After Proclaiming The Opposite, Medical Pros Quietly Admit Mutilating Trans Kids Doesn't Fix Depression

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Leroy N. Soetoro

unread,
Sep 16, 2022, 6:26:03 PM9/16/22
to
https://thefederalist.com/2022/08/26/after-proclaiming-the-opposite-
medical-pros-quietly-admit-mutilating-trans-kids-doesnt-fix-depression/

After Proclaiming The Opposite, Medical Pros Quietly Admit Mutilating
Trans Kids Doesn’t Fix Depression

Amid contentious debates over gender identity, the University of
Washington Medicine, or UW Medicine, proudly and eagerly alerted the press
of a study in mid-March indicating that transgender teen patients saw
rates of depression “plummet” because of so-called “gender-affirming
care.”

The study earned nationwide praise. As Texas and Idaho were debating bans
on allowing children to receive cross-sex hormones, this was the perfect
research to show the heartlessness of conservative lawmakers and pundits
who declared puberty blockers and surgical intervention as a dangerous and
potentially irreversible gamble.

Most dramatically, after tracking the mental health of 104 transgender-
identifying patients aged 13 to 20 for a year at Seattle Children’s
Hospital, “gender-affirming care was associated with a 60% reduction in
depression and a 73% drop in harmful or suicidal thoughts among the
participants.”

But the study didn’t actually say what was initially claimed. Some voices
now accuse the researchers of purposefully misinterpreting data to promote
the irreversible.

UW Medicine’s communications department seemingly unintentionally
misinterpreted the study. But their unwillingness to proactively correct
the record was part of a concerted effort to downplay their errors because
they had already received positive press, according to emails I uncovered
through a public disclosure request.

The original press release was sent on March 11 and claimed that “gender-
affirming care for transgender and nonbinary adolescents caused rates of
depression to plummet.”

By April 8, UW Medicine communications staff dramatically changed the
claims.

Independent journalist Jesse Singal started posing questions about the
study to UW Communications staff, and one of the study’s authors, who
agreed to speak on background, confirmed that some of the data the
researchers presented, along with their claims, did not add up.

“Among the kids who went on hormones, there isn’t genuine statistical
improvement here from baseline to the final wave of data collection,”
Singal wrote on his Substack. “At baseline, 59% of the treatment-naive
kids experienced moderate to severe depression. Twelve months later, 56%
of the kids on GAM [gender-affirming medicine] experienced moderate to
severe depression. At baseline, 45% of the treatment-naive kids
experienced self-harm or suicidal thoughts. Twelve months later, 37% of
the kids on GAM did.”

In other words, there was no statistically significant improvement. At
best, the authors could argue that wrong-sex hormones and trans surgeries
did not make these children’s depression worse than it already was.

Laura East, Department of Epidemiology spokeswoman, emailed colleagues
that Singal posted “some pretty concerning claims.” However, she wrote
that UW Medicine should not respond.

“As there is an overwhelming amount of positive coverage of the study’s
findings, I don’t believe there’s a need for a proactive response beyond
continuing to monitor, but welcome your ideas for any other actions or
messaging with the study team. Happy to jump on a call too, if that’s
easier,” East said.

One UW Medicine staffer acknowledged that, at worst, the research was
“made up” yet did not want to engage because it had already received
“extremely positive” coverage. At Seattle Children’s, a staffer won’t
respond to reasonable criticisms that could affect its patients and their
families.

Dr. Kym Ahrens, an assistant professor in the Division of Adolescent
Medicine at Seattle Children’s Hospital and UW Medicine, is one of the
study’s authors and was on an email chain with the communications staff.
After initially writing a draft statement to clarify the findings, she
offered an alternative plan.

“If it gives too much attention to clarify at all, I am also very open to
not responding,” she suggested via email.

Ahrens did not respond to a request for comment to clarify her intent.

The pressure was mounting, and emails show that it became clear to the
staff that they were wrong. They finally made edits to their press release
on April 8, nearly a month after the positive coverage was broadcast and
posted. The revisions were dramatic.

“UW researchers recently found that gender-affirming care for transgender
and nonbinary adolescents likely mitigated rates of depression and
suicidality,” the press release claimed in a significant departure from
declarations of “plummeting” depression rates.

But UW Medicine admits it never reached out to media outlets that reported
the incorrect data.

“UW Medicine did not proactively reach out to any media outlet to correct
the information, however, we made the correction to our newsroom website
and called out that a correction had been made,” a spokesman said via
email to the Jason Rantz Show on KTTH. “When we distribute press releases
on research conducted at UW Medicine, we always link to the original
research within the release so that media not only see how we presented
the information but have access to the source information. We appreciate
that the error was brought to our attention so that we could make that
correction on our website and provide the updated language to any media
who inquired about the study from that point forward.”

The spokesman clarified that UW Medicine didn’t reach out because “the
transgender research was no longer a news story” and that the edits
wouldn’t have changed the positive news coverage.

But it should have.

The study itself is concerning. The findings, and subsequent interviews
and postings by some researchers, seem intentionally misleading. And as
Singal pointed out, due to a lack of available data, parts of the study
are unnecessarily difficult to understand.

This study promotes the irreversible genital mutilation of impressionable
children and suggests that it might alleviate their depression. Media
coverage of this study could influence parents to seek out these
procedures for their children, and it convinces medical professionals to
keep their concerns private.

This sets up patients for possible failure, prevents honest inquiry into
what the data says, and can unduly influence laws under debate. The
inaccurate press release has real-world consequences.

So why is there disinterest in pursuing and publicizing corrections? It
appears the study was agenda-driven from the start.

The study’s authors appear to have wanted data to back up their
preconceived notions and preferred worldview, and corporate media outlets
and progressive reporters wanted the study’s incorrect findings to be
true.


--
"LOCKDOWN", left-wing COVID fearmongering. 95% of COVID infections
recover with no after effects.

No collusion - Special Counsel Robert Swan Mueller III, March 2019.
Officially made Nancy Pelosi a two-time impeachment loser.

Donald J. Trump, cheated out of a second term by fraudulent "mail-in"
ballots. Report voter fraud: sf.n...@mail.house.gov

Thank you for cleaning up the disaster of the 2008-2017 Obama / Biden
fiasco, President Trump.

Under Barack Obama's leadership, the United States of America became the
The World According To Garp. Obama sold out heterosexuals for Hollywood
queer liberal democrat donors.

President Trump boosted the economy, reduced illegal invasions, appointed
dozens of judges and three SCOTUS justices.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages