Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss
The Genetic Map Of Europe
59 views
Skip to first unread message
u2
May 10, 2015, 4:46:08 PM5/10/15
to
najbardziej Slowianski kraj to Polska :)
http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
The map above, created by eupedia.com, shows the genetic makeup of
European countries based on Haplogroups. These groups each share a
common ancestor and can be one way of looking at the genetic makeup of a
population.
In humans, haplogroups can either be based on Y-DNA which is passed from
father to son or mtDNA which is passed from mother to offspring of both
sexes.
The map above is only based on Y-DNA, thus only shows male common
ancestors not female ones. Moreover, it should obviously not be used to
imply that any country is better than any other. While we there may be
differences between some of us, we are all equal.
The map does highlight some rather interesting things. Here are just a few:
The British Isles have much more common with people from France,
Spain and Portugal than they do with people from Scandinavia.
While Finland shares some similar background to the Baltic states,
it’s Y-DNA groups are quite different from the other Nordic countries.
Austria and Germany despite both being German speaking, have quite
different Y-DNA groups. However, Austria and Hungary look remarkably
similar.
The Balkans is probably the most genetically diverse region in Europe.
Iceland only has significant numbers of people from 4 different
haplogroups.
And just so people don’t take the map too seriously, here’s what reddit
user tigranater commented when the map was posted on reddit:
I wish those labels would go away on this oft-reposted map. To
clarify, those labels have no scientific meaning. They are what the
original creator of the map assigned as ethnic labels to haplogroups,
but are just plain misleading as haplogroups are haplogroups and nothing
else.
For example I’ve seen this map used to argue “Poland is more Aryan
than Germany”, which makes no sense as the R1a haplogroup isn’t an Aryan
haplogroup, it’s just the R1a haplogroup. Interestingly enough, the R1a
haplogroup is found primarily around the Proto-Indo-European homeland
and in India, so in the case of that particular haplogroup there is a
definite correspondence between descendants of Indo-Europeans and the
haplogroup.
But the case of R1a is the exception not the rule. Almost all of
Europe speaks IE languages yet the haplogroups are so diverse.
--
General Skalski o zydach w UB :
"Rozanski, Zyd, kanalia najgorszego gatunku, razem z Brystigerowa,
Fejginami, to wszystko (...) nie byli ludzie."
prof. PAN Krzysztof Jasiewicz o zydach :
"Zydow gubi brak umiaru we wszystkim i przekonanie, ze sa narodem
wybranym. Czuja sie oni upowaznieni do interpretowania wszystkiego,
takze doktryny katolickiej. Cokolwiek bysmy zrobili, i tak bedzie
poddane ich krytyce - za malo, ze zle, ze zbyt malo ofiarnie. W moim
najglebszym przekonaniu szkoda czasu na dialog z Zydami, bo on do
niczego nie prowadzi... Ludzi, ktorzy uzywają slow 'antysemita',
'antysemicki', nalezy traktowac jak ludzi niegodnych debaty, ktorzy
usiluja niszczyc innych, gdy brakuje argumentow merytorycznych. To oni
tworza mowe nienawisci".
http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
The map above, created by eupedia.com, shows the genetic makeup of
European countries based on Haplogroups. These groups each share a
common ancestor and can be one way of looking at the genetic makeup of a
population.
In humans, haplogroups can either be based on Y-DNA which is passed from
father to son or mtDNA which is passed from mother to offspring of both
sexes.
The map above is only based on Y-DNA, thus only shows male common
ancestors not female ones. Moreover, it should obviously not be used to
imply that any country is better than any other. While we there may be
differences between some of us, we are all equal.
The map does highlight some rather interesting things. Here are just a few:
The British Isles have much more common with people from France,
Spain and Portugal than they do with people from Scandinavia.
While Finland shares some similar background to the Baltic states,
it’s Y-DNA groups are quite different from the other Nordic countries.
Austria and Germany despite both being German speaking, have quite
different Y-DNA groups. However, Austria and Hungary look remarkably
similar.
