Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

King's Kinsfolk: King Edward II's kinsman, Sir Gilbert Pecche, 1st Lord Pecche

424 views
Skip to first unread message

Douglas Richardson

unread,
May 14, 2008, 3:06:13 PM5/14/08
to
Dear Newsgroup ~

Sir Gilbert Pecche, Knt., 1st Lord Pecche, was styled "king's kinsman"
by King Edward II of England [Reference: Tout, The Place of the Reign
of Edward II in English Hist. (1914): 395].

The reference to Tout's comments may be viewed at the following
weblink:

http://search.live.com/books/#q=%22king's%20kinsman%22&filter=all&page=1&t=891GnkRPJZetRfmL_PpL_Q&sq=%22king's%20kinsman%22

Tout suggests (correctly I think) that the kinship betyween Gilbert
Pecche to the king comes through Gilbert Pecche's paternal
grandmother, Eve, wife of Hamon Pecche, which lady is known to have
been foreign born [see Complete Peerage, 10 (1945): 335, footnote b).
If so, it would seem that Eve Pecche was probably a near relative to
one of the foreign born queens of England. In 1242, for example, Eve
Pecche had license to go abroad.

We can be reasonably sure that Sir Gilbert Pecche was not related to
King Edward II of England through the English oryal family itself, as
Sir Gilbert's mother, Joan de Creye, is known to have married first to
Richard de Dover, a great-grandson of King John [see C.P. 10 (1945):
335–336 (sub Pecche)]. Had Gilbert Pecche's father also been a
descendant of the English royal family, then Gilbert's parents would
have needed to obtain a dispensation for affinity when they married.

Another helpful clue is the reference to Eve , widow of Robert de
Valoines, being styled “king’s cousin” to King Edward I of England
[Reference: Cal. IPMs 2 (1906): 247; see also C.P. 12(2) (1959): 150
(sub Ufford)]. Due to the given name, Eve, I have speculated that Eve
de Valoines (died 1292) was a sister of Sir Gilbert Pecche, Knt., and
thus named for Gilbert's grandmother, Eve Pecche the foreigner.

If Gilbert Pecche and Eve de Valoines were in fact siblings, then the
connection to one of the the foreign born queens would necessarily
date before King Edward I's queen, Eleanor of Castile.

We're afforded one other possible clue to the identity of Sir Gilbert
Pecche's grandmother, Eve Pecche. Complete Peerage, 10 (1945): 334
tells us that the marriage of this Eve's husband, Hamon Pecche, was
granted in 1213 to Hugh de Boves, a French knight. Hugh de Boves was
not near related to the English royal family, but he might well have
had a near kinswoman that was. My research indicates that Sir Hugh
de Boves was styled "kinsman" [nepoti] by Hugh de Gournay in 1210
[Reference: Gurney, The record of the house of Gournay (1858): 763].
This reference can be found at the following weblink:

http://books.google.com/books?id=gFUBAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA763&lpg=PA763&dq=%22Hugh+de+Boves%22&source=web&ots=_wsk0phf-5&sig=L5E_e12RyaADU9R14Qs85JFylas&hl=en

The kinship of Hugh de Boves and Hugh de Gournay is elsewhere noted in
the recent book, The Norman Frontier in the Twelfth and Early
Thirteenth Centuries (2004), by Daniel Power, pg. 359. This citation
may be viewed at the following weblink:

http://books.google.com/books?id=UrjF6T6JZvYC&pg=PA359&dq=%22Hugh+de+Boves%22&lr=&sig=JptbK3qtZbuE2f7wbCRbR9Q-2j8

For interest's sake, I should note that there is at least one 17th
Century New World immigrant that descends from Sir Gilbert Pecche,
Knt., 1st Lord Pecche, namely Jane (Lawrence) Giddings, of New
England. As for Eve (_____), widow of Robert de Valoines, I find that
she is ancestral to over 50 New World immigrants, who are listed
below.

This matter deserves further research.

