North bound interface (CLI/REST clients) support for configuring FRR BGP

83 views
Skip to first unread message

Jeff...@dell.com

unread,
Jun 11, 2020, 2:25:43 PM6/11/20
to ben....@broadcom.com, anand.su...@broadcom.com, Renuka.M...@microsoft.com, sonic-mgmt...@googlegroups.com, cris...@gmail.com, sachin...@broadcom.com, arkadiy...@intel.com, sangitam...@gmail.com, vasan...@gmail.com, gord...@gmail.com, Luke.W...@dell.com, eric.la...@ubisoft.com, arun.b...@broadcom.com, balachan...@broadcom.com, kuany...@edge-core.com, mohamme...@broadcom.com, s...@ramkrishna.me, simon...@broadcom.com, pt...@accton.com, gord...@edge-core.com, mic...@opencompute.org, r.ragha...@gmail.com, dilip...@broadcom.com, fba...@splitted-desktop.com, dan.ar...@broadcom.com, Sameer...@dell.com, Eric.E....@dell.com, jimi...@edge-core.com, Venkatesan...@dell.com, Bhavin...@dell.com

++Bhavini

Updated subject line

 

From: Ben Gale <ben....@broadcom.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2020 11:16 AM
To: Anand Kumar Subramanian
Cc: Renuka Manavalan; sonic-mgmt...@googlegroups.com; cris...@gmail.com; sachin...@broadcom.com; Yin, Jeff; Shapiro, Arkadiy; sangitam...@gmail.com; vasan...@gmail.com; gord...@gmail.com; Williams, Lucas; Eric Lauriault; arun.b...@broadcom.com; balachan...@broadcom.com; kuanyu_chen 陳冠宇; mohamme...@broadcom.com; Sriram Ramkrishna; simon...@broadcom.com; Pttch; gord_chen 陳冠億; Michael Schill; r.ragha...@gmail.com; dilip...@broadcom.com; Francois BANDET; dan.ar...@broadcom.com; Lokray, Sameer; Seifert, Eric E; jimi_chen 陳泰維; Mahalinga, Venkatesan
Subject: Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: Canceled: Weekly subgroup meeting invite

 

[EXTERNAL EMAIL]

All,

 

We discussed this one last Friday. Questions for the Dell team are: -

- What are the next steps?

- In particular, what is the plan for a Code PR for the associated code?

 

Thanks,

 

Ben

 

On Thu, Jun 4, 2020 at 4:53 PM Anand Kumar Subramanian <anand.su...@broadcom.com> wrote:

Renuka,

 

We would like to discuss the following HLD in the subgroup meeting tomorrow.

 

 

-Anand 

 

On Fri, May 29, 2020 at 8:08 AM Ben Gale <ben....@broadcom.com> wrote:

Renuka,

 

You call - I'm simply suggesting that we keep the series in place, not least because we have at least 2 documents (FRR NBI, RBAC) that have not been reviewed yet, plus a load of code PR's coming. Whatever you decide.

 

Thanks,

 

Ben

 

On Fri, May 29, 2020 at 10:38 AM Renuka Manavalan <Renuka.M...@microsoft.com> wrote:

Hi Ben,

 

PR #550 – I am in the middle of review and I will try to get in other reviewers too. By mid-next week, we will get some f/b. We have to see, if a meeting is required

PR #583 --  I am done with this. A very good doc. I will ping the team for any comments.

PR #541 – Let me ping team for  any comments; For now, there is nothing outstanding to resolve

PR #544 – Let me ping Pavel & team for f/b and get back to you by mid next week.

 

W.r.t RBAC – These would be key documents for review.  We could revive this weekly meetings, once those docs are put for review.

 

Are we in sync?

 

Thank you,

Renuka

 

 

From: Ben Gale <ben....@broadcom.com>
Sent: Friday, May 29, 2020 6:07 AM
To: Renuka Manavalan <Renuka.M...@microsoft.com>
Cc: sonic-mgmt...@googlegroups.com; cris...@gmail.com; sachin...@broadcom.com; Jeff...@Dell.com; Shapiro, Arkadiy <arkadiy...@intel.com>; sangitam...@gmail.com; vasan...@gmail.com; gord...@gmail.com; Luke_W...@Dell.com; Eric Lauriault <eric.la...@ubisoft.com>; arun.b...@broadcom.com; anand.su...@broadcom.com; balachan...@broadcom.com; kuanyu_chen 陳冠宇 <kuany...@edge-core.com>; mohamme...@broadcom.com; Sriram Ramkrishna <s...@ramkrishna.me>; simon...@broadcom.com; Pttch <pt...@accton.com>; gord_chen 陳冠億 <gord...@edge-core.com>; Michael Schill <mic...@opencompute.org>; r.ragha...@gmail.com; dilip...@broadcom.com; Francois BANDET <fba...@splitted-desktop.com>; dan.ar...@broadcom.com; Sameer...@dell.com; Eric_E_...@Dell.com; jimi_chen 陳泰維 <jimi...@edge-core.com>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Canceled: Weekly subgroup meeting invite

 

Renuka,

 

I see a few items that need continued focus, and so suggest that we keep the series. Items are: -

1) FRR Northbound Interface - https://github.com/Azure/SONiC/pull/544. Dell developed some infrastructure (and BGP implementation) for managing FRR features through the SONiC Management Framework. This PR was raised back in December, but I don't think it's ever been reviewed. I think it should be.

2) RBAC - the Mgmt FW Phase 2 HLD that we've been reviewing contains this reference, and there is a newer version coming here. However both of these are in the project-arlo repo, and need to move to Azure/SONiC. This is another Dell item.

3) More generally, we (Broadcom, Dell) are going to start raising code PRs associated with the PRs (below) that we've been discussing - we will not wait for the HLDs review to fully close because we need to get going: -

 

Thanks,

 

Ben

 

On Thu, May 28, 2020 at 8:56 PM Renuka Manavalan <Renuka.M...@microsoft.com> wrote:

Hi all,

 

Most of my issues are either resolved or in-progress over e-mails.

So I am cancelling this series.

If anyone has a topic for this sub-group, please let me know and I can revive.

 

Thank you,

Renuka

 

________________________________________________________________________________

You're invited to join a Microsoft Teams meeting.

Video conferencing, screen sharing, and more.

Or join by phone (audio only)

+1 323-849-4874,,623221271#   United States, Los Angeles

Phone Conference ID: 623 221 271#

________________________________________________________________________________

 

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages