-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bright Future Penny Auction Aggrieved Members Committee
c/o 3300 County Road 10, Ste 301, Brooklyn Center, MN 55429
&nb
sp; &nb
sp;
May 22, 2014
Rev. Dr. Josef Howard
“The Face”
Bright Future Penny Auction, North America (BFPA, NA)
5701, Ste 245, Shingle Creek, Brooklyn Center, MN, 5530
Dear Dr. Howard:
RE: We Pay Our Money to You Through Grace
Crawford, Paul and Yasmin at Registration and Not Customer Service. Please
Return Our Money or Pay Us As Promised.
We are observing a dubious and pendulumic assurances for payment
of affiliates, particularly BFPA payment system through the bank having assured
affiliates of payment within 48 hours which did not work. Another promise for
7-10 days payment through the bank did not also work with subsequent suspension
of said payment method. The legitimate
expectation (payment within 48 hours) which led affiliates to join
BFPA is placed into abeyance. Only God knows when affiliates of BFPA will start
getting compensation to pay back their loans used to join the company.
You told us that “as a
Pastor” you were never going to lead us into any scheme/scam and that we
should trust you because you are a
Pastor. What is going on with the payment Pastor Howard? Some affiliates
took car loans. Their cars are subject to be re-possessed due to the lack of
compensation as promised by you. We are pleading with you or “Sanjeev Kumar”
(if he does exist) to please remember Proverb 22:22 (Do not rob the poor
because they are poor…). When are we
going to get pay or get our money back if payment will not come forth as you
promised us? Is Bright Future Penny Auction which is headed by you in North
America a scam? It is our anticipation that “Hail Mary full of Grace” will not
lead us into scam but lead us to financial freedom. Blessed is a Pastor that
will not lead us into scam and depression.
Inconsistency in BFPA Policy Making
In your test message today May 22, 2014), having told an affiliate
to ask Grace Crawford for a receipt for the 30% payment made to you from an
affiliate in Atlanta Georgia, you changed your mind in less than three minutes
and wrote: “Change of mind. Since the money was sent to the company, henceforth,
anyone requesting receipt will have to wired their money to India.” What’s
about the hundreds of thousands of dollars that you have received through
Grace, Paul and Yasmin (the registrars at registration)?
Who is the Designated
Depository Transfer Agent? You or Grace Crawford?
How can we send money to India, if we do not know who is the
designated depository transfer agent of Bright Future Penny Auction, the
company you claimed to be representing in North America? Who are the agents here in Minnesota and in
India? You have refused to tell us, having written you over two times on the
question and others.
Illegal Suspension and
Perusal of Affiliates Account
Recently, we were taken aback when associates accounts were
suspended and still being suspended with perusal of their personal information
in violation of India law where you claimed the company is registered. Your
action requires a consent of a data’s subject in writing by letter, fax,
e-mail, or any other electronic communication. It is not dubious to say that
this illegal act was done with your acquiescent as you continue to call
yourself an “employee and Face of Bright Future in North America.” India law
also requires that time MUST be set for such perusal with data subject’s
consent. The 24-72 hours time set since
May 1 has long been gone. Prima facie,
we are obliged to submit our observation and suggestions infra for your
immediate action without let or hindrance:
1.
In
all your presentations, you have told us that with or without recruitment of people, daily commission on
section(s) was to be made with payment within 48 hours through our bank
accounts. Based on this legitimate expectation or gentleman agreement, many of us
joined BFPA. It was our fervent hope that such payment was to be done across
the board without preferential treatment. We noticed a complete deviation from
the company’s assurance being made by you. This was brought to your attention
in a meeting with Joseph Maeri Team. We
hope that the indignation in Bright Future Penny Auction (BFPA) at present is
being noted by you and not ignored;
2.