Best always, Douglas Richardson, Salt Lake City, Utah

+ + + + + + + + + + + +
List of Colonial Immigrants descended from Eve (_____) de Valoines
(died 1292).

l. Elizabeth Alsop.

2. Henry, Thomas & William Batte.

3. Anne Baynton.

4. William Bladen.

5. George & Nehemiah Blakiston.

6. Thomas Booth.

7. Elizabeth Bosvile.

8. George, Giles & Robert Brent.

9. Obadiah Bruen.

10. Stephen Bull.

11. Nathaniel Burrough.

12. Elizabeth Butler.

13. Charles Calvert.

14. Edward Carleton.

15. Kenelm Cheseldine.

16. Grace Chetwode.

17. Jeremy Clarke.

18. William Clopton.

19. St. Leger Codd.

20. Francis Dade.

21. Anne Derehaugh.

22. Edward Digges.

23. Thomas Dudley.

24. John Fenwick.

25. Henry Fleete.

26. Muriel Gurdon.

27. Jane Haviland.

28. Warham Horsmanden.

29. Anne Humphrey.

30. Edmund Jennings.

31. Edmund, Edward, Richard, & Matthew Kempe.

32. Roger & Thomas Mallory.

33. Anne, Elizabeth & John Mansfield.

34. Anne & Katherine Marbury.

35. Elizabeth Marshall.

36. Anne Mauleverer.

37. Philip & Thomas Nelson.

39. Ellen Newton.

40. Thomas Owsley.

41. John Oxenbridge.

42. Herbert Pelham.

43. Henry & William Randolph.

44. Thomas Rudyard.

45. Katherine Saint Leger.

46. Maria Johanna Somerset.

47. John Stockman.

48. Jemima Waldegrave.

49. John West.

50. Thomas Wingfield.

51. Hawte Wyatt.

CE Wood

unread,
May 14, 2008, 4:07:49 PM5/14/08
to
What changed so that you now believe Eve was Gilbert's sister rather
than his daughter, as you proposed in your post of 2004, below?

"If I had to venture a guess, I would think a good bet is that Eve,
wife of Nicholas Tregoz and Robert de Valoines, was probably the
daughter of Gilbert Pecche (died 1291) by his 1st wife, Maud de
Hastings, which Maud was a possible daughter of Henry de Hastings, by
Ada of Huntingdon. If so, the Hastings-Huntingdon connection would
explain the later intermarriage between the Valoines and Comyn
families. The Comyn family was Scottish, as was Ada de Huntingdon's
family.

I read someplace that Gilbert Pecche (died 1291) was styled "king's
kinsman," which statement is probably true. Unfortunately, I haven't
found the specific citation to verify this allegation. Gilbert's
mother, also named Eve, was a foreigner. My guess is that Eve was a
near kinswoman of King Henry III of England. If correct, then it
would explain why Gilbert Pecche was called "king's kinsman" and why
Eve (_____) (Tregoz) de Valoines was called "king's cousin.""

CE Wood

On May 14, 12:06 pm, Douglas Richardson <royalances...@msn.com> wrote:
> Dear Newsgroup ~
>
> Sir Gilbert Pecche, Knt., 1st Lord Pecche, was styled "king's kinsman"
> by King Edward II of England [Reference: Tout, The Place of the Reign
> of Edward II in English Hist. (1914): 395].
>
> The reference to Tout's comments may be viewed at the following
> weblink:
>

> http://search.live.com/books/#q=%22king's%20kinsman%22&filter=all&pag...

> http://books.google.com/books?id=gFUBAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA763&lpg=PA763&dq=%...


>
> The kinship of Hugh de Boves and Hugh de Gournay is elsewhere noted in
> the recent book, The Norman Frontier in the Twelfth and Early
> Thirteenth Centuries (2004), by Daniel Power, pg. 359. This citation
> may be viewed at the following weblink:
>

> http://books.google.com/books?id=UrjF6T6JZvYC&pg=PA359&dq=%22Hugh+de+...

