>For example, we have
>prime ministers, police chiefs, lawyers, doctors etc. who look like us.
You also have dollar bills and coins fashioned to your likeness. You have
the colour of money, you guys really live in the land of milk and honey.
Black Jacobin
Timbuktu, Mali
The only problem I have with Jamaicans is that there are simply too many of them--no offence
meant. The cultural weight of Jamaica is such that everyone else from the West Indies becomes
either subsidiary to, or simply part of, Jamaica: to most outsiders Jamaica IS the West Indies.
There is also the power of myth and stereotypes. As an example: Jamaican Posse. What do you
think of when you hear that? How often have you heard that? Trinidadian Posse--when you stop
laughing at the thought, why have you never heard this? Are Trinidadians less violent? The same
associations tend to take hold with other cultural stereotypes--Jamaican's are agressive, arrogant,
homophobic, misogynistic, ignorant, violent etc. (At least that's what I've heard--and I hardly believe
any of it). Trinidadians are...relaxed (I can't think of anything else). Bajans are wannabe Englishmen etc.
And nobody cares about the rest of the small-islanders!
Can you imagine a Trinidadian calling anybody a small-islander?!
Are Jamaicans arrogant? Perhaps, but never in a spiteful way. Are Jamaicans nationalistic? Sure, but
so too are Trinis, Bajans and everyone else. As a Trini you will never hear me saying anything good
about Jamaica, or anywhere else, without saying something better about Trinidad--or if I can't say something
better I'll add something worse about the other place: The beaches are better in Jamaica--but the ones in Trinidad
are safer. Get used to it--this too is West Indian culture!
In reply to Mr. Muir
> Jamaicans have an added "arrogance" because of their history. We have
> tended to be very outspoken about our feelings and perceptions, which I
> think has made for a good name in the Caribbean communities in some
> places but left a bit of jealousy in others.
And any equally bad name. Also, jealousy about what?
> When Colin Powell says "Trust me," he's is being a typical Jamaican...
I rather think he is being more a politician than a Jamaican!
Regards,
Philip Thomson
Waterloo, Ontario
P.S. If you hear anything bad about Trinis don't include me: I'm really from Tobago!
>Kirt, initially you were somewhat annonying but I think your posts are
>worthwhile. You clearly display an interest (albeit combative, it seems)
>in Caribbean culture which goes beyond the usual "Hail up all Bajans"
>posts that I've complained about. I am intrigued with the idea of
>caribbean islands trying to take the "arrogance crown."
>
>I think it has a lot to do with our sense of place - we are small islands
>(except for Jamaica which is a continent to the rest of them, :) and we
>value our ground. We have been relatively independent (and poor) when
>compared to say, minorities in the United States. For example, we have
>prime ministers, police chiefs, lawyers, doctors etc. who look like us. I
>am always fascinated by American associates who point out that my family
>must be proud that I reach "so far in life." I think, yes, that my
>relatives are proud but not overwhelmed; they happen to have their own
>achievements that even outshine mine, in their estimation. In other
>words, I don't belong to the "first in the family" syndrome.
>
I liken my own upbringing to your example. My granfather was the
governor of the Bay Islands off the coast of Honduras. The islands were
British until 1860. However, the British influence is still prevalent as
most of the people on the island speak english instead of spanish.
Most of my acolades and successes were expectations and not surprises.
In fact my father would always tell his children to never become fully
American. His philosiphy was the Americans become content to easily and
fail to recognize opportunities. While I am first generation American, I
love that I have a connection to my Honduran and Caymanian roots. They
help to explain what makes me tick and why I am who I am. My question
to the newsgroup was a continueum of that quest.
>Jamaicans have an added "arrogance" because of their history. We have
>tended to be very outspoken about our feelings and perceptions, which I
>think has made for a good name in the Caribbean communities in some
>places but left a bit of jealousy in others. When Colin Powell says
>"Trust me," he's is being a typical Jamaican. (Think "don't worry, man"
>or "alright, man" etc.).
>
This is what I was looking for. An answer with some support for your
reasoning.
>I think we have taken a lot of these attitudes for granted but there are
>real anthropological/sociological/orsomelogical reasons for this which
>might be worth exploring in academic research. That would also help to
>move the understanding of Caribbean people beyond the stereotypes that are
>often invoked.
>
>Keep talking, Kirt, ain't nobody else doing it.