We
were later told that payment was to be made “within 7-10 days after
consultations with leaders.” Surprisingly, this promised was also broken
without any notification to BFPA associates. On May 1, 2014, you closed down
payment through the bank to everyone’s surprise unlike you and your
“assistants” meaning: Paul Maintona, Mrs. Grace, Crawford, Yasmin, her husband
(Amed) and “Sanjeev Kumar.” ( if he does exit);
3.
You
told us that bank transfer was to be made from BFPA affiliate bank in India, ie
ICICI Bank to the accounts of BFPA affiliates in Minnesota specifically.
Contrary to this, it has been noted that said transfer to few selected people
accounts was done locally, while you continue to tell people that the transfer
was done by the Industrial Credit and
Investment Corporation of India (ICICI). There is no evidence to substantiate your claim.
4.
For
more than two months, affiliates have been asking for the company web site,
corporate address (headquarters) with photos of “Sanjeev Kumar to be made
public. The photo of others such as Luke Teng (of Better Living of which you are also a part), his address, telephone
and e-mail are made available to the public. The reason for the secrecy
surrounding the publication of Sanjeev Kumar BFPA’s Headquarters and more
details on him create doubt about information being provided to BFPA affiliates
including clergy, who are expressing concern and therefore not willing to begin
or continue any recruitment until payment begins as promised to save themselves
from mistrust by their congregations.
5.
You
were asked to give the names of Bright Future leadership and structure in
Minnesota. You were asked if you had a leadership. You said “yes” but was “not
in the position to give said information due to security reason.” We have yet
to know the “security reason.” Why so much secrecy in BFPA and a tactics
of divide and rule?
6. We
were often told that the BFPA web site was built in India. How come it was
incorporated in the United States of America by one Mr. Ahmed Mohammed and “Go
Daddy,”who controls all documents to and from the web site instead of Sanjeev
Kumar? The server is also in the US (research findings through Alexa).
7.
You
instituted a 30% payment when people are not getting pay. In this process you
disregarded an exemption for repurchase and increase in one’s sections. It is
beyond comprehension for one to pay extra $364.50, 30% of $1215.00 to increase
or repurchase his or her sections already purchased. Undoubtedly, a reasonable
administrator will immediately re-think and ratify such odd decision;
8.
While
the first phase of the 99 days is nearer with collection of thousands of
dollars by you, Dr. Josef Howard (“The Face”) through Mrs. Grace Crawford and
Mr. Paul Maintona, we have yet to know, who is the actual designated depository transfer agent
of BFPA in Minnesota or from your office supra). Who
is depositing our money and to
which account or through which bank in Minnesota? We have a serious
concern and urged that you provide this information ASAP to BFPA affiliates. We
have the right to know under the US and India Securities and Exchange laws. The
Commercial Law of India requires that said designated depository transfer agent
must be an employee of the corporation for which he or she works. Who is this person designated by you in
Minnesota to collect and wire said money to India? Are you the person
depositing money and signing the deposit slips received by those, who got some
money from your office?
We
Don’t Want To Be Part of Money Laundering
9.
As
affiliates, we do not want to be part of money laundering. The Financial Task Force of Money Laundering
(FATF) is an intergovernmental force, of which India and the US are
members. They have the power to go after corporations and individuals. The ICICI bank to which you have been
directing affiliates and potential affiliates was among the three banks where
18 employees of ICICI were caught in money laundering attempts (Cobra Post,
India March 15, 2013).
10.
The
existence of Sanjeev Kumar and your slow response to make available the
Headquarters of BFPA and the complete absence of Sajeev Kumar during the
launching of the company in Minnesota in March , 2014 are troubling and create
doubt about the legality of Bright Future Penny Auction in the US save an
evidence is provided;
11. It is occasionally said by some of
your “aides” that the US government cannot close down your company (BFPA),
neither can any member succeed in a litigation since the company is not based
in the US. Yet, BFPA operates within the territorial jurisprudence of the
United State with an office (supra). Some people have used this self-deception and bragging to extort money from poor people and abscond with it. Proverb 22-23. He that robs and oppresses
the poor, does so at his peril. And if men will not appear for them, God will. God hears the cries of the
harvesters against exploitation by the masters of the fields (italic
ours). We joined this company trusting
you as a “Pastor” that you will not lead us in more financial hardship by
failing to pay us as promised.
