My take: This was very much a dream set for me. Did not expect After All the Roads, figured we would get Act We Act, wasn't sure about Gift, figured we might get Come Around/Tilted (only Tilted tonight) but DID NOT expect JC Auto. 10 years ago I think I remember Bob saying he didn't think he had the pipes for it. Not as ferocious as the Beaster era for sure, but he sure did let out a healthy scream at the end. I very much enjoyed the new songs, which have definitely grown on me and are a valid addition to the Sugar catalog, IMO.
Band is not tight yet. I caught a few miscues and missed beats. To be expected on night one. Bob is sounding and playing great. Last year I was blown away at this, and he had it turned up tonight. He was absolutely loving this. David was smiling from ear to ear. Malcolm was focused. To me it seems this tour is more for Bob and the band than the fans. A well-deserved victory lap. In all the times I've seen him, I am not sure I have ever seen him this joyous. After the main set ended with JC Auto, he took the stage and shouted FUCK YEAH into the mic.
There was a scare mid-set. During Clownmaster, I was watching Malcolm and he had started to lean back on the throne. Was thinking he was getting into the pocket but the next moment he was gone. Fell backwards. Super strange moment as Bob and David circled the riser and continued jamming while others attended to Malcolm. After a few minutes, he pops back up and they start the next number. Scary for sure. Maybe a brief bout of heat exhaustion as David mentioned it was as hot on stage as it probably was in the crowd. I admit to keeping an eye on Malcolm the rest of the show but he played and sounded great towards the back half. Might be a little sore after the spill as he was slow getting off stage.
31 years after my last Sugar show at Roseland NYC did I think, at 52, I would be seeing this same band again at this level? I would have given it a 0% chance. SO grateful I get to do it again the next 2 nights, and again later on in the fall. Do what you can to get there. This is amazing.