Well, be careful what you wish for. Hours after I wrote that I needed more time alone, Khalil\u2019s nanny tested positive for Covid, and I retreated to our bedroom to isolate myself. Sure enough, Khalil tested positive a few days later and I will be sequestered here until he and David are both negative. I am trying not to think about how long that might be.
The "deal breaker" that makes the wish not worth it also comes in a lot of possible flavors. Perhaps the character finds out that what they wanted comes at the cost of something they wanted even more. Maybe the element of their life that they wanted gone is really essential to who they are; maybe the wish isn't all they thought it was cracked up to be; or maybe it just comes true in an unanticipated manner.
In many cases the character repents of their ill-considered wish and things revert to normal, though in some stories the character is stuck in the new situation and forced to deal with the consequences of their thoughtless wish.
Often a cause of Blessed with Suck, though not the only one; wont to count as an Opinion-Changing Dream; Contains the same type of irony as Ironic Hell. In some cases the experience may lead the wisher to discover an Awful Truth.
Compare Accidental Incantation (which covers magical spells), Gone Horribly Right (when science or logic is involved rather than wishes), Wanting Is Better Than Having (when getting your wish ends with more disappointment than satisfaction), Tempting Fate (which does not specifically require a wish) and Original Position Fallacy (when someone wants something they know will be bad for some, but wrongfully assume they will benefit from it).
Asian Animation
- Bread Barbershop: In "Magic Kettle", Wilk's genie wishes go well at first, but start to go horribly wrong later on, starting with a kid wishing his school was destroyed by aliens and getting it; besides that, among other things, the elderly woman's wheelchair malfunctions, Butter can't handle the fangirls chasing him, and Bread is too rich and doesn't work anymore. It eventually gets so out of hand that Wilk uses his last wish to wish for a trip back to when he found the kettle.
- Season 2 Episode 20 of Happy Heroes is about Doctor H. finding a bottle genie and wishing that he were married to his crush, Miss Peach. He ends up going through all three of his wishes trying to fix some problems inherent in the results, as side-effects of the wishes being made with no effort:
- First, Doctor H. and Miss Peach are happily married, but with the trade-off that the heroes are now bullies and/or criminals due to Doctor H. ignoring them. The doctor consults the genie again and clarifies that he also wants the heroes to be good.
- For the second wish, Doctor H. is married to Miss Peach and the heroes are well-behaved, but now Doctor H. has an incurable disease and could pass away from it at any second. Just before that happens, he makes it back to the genie and mentions that he also wants to be 100 years old so that no diseases will be able to hurt his younger self.
- For the third and final wish, Doctor H. and Miss Peach are still married, but are now 100 years old just as the doctor wanted. The only problem here is that Doctor H. finds the senior citizen Miss Peach to be less attractive than her younger self... at which point he gives up on the wish entirely and begs for everything to go back to normal.
- Mechamato: Pian yells for Rubika's hand to let go of Amato and open the door which was blocking him, but it opens instantly afterwards. The giant hand drops Amato and invites him in, but Pian just slowly backs out of the room in fear.
Eastern European Animation
- Gypsy Tales: In "The Gypsy Woman and the Devil", Vunida wants to feed her thirteen starving children. She gets her wish when the devil turns her into a cherry tree; while her fruit helps them survive into adulthood, they never realize the tree is their cursed mother, not even when they hear the wise old man tell the story of her encounter with the devil.
Manhwa
- The Druid Of Seoul Station has Suho Park wishing to go somewhere where there are no humans and he ended up transported to another world where there are no other humans.
- Hero X Demon Queen starts with Demon Queen Elizabeth taking over the human kingdom. One of the chief mages of the human kingdom prophesies the coming of a hero who will defeat the Demon Queen. However, Elizabeth turns out to be a fair and just, if temperamental, ruler, under whose rule the human kingdom prospers more than it ever has, and by the time the prophecy is set to happen, most of humanity, including the same mage who prophesied Elizabeth's downfall, do not want her overthrown. Fortunately, the prophesied hero only wants to be an ordinary farmer, and when he does "defeat" her, it's a complete accident that doesn't hurt her aside from injuring her pride. Unfortunately, the rest of the kingdom thinks Elizabeth is dead afterwards, and several of her subordinates create a disaster trying to bring her back.
Puppet Shows
- Sesame Street:
- The Amazing Mumford and Abby Cadabby lack both the skill to control their magic and the ability to undo their mistakes. A number of episodes are based on this.
- In "Elmo Saves Christmas", Elmo wishes for it to be Christmas every day. He gets his wish but after a year of non-stop Christmases, the Christmas trees have run out, the carol singers have lost their voices, the Count is bored of counting the Christmases, a lot of things are broken because the fix-it shop is closed (and Maria and Luis have been out of practice), there's nothing on TV but It's a Wonderful Life (which people are bored of), Big Bird is sad because he misses Snuffy, who's been away visiting his grandma for a whole year, and eventually, Santa has retired to Florida. Eventually, he resets it by going back in time.
- In When You Wish Upon a Pickle, a mysterious (and sentient) Wish Pickle, which grants one wish per customer, is delivered to Sesame Street. Cookie Monster's wish for more cookies gets him multiplied, Elmo's wish to be grown-up and Chris' wish to be younger causes them to switch bodies, and Ernie's wish for Bert (who wants to be a weather man) to be on TV causes Bert to become physically trapped inside the television and get shuffled from show to show.
Visual Novels
- Amnesia: Memories
- Ikki was in elementary school and tended to be ignored by the girls. He saw a shooting star and wished to become popular with girls... and he was given the power to make any woman fall in love with him that looked him in the eye. Now he cannot go out in public without getting accosted by girls and women, and wearing sunglasses only has limited success in keeping them away.
