Looking back in the forum archives, within the thread, Ancestry of Sir Richard Page (d. 1549) (linked below) Brad Verity, John Higgins and others shared what appears to be very relevant information pertaining to the ancestry of Henry Sapcote. John Higgins pointed out that the Sapcote pedigrees in the visitation and those in Maddison's Lincolnshire cannot be trusted, and referred attention to Plantagenet Harrison's History of Yorkshire. Within the thread it seems to be convincingly established that the father of Sir John Sapcote of Elton who was married to Elizabeth Dinham was Sir Richard Sapcote who was buried in Fotheringhay in 1477.
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/soc.genealogy.medieval/Ancestry$20of$20Sir$20Richard$20Page$20(d.$201549)%7Csort:relevance/soc.genealogy.medieval/YaV0DDWgKIM/sQo5cYpS8BEJ
Plantagenet Harrison's History of Yorkshire (linked below starting at page 278 of the pdf) indicates that Richard Sapcote was married to Isabel Plessington whose IPM taken at York Castle 4th November, 10 Hen. VII, referred to in the text indicates that she was the late wife of John Francis.
https://dcms.lds.org/delivery/DeliveryManagerServlet?dps_pid=IE4784752
A portion of the IPM is found within Lincolnshire Notes and Queries, Volume 3 (linked below). Within the IPM it outlines that Isabel Plessington had three heirs resulting from her marriage with John Francis. Joan who married William Nevill of Rolleston and was said to be of the age of 50 years, Alice wife of William Staveley of Bygnall, said to be of the age of 40 years, and Joan, wife of Thomas Sapcote of Burley, said to be of the age of 35 years, and more. The age of Isabel’s eldest daughter Joan places her marriage to John Francis 1443 or earlier, which indicates that she born prior to 1430.
https://books.google.ca/books?id=6Mo4AQAAMAAJ&lpg=PA218&ots=QHUbKd50Kj&dq=burley%20%22richard%20sapcote%22&pg=PA218#v=onepage&q=burley%20%22richard%20sapcote%22&f=false
John Francis appears to have died in 1464, and a Calendar of Closed Rolls entry (copied and linked below indicates that Isabel Plessington and Richard Sapcote were married by 08 Nov 1465. Taking this into account it seems apparent that Richard Sapcote was married prior to his marriage to Isabel Plessington, because his son John Sapcote who married Elizabeth Dinham was born prior to that time.
Calendar of the close rolls preserved in the Public Record Office ... Edward IV. A.D. 1461-1468.
5 EDWARD IV. (Page 295 of the link below)
MEMBRANE 5.*
1465 Nov. 8. Westminster
To the escheator in Derbyshire. Order to give Richard Sapcote knight and Isabel his wife livery of a messuage, 40 acres of land and 10 acres of meadow in Hasilwode, four messuages, 50 acres of land and 10 acres of meadow in Osmanston, a toft, 6 acres of land and 2 acres of meadow in Normanton, and 20/. of rent in Cotton; as it is found by inquisition, taken before John Neville esquire late escheator, that Jobn Franceys knight was seised of the premises, and granted the same to Henry Pole, Ralph Pole, John Curson, John Stathum, Thomas Bradfeld and Roger Foljambe, their heirs and assigns, that the rest died, and the said Henry overlived them and was thereof seised by survivorship, that he made a grant of the same to the said John Franceys and Isabel his wife and to the heirs of their bodies, with remainder to the right heirs of John Franceys, that they had issue three daughters, namely Joan the elder, Alice and Joan the younger, that John Fraunceys died, and Isabel overlived him and is seised of the premises by survivorship, that she has taken Richard Sapcote to be her husband, and is now under his coverture, and that the premises are held of the king as of his castle or lordship of Melburne co. Leicester, which is parcel of the duchy of Lancaster ; and the king has taken the fealty of Richard Sapcote and Isabel.
https://dcms.lds.org/delivery/DeliveryManagerServlet?dps_pid=IE186234
The question is who was the wife of Sir Richard Sapcote (father of John Sapcote who married Elizabeth Dinham, and _____ Sapcote who was father to Henry Sapcote)?