12. Foreseeably, what victimized investors in
other companies such as Better Living, WCM
(777),
etc is beginning to take root in Bright Future Penny Auction headed by you in
North America. We urged you and your partners to have a fear of God and be a
man of God you say you are. We are not judging you. We just want for the name
of God to be glorified through your action.
It is against this backdrop that
we submit the following suggestions:
1. Having told us that money to pay
Bright Future associates is “ not a problem”, we suggest that you begin to pay
associates without special preference through checks or deposit, as done
previously with selected people, until payment through the bank arrangement is
finalized;
2.
We seek that the designated
depository transfer agent ( the one who collects and deposits our money to BFPA
through ICICI be known to clear doubt that money laundering is taken root in BFPA through your Minnesota
based office known as “Center for Empowerment” (address supra).This is very
urgent. We
need to know. We are making reference to the office launched at 5701 Ste 245,
Bass Lake Road, Brooklyn Center as “Bright Future office.”
3.
We need to know the Headquarters of Sajeev
Kumar the (CEO), with full address, telephone, fax and photo be placed on the
web site similar to that of Better Living ASAP, particularly the address, fax and telephone numbers and not customer
service so-called number;
4. With more than two months since
the launching of BFPA in Minnesota/North America, the need to publish its web
site should be given urgent attention with more information on Mr. Sajeev
Kumar. Current and potential members are in need of such web site.
5. The 30% placed on repurchase and
to increase one’s sections be removed without delay. It is annoying and very,
very unacceptable by affiliates. This is
extortion of affiliates to pay twice for a section already paid for with
$1,215.00. Additional $365.50 for
every re-purchase (365.50 x 4 =
$1,458.00+ $1215 x 4 = $4,815.00.) A total of $6,273.00 per section in a period of 288 days
makes no sense.
6. The institution of a cash wallet
was only a suggestion predicated on people being paid within 48 hours or within
7-10 days. With the cancelation of said payment, its imposition should be
suspended ASAP;
7. That
Mrs. Grace Crawford and Paul Maintona (sp) and Yasmin, who, according to you
have been “registering people” have received hundreds of thousand of dollars
from members in Bright Future since March 2014. They need to give out receipts to
affiliates, whose money they have
received. It is illegal to receive small or huge amount of money from people in
any business venture when they are demanding for it. We want these receipts as
evidence that you Josef Howard as “Face of the company” has received said money
through your surrogates, Mrs. Grace Crawford, Yasmin and Paul Maintona.
8. A fear of this company being another
establishment to scam people is permeating throughout the membership of Bright
Future Penny Auction (BFPA) given the inconsistency of policy, decision making
and difficulty to reach the so-called customer service;
9. The suspension and perusal of
affiliates accounts violates privacy and the Commercial Law of India and or the
Securities and Exchange laws of the US and India. We call for the immediate
restitution of all accounts suspended contrary to the law. This action affirms our demand for Mr. Sajeev
Kumar full information i.e contact number, fax and telephone to be made
available rather than referring affiliates to customer service or to a
telephone that is not directly connected to Kumar’s office.
10.
Against the aforesaid, we are
urging you to call a special general meeting to clarify doubts and other
actions taken by you which is the source of indignation among members. Please
do not refer us to customer service. We did not pay our money to customer
service.
We
look forward to your immediate intervention to resolve the problems as
enumerated. May the Lord bless you as we continue to seek financial freedom
legally
Affirmed:
Signed and affirmed: J.
Kirkpatrick Weah
Chair, BFPA Aggrieved Members Committee
Signed and Affirmed: Fredrick A.
David
Co-chair, BFPA Aggrieved Members Committee
cc:
Other aggrieved members of BFPA, North America and Australia.
Bright Future Penny Auction Grievances Committee