>
>Clive Muir
>NMSU in dah desert
Thanks for your response. I finally feel like I'm getting somewhere.
You kinda made me feel like I don't have to post anymore questions on
this subject. I had no agenda. Thanks for recognizing that.
By the way are you at New Mexico State? My alma mater, LSU will trounce
them this Saturday in Baton Rouge. :)
Peace,
Kirt
Ahem.
Being a Bahamian and usually above this sort of drivel, I have watched
this discussion unfold from the sidelines. I am compelled to point out
a few things.
1) While Jamaica has a proud history, it is nothing compared to the
history of Haiti (an much more desolate island), and quite frankly, not
enough upon which to base any sort of national pride. Particularly in
light of the fact that Jamaica until recently was not an liberated
nation, and under the power of a dictator.
2) That is partially, but not entirely, responsible for the utter misery
of the ghetto life that most Jamaicans suffer their entire lives. And I
won't even get into the level of corruption that exists throughout all
levels of government (and to be fair, this is true in most nations to
varying degrees).
3) That miserable existence drove many Jamaicans to settle in other
countries to earn decent livings at their chosen profession. During
that time, Jamaicans earned a reputation for confrontational behaviour,
rudeness, and untrustworthiness. Whether or not such a reputation was
fairly earned, it certainly has persisted to this day.
4) I believe that many Jamaicans have an inflated view of themselves
because of the popularity of aspects of and things associated with the
Rastafari culture, whether it be music, marijuana, clothing, symbolism,
haistyles, etc. Many Jamaicans allow the ignorance of outsiders, who
tend to associate Jamaicans and Rastafarians on some levels, to seep
into their own thinking. In other words, they believe their own press.
I question the wisdom of allowing one's self-image to be predicated
largely on what amounts to the ignorance of others.
5) If the intent is to have Jamaicans defend themselves for arrogance
toward Americans .... well, let me say that you will then need to attack
every other Caribbean nation.
Let me conclude by pointing out that although there is much to be said
about pride in one's heritage, this line of discussion has no inherent
value, and is rather pointless. There are so many cross-linked families
and bloodline across the Caribbean Nations (yes, even Haiti), that to
disparage one is to disparage all. The originator should be ashamed to
have raised the issue, in my opinion, and I recommend that in the future
he or she find more relevant topics in which to partake.
A Bahamian
>5) If the intent is to have Jamaicans defend themselves for arrogance
>toward Americans .... well, let me say that you will then need to attack
>every other Caribbean nation.
That was not the intent.
>
>Let me conclude by pointing out that although there is much to be said
>about pride in one's heritage, this line of discussion has no inherent
>value, and is rather pointless.
Yet you dignify it with a lengthy response?
There are so many cross-linked families
>and bloodline across the Caribbean Nations (yes, even Haiti), that to
>disparage one is to disparage all. The originator should be ashamed to
>have raised the issue, in my opinion, and I recommend that in the future
>he or she find more relevant topics in which to partake.
>
>A Bahamian
There is no shame in my game. As I said earlier, when in doubt, ask.
Thanks for your input anyway.
Kirt
And please enlighten me on the dictatorship. I must have missed that. It's
very easy to miss stuff like that.
/\ i...@sojourn.com
/()\ http://www.sojourn.com/~ita/
/_||_\ "None but ourselves can free our minds." Nesta Marley
< reasons why Jamacans should not be proud, much less arrogant>
My sister had a couple things to say :
If you get a chance, just communicate to Mr Bahamas that Jamaicans have
been arrogant since before ganja, Rastas etc. My historical research has
shown that, OK? And give us a little credit: if there's one thing we've
been fairly good at it's creating at least a semi-autonomous identity
(viz Rastafarianism, dancehall etc).
Meaning, I don't think we allow others' opinions of us to make much
headway on our identity.
Jamaicans abroad are as far as I know, also known for their incredible
drive and success occupationally, especially in the US. Many firms would
rather hire a person from the Caribbean (and most being from JA) than a
black AMerican, cos they figure they'll get a better day's work out of
them.
But I do agree with Mr Bahamas that the discussion is really not
important and a waste of good cyberspace.
Scott Wallace
Machete <sh...@polaris.net> wrote:
>C. MUIR wrote:
>>
>> : kben...@cris.com wrote:
>> : : >I beg your pardon, I think Bajan's are the most arrogant of them all.