I think I may have found a couple of clues.
The first in:
'Parishes: Elton', in A History of the County of Huntingdon: Volume 3, ed. William Page, Granville Proby and S Inskip Ladds (London, 1936), pp. 154-166. British History Online
http://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/hunts/vol3/pp154-166 [accessed 19 March 2017].
http://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/hunts/vol3/pp154-166
where the excerpt reads:
“From 1414 to 1425 the tenant was Oliver de Woderove (fn. 120) and from 1429 to 1447 William Wolston. (fn. 121) In 1451 Richard Sapcote was the tenant, (fn. 122) and at this time the holding seems to have been known as the Hall Fee or Hall Place. (fn. 123) The Wolstons bore for their arms argent, three turnstiles (orreels) sable, (fn. 124) and these were the arms of Sir Richard's wife, although the heraldry does not represent her as an heiress; (fn. 125) she was Isabel, the widow of Sir John Frauncis, of Burley, Rutland, (fn. 126) and died in 1493. (fn. 127) As Sir Richard Sapcote, he was holding in 1473, (fn. 128) and is said to have died in 1477. (fn. 129) In 1495, when his son, Sir John Sapcote, was the tenant, the Hall Fee was first described as a manor. (fn. 130) To his wife, Elizabeth, sister and co-heir of John, Lord Dinham, (fn. 131) he left his manor and other property in Elton, for her life, with remainder to his son Richard, vesting it in trustees. (fn. 132) At his death in 1501, Richard was a minor, betrothed to Alice or Anne, daughter of Sir Nicholas Vaux. (fn. 133) He afterwards married Christian, daughter of Sir John Hungerford, who survived him. (fn. 134) He died in 1542, directing in his will that he should be buried at Fotheringhay College, near to his grandfather, Sir Richard Sapcote.”
To me it seems there is an error in the identification of the arms of Richard Sapcote’s wife as being those of Isabel Plessington (widow of John Francis), but I am guessing that they belong to Richard Sapcote’s first wife who according to this could be a daughter of William Wolston.
The Visitation of the County of Huntingdon has an image of the arms of Richard Sapcote along with his wife’s are displayed at the bottom of page 14. Below the Sapcote pedigree on page 12 there are a couple of pages of arms for the family.
https://books.google.ca/books?id=AS1TAAAAcAAJ&dq=the%20visitation%20of%20the%20county%20of%20huntingdon%20%20sapcote&pg=PA11#v=onepage&q=the%20visitation%20of%20the%20county%20of%20huntingdon%20%20sapcote&f=false
The next clue is found in Feet of Fines: CP 25/1/294/79, number 46 located at:
http://www.medievalgenealogy.org.uk/fines/abstracts/CP_25_1_294_79.shtml#46
The most relevant portion reads:
“And after that term the same manors, tenements and advowsons shall remain to the aforesaid John Sapcote and Elizabeth, his wife, and the heirs of the body of John, to hold of the chief lords for ever. In default of such heirs, successive remainders (1) to Guy Sapcote and the heirs of his body, (2) to Thomas Sapcote and the heirs of his body, (3) to Richard Sapcote, son of John Sapcote of Keton' in the county of Rutland, and the heirs of his body, (4) to the heirs of the body of William Woulston', late of Ayleton', esquire, and (5) to the right heirs of Richard Sapcote, knight, the father of the aforesaid John Sapcote, knight.”
The inclusion of the heirs of William Wolston seems to indicate a close relationship to John Sapcote. If indeed a daughter of William Wolston was the mother of John Sapcote, it would explain why the property which passed through her to the Sapcotes was defaulted to the Wolston heirs before those of Richard Sapcote, father of John. I believe also that Guy Sapcote married Margaret Wolston, daughter of Sir Guy Wolston, which would explain his inclusion and position in the way the property defaults.
Any thoughts or insight into this would be very welcome.
Jordan Vandenberg.