Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Forum in Amman on Revisionist Historians

3 views
Skip to first unread message

Mustafa Naqib

unread,
Apr 6, 2001, 8:09:30 AM4/6/01
to
Forum in Amman on Revisionist Historians:
=========================================

Invitation: You are cordially invited to attend a forum under the theme
of 'What Happened to the Revisionist Historians Conference in Beirut?'
The forum will take place on Sunday, April 8, 2001, at 6:30 in the
evening, at the offices of the Jordanian Writers Association in Amman.

The speakers at the forum will be:
1) Hayat Atiyah, a Lebanese journalist specialized in European
historical revisionism and a staunch secularist.
2) Arafat Hijjazi, a Jordanian journalist known for his anti-Zionist
stances.
3) Ibrahim Alloush, editor of the Free Arab Voice (
www.fav.net), and a
member of the board of the Association against Zionism and Racism.

The moderator of the forum will be Dr. Hisham Ghassib, a university
professor and the president of the Socialist Thought Forum.

Context: After the Lebanese government banned a conference for
revisionist historians that was supposed to be held in Beirut on March
30, 2001, on the behest of the Zionist movement and Western
governments, and after a highly suspicious statement calling for such a
ban was allegedly signed by fourteen prominent Arab intellectuals,
scores of writers and intellectuals across Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon
moved to defend freedom of expression in the Arab World and to set the
record straight on revisionist historians.

The forum is just the beginning of a series of activities in this
regard that will hopefully culminate in a conference for revisionist
historians in some Arab country.  A petition denouncing the banning of
the revisionist conference in Beirut, to be signed by Arab
intellectuals, is in the works as well.

Revisionist Historians for Arabs: A Preview
===========================================

1) Who are the revisionist historians?

You probably heard through the Zionist-controlled media machine that
revisionist historians are a bunch of anti-semitic Christian
fundamentalists.  The truth, however, is that historical revisionism is
NOT an ideology or an ideological current.  Among revisionist
historians there are Muslims like Roger Garuady.  There are leftists
like Pierre Guillaume, Garaudy's publisher who used to issue a
publication called 'Socialism or Barbarism', and whose bookstore was
attacked and destroyed by the Zionists repeatedly.  There are Jews
among revisionist historians like Henry Lewkowicz and Bernard Lazar,
and there are as well Christians and Christian fundamentalists.
Historical revisionism then is not an ideology, but a position,
supported with facts and meticulous analyses, on a specific historical
event: the 'Holocaust'.  And for taken such a position, many
revisionist historians have been fined, fired from their jobs, socially
ostracized, and even assassinated.  In many countries in Western Europe
now, which claim to defend free speech otherwise, expressing views
sympathetic to historical revisionism is punishable by law.

2) Do revisionist historians deny that Jews died in WWII?

Revisionist historians do NOT deny that Jews died in the Second World
War.  They say, however, that hundreds of thousands of Jews died along
with the forty five million who perished in that war.  The revisionist
historians used hard sciences like physics and chemistry in proving
that the so-called gas chambers were not used to exterminate Jews
systematically, but to burn the corpses of people from different
nationalities (after their deaths) to circumvent plagues.  They proved,
for example, that Anne Frank died of Typhus, like many others who
supposedly died in a systematic campaign by the Nazis.  The revisionist
historians then dispute: a) the number of Jews who died in WWII, b) how
they died, and c) the alleged uniqueness of the death of the Jews in
human history.  The revisionist historians dispute scientifically the
received version of the 'Holocaust', not that Jews died in WWII.

3) Why is this important to Palestinians, Arabs, and Muslims?
   
Many Palestinians, Arabs, and Muslims, frequently voice frustration at
the indifference with which Western public opinion treats Palestinian
and Arab suffering at the hands of the Zionists.  In fact, the Zionists
have succeeded in presenting themselves to Western public opinion as a
people who were so victimized in the 'Holocaust', they practically
acquired a free license from the West to do anything to anybody at
anytime with impunity.  Palestinians, Arabs, and Muslims frequently say
when the 'Holocaust' is cited in defense of the Zionist movement that
if there had been a 'Holocaust', why should they be the ones to pay for
it?  After all, nobody, even the Jews, accuses the Arabs of
perpetrating the 'Holocaust'!

But things are not so simple. The myths of the 'Holocaust' are
extremely important for the Zionist movement.  For example:

a) the claim that the Jews were systematically exterminated in WWII,
provides the argument for the need for a safe haven for the Jews, i.e.,
the need for "Israel".  This myth basically provides a justification
for the rape of Palestine.  As Uri Avenary put it in a recent article,
the Jews are like a man who jumped from a burning building only to land
on somebody's head, and the Jews landed on the heads of the
Palestinians.  He says blithely that the [real] dislocation of a few
hundred thousand Palestinians cannot be compared of course to the
[alleged] extermination of a several million Jews, but the Palestinians
have been the victims of the 'victims', and this is why the world won't
support them as it supported the blacks of South Africa.  
b) the claim that the Jews were exterminated in a way unparalleled in
human history, i.e., the argument of the uniqueness of Jewish deaths,
provides a justification for "Israel" and the Zionist movement to
violate every ethical and legal code in the book, and to persecute
opponents, like the revisionist historians and the Arabs, without any
reprimand, even with sympathy, from the West. 
c) the claim that the countries and the peoples of the West bear a
collective guilt for the alleged 'Holocaust' lies at the heart of the
support that Western public opinion furnishes "Israel" and the Zionist
movement.  This collective guilt has been a very lucrative source of
financial compensation and moral support, without which "Israel" could
not have been established or sustained.

