I like the info insert idea. It would also be one less step for someone (thereby increasing liklihood of filling it out).
Once the bulletin framework is set, carli will be filling in the weekly announcements and producing the bulletin. She will be doing it on a mac, so font choice shouldn't be an issue.
My fiancee's church also does detached response cards (with much of the same info that is being proposed in our new response card). They also give out pens with the bulletins, with the expectation that people will return the pens after service (on the way out of the sanctuary) or keep them as souvenirs. I think most regular attendees return them, while newcomers tend to keep them, so the attrition rate of pens isn't too bad. Maybe we can look into the feasibility of getting several hundred pens with "QPC Sunnyside" written on them, to promote both the filling out of the response cards and the new church name? Just a thought..