Douglas Richardson

unread,
May 14, 2008, 7:00:25 PM5/14/08
to
On May 14, 2:07 pm, CE Wood <wood...@msn.com> wrote:
> What changed so that you now believe Eve was Gilbert's sister rather
> than his daughter, as you proposed in your post of 2004, below?
>
> CE Wood

In my post earlier today, I was chiefly discussing Sir Gilbert Pecche,
Knt.., 1st Lord Pecche, died 1322, NOT his father, Gilbert Pecche,
died 1291. You appear to have confused father and son. It was the
elder Gilbert Pecche who married Joan de Creye, widow of Richard de
Dover.

mhol...@mac.com

unread,
May 14, 2008, 7:09:57 PM5/14/08
to
>
> For interest's sake, I should note that there is at least one 17th
> Century New World immigrant that descends from Sir Gilbert Pecche,
> Knt., 1st Lord Pecche, namely Jane (Lawrence) Giddings, of New
> England.

I would add all of Jane's siblings too including my ancestress Mary
(Lawrence) Burnham.

Merilyn Pedrick

unread,
May 14, 2008, 7:43:52 PM5/14/08
to Douglas Richardson, gen-me...@rootsweb.com
Thankyou Douglas for the information that Eve, the wife of Hamon Pecche
had previously been married to Robert de Valoines. I previously had two
separate Eves.
Merilyn Pedrick
Here is previous correspondence about Eve:-
Rosie,
Thank you very much for sharing this information with me. It is very
helpful and very much appreciated.
I can only hope that the identity of Eve, wife of Robert Valoines (#7
below), might proof intriguing enough to catch the eye of some of the
other researchers. It seems there may be an, as yet, unidentified royal
connection to be worked out. It will be interesting to see what clues
may turn up that will lead to that connection.
I know you are busy with many tasks, so thanks again for taking the time
to respond. Sincerely,
Gordon
-----Original Message-----
From: Rosie Bevan [<mailto:rbe...@paradise.net.nz>]
Sent: Thursday, February 19, 2004 8:57 PM
To: GEN-MED...@rootsweb.com <mailto:GEN-MED...@rootsweb.com>
Subject: Re: Robert Mortimer m. Isabel Howard
> Rosie et al, >
> Thanks for posting this; I found it very helpful. However, as you can
expect, it raises some additional questions that I'm hoping you, or
someone else, can answer.
Dear Gordon
Please see comments below
1.According to the IPM of William le Blund [CIPM I no. 585] he was
holding the "land of Lenehey(?)' of the Earl of Oxford by free marriage.
So the indication is that he was married to a comital Vere - perhaps a
daughter of Hugh de Vere and Hawise de Quincy. Cecily might be a name
that would appear in the de Vere family as it was the name of Hugh's
great grandmother.
2.The evidence about Eve's kinship to the king comes from the
inquisition of her husband [CIPM 2 no. 432]. "Mandate to W. de Odiham
and A. de Berton marvelling that they have returnes the extents sent to
them without making assignment of dower to Lady Eva, the king's cousin,
pretending that it was not fully evident to them what the king wished,
and commanding that not what pleases him, but what is in accordance with
right by these extents should be done. They need not write about the
manors of Toleshunte and Blunteshale, the king having formerly commanded
the manor of Toleshunte to be delivered to her" Eve's inquisition [CIPM
III no. 150] says that she and her first husband, Nicholas Tregoz, had
been granted the manors for life by Robert Burnel bishop of Bath and
Wells, with remainder to the heirs of Nicholas. It is unlikely that Eve
was a Criketot, on the grounds of consanguinity - unless she was a
daughter of William de Criketot by a previous wife to Agnes Blund.
3.. The following is the descent of the Valoines of Parham, Suffolk
1.Hamo de Valoines, tenant of Count Alan in Parham and other lands in
Suffolk [EYC V 234; DP 242]
2.Theobald de Valoines, lord of Parham. Father of Bertha, wife of
Ranulph de Glanville, and Matilda, wife of Hervey Walter. Living 1135.
Married to Helewise [EYC V 234; DD755] 3. Robert de Valoines , holding 7
fees of the castle guard of Richmond, dead by 1178. Married to Alice
[EYC V 234 ; DD754* see note below]
4. Theobald de Valoine held 5 1/2 fees in Parham, Suffolk, 1 fee in
Hickling Norfolk and 3 fees in Ditton, Cambs. In return for castle guard
at Richmond. Founder of Hickling priory d. bef 1209. Married to Avice.
[EYC V 234; DD 754; Monasticon Anglicanum vol VI p.476]
5. Thomas de Valoines, holding 7 fees of the honour of Richmond,
including 3 fees in Ditton. Involved in a suit over land in Parham in
1220. Married to Isabel de Creake [EYC V 234; CRR IX p.24, 31; CIPM 4
no. 392; HKF III p.428].
6. Robert de Valoines . Held the manor of Parham of John de Vaux of the
honour of Richmond. Married to Roese Blund, sister and coh of William
Blund d.s.p. 1264 [ HKF III p.428; CIPM I no. 585].
7. Robert de Valoines b. c 1247. In the custody of Robert Burnell,
bishop of Bath and Wells during his minority. Holding 3 fees in Cambs.
(Wood Ditton aka Ditton Valence) and 2 fees in Hickling, Norfolk (no
return for Suffolk) of the honour of Richmond (of Peter de Savoy) for
castle guard. Married to Eve, widow of Nicholas Tregoz. She died in 1292
[CIPM II no.381; CIPM II no.
432; CIPM III, no.125; HKF III p.428].
8. Rose de Valoines b.1280 married Sir Edmund de Pakenham. At her death
in 1353 she was holding the manor of Ditton Valoyns, held of the earl of
Richmond for 3 knights fees and 37s. yearly [CIPM X no. 111] 8. Cecily
de Valoines b.1281 married to Robert de Ufford who was granted free
warren in his lands in Parham in 1304. At her death in 1325, Cecily was
holding in dower the manor of Hickling of John of Brittany, earl of
Richmond, by service of a knight's fee and 10s. for the guard of the
castle of Richmond, and the manor of Parham of Petronilla de Nerford, by
service of 55s. for the guard of the castle of Richmond. Note.
Keats-Rohan DD 754 is clearly in error on chronological grounds for
attributing Rose Blund as wife of the Robert (generation 3) described as
dead by 1178.
I hope this has been of some help. Cheers Rosie

> -------------------------------
> To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to GEN-MEDIEV...@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message
>
>
>

CE Wood

unread,
May 14, 2008, 8:28:30 PM5/14/08
to
Oops!! Thanks for your gentle correction.

CE Wood

Douglas Richardson

unread,
May 14, 2008, 9:32:12 PM5/14/08
to
On May 14, 5:43 pm, Merilyn Pedrick <merilyn.pedr...@internode.on.net>
wrote:

< Thankyou Douglas for the information that Eve, the wife of Hamon
Pecche
< had previously been married to Robert de Valoines. I previously had
two
< separate Eves.
< Merilyn Pedrick

No, Eve, wife of Hamon Pecche, did not marry Robert de Valoines.
Eve, wife of Robert de Valoines, was a different woman. I have
speculated that Eve, wife of Hamon Pecche, was the grandmother of Eve,
wife of Robert de Valoines. I have not yet proven this connection.
This is merely speculation.

This matter deserves further research.

DR

letiTi...@gmail.com

unread,
May 14, 2008, 10:20:59 PM5/14/08
to

compliments due, and noted, as this exchange focused on the content,
got it right, and finally we have several exchanges by several members
and scholarly debate shows it CAN HAPPEN here on soc.gen.medieval

~Bret, scion of Charle de Magne

http://Back-stabbing Ancestral Descendants ASSoc.genealogy.medieval

peter...@yahoo.ca

unread,
Aug 14, 2016, 3:56:20 PM8/14/16
to
Has any further research been done to try to determine the connection between Eve, wife of Hammon Pecche and English monarchy?
0 new messages