our membership, and many levels of
> management at Amtrak have taken notice. Please put your best
> professional foot forward, use discretion, and go forth with dignity
> and purpose.
> >

Message has been deleted

Susan F. Heywood

unread,
Mar 28, 2008, 2:00:06 AM3/28/08
to sunset-u...@googlegroups.com
Although I agree with the rules about personal attacks and off-topic discussions, given the problems that have ensued, there is now no designated moderator for this group.
 
This group was not convened by NARP, in fact, it was designed to be a separate grassroots effort separate from NARP.
 
If there are areas where the group does not agree with NARP, that does not mean the group's ideas don't have value.
 
Thanks,

Susan

--

Howard Bingham

unread,
Mar 28, 2008, 2:30:52 AM3/28/08
to sunset-u...@googlegroups.com

I suggest that those attending the dinner Friday night ought to
convince John to stay on, or if Henry Wulff doesn't decide to turn
around, perhaps Henry can mend the fence...

Meanwhile IF Matt is reading, perhaps he would be willing to refund
any charges the hotel may charge me for cancelling AFTER the 4 P.M.
cut off time (Being he did NOT call John Frank until after 5 P.M.

Howard Bingham, still steaming, but an extra does of Inderal has
quieted my BP..

---

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages