Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss
Warren's "Native American" problem is only going to get worse
3 views
Skip to first unread message
Ubiquitous
Mar 13, 2018, 7:51:38 AM3/13/18
to
If you had any doubt that Sen. Elizabeth Warren has her eye on the
White House, it was dispelled this past weekend when she showed up
on the Sunday morning talk shows to say she wasn’t running for
president.
By issuing a deliberately non-Shermanesque denial, Warren signaled
her strong interest in 2020. But while the former law professor has
learned to speak Washington doubletalk like a native, her other
tribal connections — or lack thereof — may yet trip her up.
Rather than retracting or apologizing for past assertions of Native
American identity that have been refuted by genealogists and
historians, the Massachusetts Democrat is doubling down on her story
about being a Cherokee or a Delaware.
Last month, The Post dared her to take a DNA test to prove her story
and now a Bay State paper (The Berkshire Eagle) has issued the same
challenge. The test results would either compel critics like
President Donald Trump to stop calling her “Pocahontas” or force her
to admit it was all a lie.
But while Warren won’t take the test, she also won’t shut up about
being a Native American. On the Sunday shows, she repeated the story
she’s been telling for years about her parents’ epic romance in
which her father’s family opposed the match because of her mother’s
supposed Indian ancestry.
It’s a sweet tale — but, given that no member of her family has ever
shown up on a list of tribe members or any other birth, marriage or
death records dating back to the early 19th century — it’s hard to
imagine why the blonde-haired, blue-eyed senator’s grandparents
would have rejected her mother on those grounds.
At this point, she’s only a degree away from being another Rachel
Dolezal, the white woman who passed as African-American while
becoming a local NAACP official.
Yet Warren keeps telling America that she “knows who she is” and
that “no one is going to take that part of me away.”
Why is she doing this?
Like most people and politicians, Warren is allergic to admitting
fault even if just saying you’re sorry and moving on from this mess
would be the smart thing to do.
Then, too: In a Democratic Party where identity politics and
minority status is the political gold standard, having to give up
her claim would be painful.
Despite her denials of profiting from her claims of Native American
ties, she likely never would have been appointed to the faculty of
Harvard Law without the distinction of being the first “Indian”
there. It was a key point in her rise from an obscure academic to
her current position as one of the leading lights of her party’s
left wing.
Last month, she showed up at a convention of Native Americans and
admitted that without a tribal identity — something that must be
based on actual proof — you can’t call yourself an Indian. That’s
particularly true nowadays when income from casinos has enabled some
tribes to prosper.
Yet she still stuck to her myth while saying she would be working to
defend Native American interests. It sounded as if what she was
looking for was some sort of honorary status — a modern version of
“honorary Sioux” Annie Oakley — as a mark of gratitude for her
advocacy.
But as perhaps she’s starting to realize, the higher her ambitions,
the rougher will be the treatment from the press and even popular
culture outlets that liberals assume will always be on their side.
In November, Trevor Noah said on “The Daily Show” that Trump was
being “woke” for calling out Warren for not telling the truth and
never apologizing for her Indian lies. That should have been the
wake-up call she needed. But, like taking a test that might produce
the truth, that’s not something she seems able to do.
It’s only going to get worse for Warren. In 2020, she will likely be
facing off in Democratic primaries against some real minorities,
like Sens. Kamala Harris (Calif.) and Cory Booker (NJ). So she’s not
going to get the same free pass for her Native American fairy tale
that Democratic voters in deep blue Massachusetts have given her.
It’s long past time for Warren to back down. If she doesn’t, the
cries of “Fauxcohantas” from Trump and other conservatives will be
the least of her problems.
--
Dems & the media want Trump to be more like Obama, but then he'd
have to audit liberals & wire tap reporters' phones.
White House, it was dispelled this past weekend when she showed up
on the Sunday morning talk shows to say she wasn’t running for
president.
By issuing a deliberately non-Shermanesque denial, Warren signaled
her strong interest in 2020. But while the former law professor has
learned to speak Washington doubletalk like a native, her other
tribal connections — or lack thereof — may yet trip her up.
Rather than retracting or apologizing for past assertions of Native
American identity that have been refuted by genealogists and
historians, the Massachusetts Democrat is doubling down on her story
about being a Cherokee or a Delaware.
Last month, The Post dared her to take a DNA test to prove her story
and now a Bay State paper (The Berkshire Eagle) has issued the same
challenge. The test results would either compel critics like
President Donald Trump to stop calling her “Pocahontas” or force her
to admit it was all a lie.
But while Warren won’t take the test, she also won’t shut up about
being a Native American. On the Sunday shows, she repeated the story
she’s been telling for years about her parents’ epic romance in
which her father’s family opposed the match because of her mother’s
supposed Indian ancestry.
It’s a sweet tale — but, given that no member of her family has ever
shown up on a list of tribe members or any other birth, marriage or
death records dating back to the early 19th century — it’s hard to
imagine why the blonde-haired, blue-eyed senator’s grandparents
would have rejected her mother on those grounds.
At this point, she’s only a degree away from being another Rachel
Dolezal, the white woman who passed as African-American while
becoming a local NAACP official.
Yet Warren keeps telling America that she “knows who she is” and
that “no one is going to take that part of me away.”
Why is she doing this?
Like most people and politicians, Warren is allergic to admitting
fault even if just saying you’re sorry and moving on from this mess
would be the smart thing to do.
Then, too: In a Democratic Party where identity politics and
minority status is the political gold standard, having to give up
her claim would be painful.
Despite her denials of profiting from her claims of Native American
ties, she likely never would have been appointed to the faculty of
Harvard Law without the distinction of being the first “Indian”
there. It was a key point in her rise from an obscure academic to
her current position as one of the leading lights of her party’s
left wing.
Last month, she showed up at a convention of Native Americans and
admitted that without a tribal identity — something that must be
based on actual proof — you can’t call yourself an Indian. That’s
particularly true nowadays when income from casinos has enabled some
tribes to prosper.
Yet she still stuck to her myth while saying she would be working to
defend Native American interests. It sounded as if what she was
looking for was some sort of honorary status — a modern version of
“honorary Sioux” Annie Oakley — as a mark of gratitude for her
advocacy.
But as perhaps she’s starting to realize, the higher her ambitions,
the rougher will be the treatment from the press and even popular
culture outlets that liberals assume will always be on their side.
In November, Trevor Noah said on “The Daily Show” that Trump was
being “woke” for calling out Warren for not telling the truth and
never apologizing for her Indian lies. That should have been the
wake-up call she needed. But, like taking a test that might produce
the truth, that’s not something she seems able to do.
It’s only going to get worse for Warren. In 2020, she will likely be
facing off in Democratic primaries against some real minorities,
like Sens. Kamala Harris (Calif.) and Cory Booker (NJ). So she’s not
going to get the same free pass for her Native American fairy tale
that Democratic voters in deep blue Massachusetts have given her.
It’s long past time for Warren to back down. If she doesn’t, the
cries of “Fauxcohantas” from Trump and other conservatives will be
the least of her problems.
--
Dems & the media want Trump to be more like Obama, but then he'd
have to audit liberals & wire tap reporters' phones.
0 new messages