The Balkans is probably the most genetically diverse region in Europe.
Iceland only has significant numbers of people from 4 different
haplogroups.
And just so people don’t take the map too seriously, here’s what reddit
user tigranater commented when the map was posted on reddit:
I wish those labels would go away on this oft-reposted map. To
clarify, those labels have no scientific meaning. They are what the
original creator of the map assigned as ethnic labels to haplogroups,
but are just plain misleading as haplogroups are haplogroups and nothing
else.
For example I’ve seen this map used to argue “Poland is more Aryan
than Germany”, which makes no sense as the R1a haplogroup isn’t an Aryan
haplogroup, it’s just the R1a haplogroup. Interestingly enough, the R1a
haplogroup is found primarily around the Proto-Indo-European homeland
and in India, so in the case of that particular haplogroup there is a
definite correspondence between descendants of Indo-Europeans and the
haplogroup.
But the case of R1a is the exception not the rule. Almost all of
Europe speaks IE languages yet the haplogroups are so diverse.
--
General Skalski o zydach w UB :
"Rozanski, Zyd, kanalia najgorszego gatunku, razem z Brystigerowa,
Fejginami, to wszystko (...) nie byli ludzie."
prof. PAN Krzysztof Jasiewicz o zydach :
"Zydow gubi brak umiaru we wszystkim i przekonanie, ze sa narodem
wybranym. Czuja sie oni upowaznieni do interpretowania wszystkiego,
takze doktryny katolickiej. Cokolwiek bysmy zrobili, i tak bedzie
poddane ich krytyce - za malo, ze zle, ze zbyt malo ofiarnie. W moim
najglebszym przekonaniu szkoda czasu na dialog z Zydami, bo on do
niczego nie prowadzi... Ludzi, ktorzy uzywają slow 'antysemita',
'antysemicki', nalezy traktowac jak ludzi niegodnych debaty, ktorzy
usiluja niszczyc innych, gdy brakuje argumentow merytorycznych. To oni
tworza mowe nienawisci".
Jakub A. Krzewicki
May 10, 2015, 4:56:23 PM5/10/15
to
u2 wrote:
> najbardziej Slowianski kraj to Polska :)
>
>
> http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
>
> http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
To się dopiero o tym dowiedziałeś?
> najbardziej Slowianski kraj to Polska :)
>
>
> http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
>
> http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
Zajrzyj na strony Czesia Białczyńskiego.
Niestety nie mogę się bardziej tu rozpisać, bo zakuwam 漢字.
--
СВЕТ
МИР
ЗНАНИЕ
brat_olin
May 10, 2015, 5:48:09 PM5/10/15
to
u2 wrote:
>
> najbardziej Slowianski kraj to Polska :)
> http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
> http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
>
Ciekawe, ze zgodnie z ta mapa w Polsce nie ma w ogole
>
> najbardziej Slowianski kraj to Polska :)
> http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
> http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
>
"Jewish/Arabic" haplogroups. A na Ukrainie - masa!
Polemizowalbym.
--
Smart questions to stupid answers
Basia
May 10, 2015, 6:20:12 PM5/10/15
to
On Sunday, May 10, 2015 at 1:46:08 PM UTC-7, u2 wrote:
> najbardziej Slowianski kraj to Polska :)
>
> http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
>
> http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
U2 daltonista czy Poludniowych Slowian
> najbardziej Slowianski kraj to Polska :)
>
> http://brilliantmaps.com/the-genetic-map-of-europe/
>
> http://i.imgur.com/GLL0M9y.png
nie uwaza za takowych?
Z mapki wynika ze Chorwacja moze byc bardziej
slowianska nizeli Polska. Szkoda ze niema mapki
dla Slowenii. Ukraina z Bialorusia tez moga
byc lepsi.
Z tym nieistniejacymi J1 to rzeczywiscie lipa,
moze Zydow pod Poludniowych Slowian podciagneli?
Basia
0 new messages