Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Re Sikhs and meat

12 views
Skip to first unread message

ae99

unread,
Jan 25, 1995, 4:20:09 PM1/25/95
to
To Jatinder KAUR

What about Jhatka meat i.e animal is decapitated with sword

ae99

unread,
Jan 25, 1995, 4:24:10 PM1/25/95
to
In article <3g6fa9$l...@ns.cityscape.co.uk>, ae...@cityscape.co.uk (ae99)
says:

>
>To Jatinder KAUR
>
>What about Jhatka meat i.e animal is decapitated with sword

Also who killed T.S.Purewal ?


Jasdeep S.Suniara


Khalistan Zindabad !

Jatinder Kaur

unread,
Jan 30, 1995, 9:07:56 AM1/30/95
to

In article <01271995...@dios.demon.co.uk>, sh...@dios.demon.co.uk (shin dio) writes:
|>
|> ae...@cityscape.co.uk (ae99) wrote.....
|>
|> >To Jatinder KAUR
|>
|> Sorry, I'm not Jatinder but I'll followup anyway

|>
|> >What about Jhatka meat i.e animal is decapitated with sword
|
|> Yes Jhatka was permitted but it wasn't a command; and we are not
|> commanded to eat meat and I don't.

Ok Jatinder is also here now :-) AND more informed.

I went to the Gurudwara this weekend and asked some people
there about all this confusioning stuff.
The response I got was that Sikhs are not suppose to eat
meat. It appears like there is some contradictions
in Gurbani, but someone named Dr. Santokh Singh have
written a book called, "Why man ought not eat meat?"
Where goes through the bani step by step and
explains how there is no contraditions, and it
says that Sikhs are not suppose to eat meat.

It appears like it is well accepted by the Sikhs
that Sikhism as religion requires more research and
updating. But Sikh political problems take
higher priority at this time, and it will
be done later.

Also I was wrong about saying that we should
follow only our Gurus writing not the bani
written by other Saints. The reason for that
is: our Gurus included only the parts which they
"agreed" with. So it is the same thing as our
Gurus writing it themselves.

I hope I have settled this for once and for all.

Jatinder Kaur


|>
|> Regards,.....shin
|>
|> sh...@dios.demon.co.uk
|> ......striving to survive - causing least possible suffering......
|> .... find out what the nazi scum are doing - read SearchLight ....
|>
--
Jatinder Kaur
(All opinions expressed in my message are mine, not of my employer.)

0 new messages