>> : : >And proud of it!
>>
>> : : What are Bajan's ?
>>
>> Bajans mean "Barbadians or people from Barbados"
>>
>> CLive MUir
>
>Ahem.
>
>Being a Bahamian and usually above this sort of drivel, I have watched
>this discussion unfold from the sidelines. I am compelled to point out
>a few things.
>
>1) While Jamaica has a proud history, it is nothing compared to the
>history of Haiti (an much more desolate island), and quite frankly, not
>enough upon which to base any sort of national pride. Particularly in
>light of the fact that Jamaica until recently was not an liberated
>nation, and under the power of a dictator.
>
>2) That is partially, but not entirely, responsible for the utter misery
>of the ghetto life that most Jamaicans suffer their entire lives. And I
>won't even get into the level of corruption that exists throughout all
>levels of government (and to be fair, this is true in most nations to
>varying degrees).
>
>3) That miserable existence drove many Jamaicans to settle in other
>countries to earn decent livings at their chosen profession. During
>that time, Jamaicans earned a reputation for confrontational behaviour,
>rudeness, and untrustworthiness. Whether or not such a reputation was
>fairly earned, it certainly has persisted to this day.
>
>4) I believe that many Jamaicans have an inflated view of themselves
>because of the popularity of aspects of and things associated with the
>Rastafari culture, whether it be music, marijuana, clothing, symbolism,
>haistyles, etc. Many Jamaicans allow the ignorance of outsiders, who
>tend to associate Jamaicans and Rastafarians on some levels, to seep
>into their own thinking. In other words, they believe their own press.
>I question the wisdom of allowing one's self-image to be predicated
>largely on what amounts to the ignorance of others.
>
>5) If the intent is to have Jamaicans defend themselves for arrogance
>toward Americans .... well, let me say that you will then need to attack
>every other Caribbean nation.
>
>Let me conclude by pointing out that although there is much to be said
>about pride in one's heritage, this line of discussion has no inherent
>value, and is rather pointless. There are so many cross-linked families
Well said!! All these facile generalisations are being made by people who
no doubt, have not lived in other Caribbean countries apart from their
own.
If Powell is being a typical Jamaican by saying "Trust me", how did
Stokely Carmichael show that he is a typical Trinidadian? Or Farrakhan,
Rap Brown, etc. for that matter.
Once you're black and in North America, who the hell cares which lil
"island paradise" you're from?
It is unfair to associate Jamaicans with criminality because of the
activites of a small minority. Classes in "assertiveness" are available
to all those who find any one group more assertive than another. You need
it here if you haven't yet realised that.
Black slaves didn't have a choice about where they were sent. It was
dangerous for Europeans everywhere to have too many slaves of the same
ethnicity. Ashanti and Yoroba influence are seen in Jamaica. This crap
about "fiercest tribe" or whatever, is more a reflection of how we have
been programmed to think of Africa and to associate Blacks, in particular
with violence.
Some people never see through divide and rule tactics.
Nuff said,
Godfrey
> This person from the Bahamas comes across as rather snotty. Really, at
> least Jamaica is an independent country. Bahamas is essentially the
> backside of the USA. If not for tourism it would be nothing. They don't
> grow or produce anything.
Without defending mr. Machete, you are wrong. Banking is at least as
important to the Bahamas economy as is tourism.
Aad, as far as bing the backside of the USA- if you can't tell the
difference between a Bahamian and an ass(oops-) American, you have a
problem.
Peace,
Rich
Richard Thompson
Dept. of Psychology
McGill University
1205 Dr. Penfield Ave
Montreal P.Q.
H3A 1B1
"A man who is master of himself can end a sorrow as easily as he can invent
a pleasure"
-Oscar Wilde
Just had to answer! I read somewhere that many blacks in the Bahamas
are descended from Blacks who were transported by slaveowners from the
Carolinas. If that is the case, then maybe there isn't much difference?
I also read (on the language listing) that Gullah has a 60 or so percent
intelligibilty with Bahamian (creole) English. SOmething to make you
think, maybe?
This is NOT a flame! I just have a knack for finding the more than a
few similarities between American and Caribbean Blacks. We had
different colonizers/masters, and it's a shame, because I think now
we're often pitted against one another.
Alana
I am somewhat amazed, ( and encouraged ) that it has dealt with topic that could so
easily explode into flames, but instead has served its purpose of open communication.