- Ukyo wished for the heroine's fate of death to be averted, and this summoned Lord Nhil to him. He sent Ukyo to alternate universes, where the heroine was still alive, to let them meet again and live, but the heroine either died or Ukyo died. This happened so many times that it caused Ukyo to go insane and be torn between loving the heroine and wanting her to live and his own, twisted sense of survival and willingness to kill her himself.
- Case 03: True Cannibal Boy: Jade convinces Lily to pray to Nya to help Sally and get her a proper body. Unfortunately, Jade and Nya orchestrate events so that Marty kills Lily in order to give Sally a complete body.
- Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony: Depending on if you believe the mastermind, the entire game is this for the characters. According to Tsumugi, the characters were originally average, untalented, high school students who were extreme fans of the long-running reality show, Danganronpa, and auditioned to be on the fifty-third season. While only Kaede, Shuichi and Kaito's audition tapes were shown, all three were obsessed with the show, excited at the prospect of murder, and Kaito in particular was thrilled with the idea of massacring everyone. However, after being accepted, the students' personalities and memories were overwritten, and they were given new identities for the sake of pleasing the audience, making it so not one of them enjoyed their dreams being fulfilled.
- Some of the executions also fall into this category, with Kaito having wished desperately to see space, and being sent there as part of his punishment. However, this ended up being subverted because his illness killed him before the punishment was completed, and thus he got his wish, which made Monokuma livid.
- During the fifth trial, Shuichi sought to find the 'truth beyond the truth'. The case in question surrounded Kokichi faking Kaito's death and purposely having Kaito kill him, all the while making it impossible to deduce who the killer was in an attempt to nullify the killing game, which would have saved everyone. Unfortunately, Shuichi got what he wanted and ended up figuring out the truth, only to discover he had allowed Monokuma to catch on, resulting in Kaito's execution and Kokichi's plan being absolutely pointless.
- Date Warp: When Janet finds out about how much Nathaniel loves Bianca she wishes that she was his princess instead. In his bad end, her soul ends up being stuck in Bianca's body.
- Fate/stay night:
- Discussed in many places throughout the novel, but generally averted. A prevading theme seems to be 'do what you can with your own ability, and accept your own failures if it doesn't work.'
- In life, Archer wanted to save everyone but lacked the strength and ability to do so. He eventually made a contract with the world to become a Counter Guardian. It was only later he discovered that Counter Guardians don't save people, they slaughter humans en masse to prevent situations which would cause even more deaths.
- Also played straight in "Unlimited Blade Works" when Shinji obtains the Holy Grail... by having it implanted in his body, transforming him into its vessel. He recovers and is noted to have reverted to a more pleasant personality after overcoming his obsession.
- And played straight: Angra Mainyu/Avenger was an ordinary villager whose compatriots chose him to be the embodiment of all mankind's sins and sacrificed him in order to purify themselves. His soul was engraved with the "wish" for there to be a singular source from which all of humanity's evils stemmed, a wish which the Grail attempted to grant when it absorbed Avenger. As a result there now exists an Embodiment of Evil made up of every sin mankind has ever or will ever commit gestating within the Grail, waiting for a wish to free it.
- Played with in Tatarigoroshi-hen of Higurashi: When They Cry. Keiichi wishes Irie and Ooishi were dead, then Irie commits suicide and Ooishi disappears. Then, thinking he had entered another dimension, he wishes the entire village of Hinamizawa destroyed... and it gets destroyed. His wishes had nothing to do with the deaths; they were pure coincidences.
- This comes up in case 4 of Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney when von Karma jokingly suggests putting the witness's pet parrot on the stand. When you decide to humor him, he wastes no time raising an objection. Should've stayed quiet, old man.
- Later, in Justice for All, Matt Engarde wants to be found Not Guilty to the point where he hires an assassin to blackmail Phoenix with the threat of Maya being killed. When all's said and done, he can absolutely get that Not Guilty verdict... after Phoenix has told the assassin he hired that Matt intended to blackmail him. The assassin is furious and states outright that if he ever sees his employer outside of prison, he will kill him. The guy eventually confesses to avoid getting a Not Guilty verdict and being put in the assassin's sights.
- Spirit Hunter series:
- Moe from Spirit Hunter: Death Mark is a big occult fan and has always wanted to meet a ghost. She found meeting Hanahiko terrifying.
- Kaoru from Spirit Hunter: NG is a fan of the occult and geeks out at the genuinely threatening spirits that she fights alongside Akira. In one Bad End, she's decapitated by one of said spirits. While she claims to be excited at the genuine supernatural experience, the narrative notes that she's actually terrified in her last few moments before death.
- One of the side stories in Kagetsu Tohya has Shiki living in a world based on Twin Threesome Fantasy fantasy scenario he had. The problem is, he realized such a thing could never happen unless they were in a world all by themselves plus he's currently already trapped inside a "Groundhog Day" Loop. So the Dream Within a Dream he has just traps him a world where he's living forever inside the mansion grounds with only Kohaku and Hisui, doing whatever he likes with them while slowly going insane.
- The Jerkass protagonist of Yandere I Love You So I Want To Kill You wants to have sex with as many girls as possible. He gets his wish, but, as the title suggests, he gets a few Yandere girls who may try to kill him if he makes the wrong choice.
- Brought up in Your Turn to Die's backstory: several people were approached and signed consent forms allowing the company behind those forms to grant them a single wish, whether it'd be to reunite with family or cure injuries. The price paid for those wishes? Forced participation in a Deadly Game.
31c5a71286