It is because revisionist historians of different ideological
backgrounds quarrel with all of the claims above that they represent
such a serious threat to the Zionist movement.  They basically threaten
the lifeline of Zionism in the West.  Thus, their importance as a
crucial ally to the Palestinians, Arabs, and Muslims, should not be
missed by any of us, and by the defenders of truth and justice anywhere
in the world.

On the other hand, there are Palestinians, Arabs, and Muslims who were
duped by the supporters of Zionism into thinking that to get the
Palestinian cause accepted in the West, they have to pay homage to the
Zionist version of the 'Holocaust',  and to participate in the
persecution of revisionist historians.  In fact, this is extremely
self-destructive behavior.  By accepting the claims of the Zionists
about the 'Holocaust', we would be effectively setting the stage for:

a) accepting the rape of Palestine and the legitimacy of the Jewish
invasion of Palestine, by accepting the Zionist narrative on how the
Jews 'had to' come to Palestine.
b) accepting implicitly the motives for Western political, financial,
and moral support for "Israel", and thus obstructing sincere efforts by
many Arab activists to garner support for the Palestinian cause in the
West.
c) accepting implicitly part of the motives for the siege on Iraq,
since Iraq is viewed first and foremost as a threat to "Israel".  The
memory of how the ancient Iraqis obliterated the ancient kingdom of
Israel several thousand years ago intertwine with the Hollowcause here
to provide a background of a people under a continuous threat to
maintain support for the siege, more than ten years after the Iraqi
withdrawal from Kuwait.  When claims are spread that Iraq represents a
threat to the neighboring countries, who do you think is meant here?

Thus, it is counter-productive for an Arab to gain individual
acceptance in the West by conceding to the Zionist narrative on the
'Holocaust'.  The price of that individual acceptance is the national
rights of the Palestinian Arab people.  It's not worth it!

4) Should we accept everything about revisionist historians?

Of course not!  Historical revisionism is a research project underway.
As said earlier, revisionist historians are not one monolithic
prototype.  Historical revisionism has obtained some useful results,
but it remains lacking in many points. 

For example, upon reading the literature of many revisionist
historians, I noticed that they do not give enough attention to the
role and interest of Western governments in forcibly maintaining the
myths of the 'Holocaust'.  The dilemma can be paraphrased like this: if
we agree that the death of the Jews in WWII is neither unique nor
unparalleled, and if we agree the numbers were highly over exaggerated
and that gas chambers were not used to exterminate Jews but to fight
diseases emanating from corpses, we are left with a big question which
is WHY DID THE JEWS COME TO PALESTINE THEN?

In fact, it is historically proven that European colonial powers
blocked the immigration of Jews on and off in an attempt to force them
to go to Palestine.  Why did they do that?

European colonial powers had an interest in creating an alien
demographic barrier in the midst of the Arab World, in Palestine, as is
evident from the correspondences of Viscount Palmerston, the British
Ambassador in Istanbul, and Lord Rotschield in the first half of the
nineteenth century.  That's when the idea of creating a colonial base
in Palestine first came into being, after Muhammad Ali Pasha of Egypt
succeeded in uniting the Arab east with Egypt and the Sudan. 

The need for that colonial base, i.e., the colonial need for "Israel",
remains as indispensable today as it was in the first half of the
nineteenth century.  Hence, mobilizing public support for "Israel" in
Western democratic societies, and justifying all the financial,
political, and moral support rendered to it, necessitate that Western
public opinion embrace the myths of the 'Holocaust' wholeheartedly.
Mind you, this happens NOT because poor Western governments are
manipulated by some Zionist conspiracy, but because Western governments
derive strategic benefits from creating and maintaining a colonial base
that would split the eastern and Western parts of the Arab World and
weaken it. 

To attribute all support for "Israel" by Western governments to Zionist
influence is to miss the point behind the dynamics of imperialism,
divide and conquer strategies, and economic exploitation.  In fact,
attributing all Western support to "Israel" to Zionist influence there
would set the stage for another political mishap that many Arabs make:
deluding oneself into pandering to neo-colonial policies of Western
governments in the illusion of winning them over against Zionism.  The
first political mishap, of course, is that of pandering to Zionists in
the illusion of winning over the West!  These are in fact two sides of
the same coin.  We cannot afford to miss the symbiotic relationship
between Zionism and imperialism.  By getting the Jews to play their
reactionary geopolitical role in Palestine, through "Israel",
imperialism and the Zionist movement have exposed them to serious
danger.  That is the real threat the Jews should be aware of.  We are
not the threat.  We are only a people who will not stop at anything to
get their LAND back.

Later
Ibrahim Alloush

0 new messages