Dear Matt ~
You're quite correct, of course. Collectanea Topographica et Genealogica which I quoted states that Elizabeth Newmarch, wife of Ralph Newmarch, died in 36 Henry VI, whereas it was her son and heir apparent, Robert Newmarch, who died in 35 Henry VI. Mea culpa. I got my eye on the wrong line when I was typing. Even so, I can't seem to locate an inquisition for Elizabeth's son, Robert Newmarch, if one ever existed.
Elsewhere I find that Throsby, Thoroton’s History of Nottinghamshire 1 (1790): 265–267 includes a pedigree and some helpful material regarding the family and extended ancestry of Elizabeth Newmarch, wife of Sir Ralph Newmarch. Thoroton's History may be viewed at the following weblink:
http://books.google.com/books?id=03tbAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA265
Below is a transcript of some of Thoroton's comments:
"This Thomas Newmarch, then call the elder, because his Son was also Thomas, had Market and Fair granted, 12 E. 3 [1338-39], as well as Free-warren in this Lordship ... which said Thomas Newmarch, his son, left it to Hugh Newmarch, his Son and Heir, who, by Fine, 1 R. 2. settled this Manor on himself and his wife Alina, and the Heirs of their Bodies, with Remainder to the right Heirs of the said Hugh. The Lands which were Margaret's, who had been Wife of Richard Reynes, one of the Daughters and Heirs of High Newmarch, Chr. 8 July, 11 H. 4 [1410] were to be seized. But Elizabeth, Daughter and Heir of the said Hugh, was married to Raph Newmarch, Son of Robert, Son of Adam, Son of Adam, Son of John, Owners of Bentley, in Yorkshire, which afterwards descended with this Manor. This Raph and Elizabeth Newmarch, had a Son called Robert, who had an only Daughter, named Elizabeth, married to John Nevile, of Althorp, in the County of Lincolne; whom the said Elizabeth, her Grandmother, over-living her said Son Robert, had a Mind to disinherit, and thereupon enfeoffed John, Duke of Norfolk, and Ralph Laventhorp, Clerk, of this Manor, and by that Means thought to convey it to Thomas Newmarch, Esquire, and the Heirs of his Body : But the Duke, after the Death of Leventhorp, not liking the Design, conveyed it to the Grandmother for Life; the Remainder to the said Elizabeth, the Wife of John Nevile, and the Heirs of her Body; who accordingly succeeded, and left a Daughter and Heir, named Joane, the Wife of Sir William Gascoigne, Knight ..." END OF QUOTE.
I note that Thoroton above makes Elizabeth (Newmarch) Newmarch to be the co-heiress of her father, Sir Hugh Newmarch, whereas Collectanea Topographica et Heraldica which I cited earlier makes her to be the sole heiress of her nephew, Thomas Newmarch. I suspect Thoroton is correct, but this matter deserves further study.
For interest's sake, below are four records which pertain to Sir Hugh Newmarch(e), Knt., of Whatton, Nottinghamshire, the father of Elizabeth (Newmarch) Newmarch. The first three records are taken from the online Discovery Catalogue. These records indicate that Hugh Newmarche was Escheator of Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire, 1379-81. The fourth record is a feet of fine dated 1378 for Sir Hugh Newmarch and his wife, Aline, which involves the settlement of the manor of Whatton, Nottinghamshire. This record is taken from Chris Phillips' collection of feet of fines on his website, Some Notes of Medieval English Genealogy. This same fine is mentioned by Thoroton quoted above.
Best always, Douglas Richardson, Salt Lake City, Utah
+ + + + + + + + + + +
1. Notts, Derb: Hugh Newmarche (1m)
Exchequer: King's Remembrancer: Escheators' Particulars of Account. Notts, Derb: Hugh Newmarche (1m). NOTE - added from Exchequer, Miscellanea B, June 1937.
Collection: Records of the Exchequer, and its related bodies, with those of the Office of First Fruits and Tenths, and the Court of Augmentations
Date range: 22 June 1379 - 21 June 1381
Reference:E 136/248/13
Browse by hierarchy | Browse by reference
+ + + + + + + + + + +
2. Hugh Newmarche (4mm)
Exchequer: King's Remembrancer: Escheators' Particulars of Account. NOTTS, DERB. Hugh Newmarche (4mm).
Collection: Records of the Exchequer, and its related bodies, with those of the Office of First Fruits and Tenths, and the Court of Augmentations
Date range: 22 June 1379 - 21 June 1381
Reference:E 136/165/3
Browse by hierarchy | Browse by reference
+ + + + + + + + + + +
3. Escheator: Hugh Newmarche, Escheatry: Notts, Derb
Exchequer: King's Remembrancer: Escheators' Files, Henry III to Richard III. Escheator: Hugh Newmarche, Escheatry: Notts, Derb.
Collection: Records of the Exchequer, and its related bodies, with those of the Office of First Fruits and Tenths, and the Court of Augmentations
Date range: 05 November 1379 - 18 October 1380
Reference:E 153/1393
+ + + + + + + + + + +
4. Feet of Fine dated 1378
Weblink:
http://www.medievalgenealogy.org.uk/fines/abstracts/CP_25_1_186_35.shtml#2
CP 25/1/186/35, number 2.
Link: Image of document at AALT
County: Nottinghamshire.
Place: Westminster.
Date: Two weeks from St Hilary, 1 Richard [II] [27 January 1378].
Parties: Hugh Neumarche, knight, and Aline, his wife, querents, and John del Grene, chaplain, Richard de Cotegraue, chaplain, and Thomas Baker of Whatton', chaplain, deforciants.
Property: The manor of What[ton'].
Action: Plea of covenant.
Agreement: Hugh has acknowledged the manor to be the right of John, as that which John, Richard and Thomas have of his gift.
For this: John, Richard and Thomas have granted to Hugh and Aline the manor and have rendered it to them in the court, to hold to Hugh and Aline and the heirs of their bodies, of the chief lords for ever. In default of such heirs, remainder to the right heirs of Hugh.