It reminds me that the perception of arrogance, or any personality trait for that
matter is quite cultural and subjective. It could just as easily be a thread about
French, English, American, Western, Christian .....
Your same,
Kevin
http://users.aol.com/jamzen
>5) If the intent is to have Jamaicans defend themselves for arrogance
>toward Americans .... well, let me say that you will then need to attack
>every other Caribbean nation.
That was not the intent and there was no attack.
this line of discussion has no inherent
>value, and is rather pointless. There are so many cross-linked families
>and bloodline across the Caribbean Nations (yes, even Haiti), that to
>disparage one is to disparage all. The originator should be ashamed to
>have raised the issue, in my opinion, and I recommend that in the future
>he or she find more relevant topics in which to partake.
>
>A Bahamian
NO shame in my game. The fact that dialogue has grown as a result of the
original post and that fact that you dignified this psot with your 2
cents invalidates your contention that it has no inherent value.
Kirt
Kirt
Godfrey,
Get a life!
I could care less if someone agrees or disagrees with me. I asked a
question because I wanted to learn. You could have given insight.
Instead you choose to stand on the sidelines in disgust.
Lead, follow or get the heck out of the way.
The fact that this post has gone on this long debunks your "relevant
topics" viewpoint.
Kirt
"Godfrey A. Whyte" <gwh...@sympatico.ca> wrote:
>>
>> Kirt
>Ahem.
>5) If the intent is to have Jamaicans defend themselves for arrogance
>toward Americans .... well, let me say that you will then need to attack
>every other Caribbean nation.
>Let me conclude by pointing out that although there is much to be said
>about pride in one's heritage, this line of discussion has no inherent
>value, and is rather pointless. There are so many cross-linked families
>and bloodline across the Caribbean Nations (yes, even Haiti), that to
>disparage one is to disparage all. The originator should be ashamed to
>have raised the issue, in my opinion, and I recommend that in the future
>he or she find more relevant topics in which to partake.
>A Bahamian
This sounds like sour grapes from someone who has no national pride
or does not know enough of his history to have any pride.
Haiti is a country that has had a remarkable history but if you
research that history did enought you will see that a Jamaican slave
called Bookman played a very inportant role in their independence.
Perhaps of you geographical isolation not only form the rest of the
West Indies but within you own country (note Bahamas is a chain of
over 700 wee island spread out all over the Atlantic) , you cannot
fathom the idea that a proud black nation exist and is thriving.
A proud Jamaican
Is it just me or by saying tha above statement you just proved his point that
Jamaicans are arrogant? I don't think Jamaicans are arrogant your statement
sound like one. Like many other immigrants the middle and upper class
of the Jamaicans come to the States and therefore your comparison does not
hold true.
Ali
I am Trinidadian. I am proud to be Trinidadian. I have our flag in my
room at school. It is on my car. I listen to Soca and Calypso (no matter
what island it is from, yes I think Trinidad Calypso is the best)
constantly. If you want to call it arrogant fine. That is your
perogative. I do not put down nor think less of any of the other islands
in the Caribbean. We all have our role to play and own contribution to the
culture of the Caribbean. My roommate is Jamaican. I do not find him
arrogant at all. (maybe it is because we are both arrogant) He jokes
about me wishing I came from Jamaica and I do the same to him about
Trinidad. No harm done. I like it better than the Americans I have lived
with.
At my school, there are a lot of foreign students. One of the jokes that
went around was this...
Why do Americans walk around Costa Rica like they own the place? Because
they do own the place. (You could probably put any country here except for
the end. Americans think they own or could own everyplace.)
If you really want to talk about arrogance, I think Americans are the worst
in the world. My roommate
Richard A. Gibbs <rgi...@vt.edu> wrote in article
<01bbaee4$fc86f4a0$675a...@forte.engr.vt.edu>...
> I am going to add my two cents to this discussion with a twist to the
rest
> of the subject. This was "Don't worry Trinidad, you are not far behind."
> If you really want to talk about arrogance, I think " some " Americans
are the worst
^^^^^^^^
> in the world.
Peace out and 'Nuf Respect!!!!
SirShank
Dis yute fi real is one ignorant rass hole. Di yute neva come a de island
at all. Nuh even know bout de culture and massive. But a so it go still
when yuh culture dominate de region.