On Saturday, January 22, 2022 at 3:12:42 AM UTC-8, Paulo Ricardo Canedo wrote:
> Other than Agatha and the Conradines, what are the most divisive figure issues in medieval genealogy?
I am not sure how to quantify divisiveness - example, Portuguese and Spanish genealogists have presented conflicting alternative ancestries for Alfonso VI's mistress, Jimena Munoz, but can you really call it divisive when the two sides have largely ignored the existence of each other? And there are some that couldn't rightly be classified as divisive, being generally simply accepted as established fact due to ignorance of how flimsy they really are, or for which there are as many answers as there are people making their own guess without any of them becoming prominent enough to actually cause division (e.g. the identities of 'Louis, prince of Aquitaine', and/or the 'prince near the Alps', son(s) in law of Edward the Elder). Anyhow, a few come immediately to mind that have generated a good bit of ink (or electrons) - these are not ranked, just whatever popped into my head until I got bored with the exercise:
Robert the Strong's parentage (more historical than current)
wife of Henry of Burgundy (heir of Duke Robert I)
Stephanie, wife of William, Count of Burgundy
whatever happened in Toulouse between Raymond III Pons and William III
Zaida
mother of Vermudo II of Leon
Madragana
anything Ragnar Lothbrok-related
the 'Fairhair dynasty'
Theophano
Eodoxia
I could go on and on . . . .
taf