The McDonough Assemblage was uniquely
community-based
The loss of this
option is truly unfortunate because the McDonough
Assemblage, located northwest of the Lovettsville Fire and
Rescue Department and near the planned bike trail, represented one of
the most promising community-based, accessible school sites to be
identified in western Loudoun. Many believed it to be
Lovettsville's best option. A future Town high school would
surely emerge as the center of the community, and the McDonough
site in particular offered minimal traffic impacts. Unlike the
multi-million dollar water/wastewater treatment plants needed
for Cangiano, McDonough's site was close to the Town's water/sewer
lines. A future high school also would help the
stalled commercial development in Town. Further, with
schools constructed at the McDonough site, the Town of Lovettsville would
receive County investment via utility tap and usage fees, road
improvements, and most notably County (and grant) funding for sidewalks
to/from the schools. Funding for sidewalks? Well, according to the
Comprehensive Plan:
- All public schools will be linked to adjacent
neighborhoods by sidewalks or trails on both sides of roadways and crosswalks,
and where possible, linked to greenways or trails.” Chapter 3, Sec.
It also
states:
- Whenever possible, new public schools in the Rural Policy Area
will be located in or immediately adjacent to the Existing Villages, Towns,
and Joint Land Management Areas (JLMAs).” Chapter 3, Sec 9a8
- Loudoun County’s quality of life is a
key competitive advantage that is vital to the economic base. The County
offers a distinctive sense of place, a beautiful rural environment of
mountains, valleys, farms, estates and open space, charming small towns and
existing villages, and well-planned suburban communities in proximity to
employment corridors. Maintaining these distinctive places and their
accompanying sense of community are important advantages for Loudoun County in
a competitive marketplace.” Chapter 4,
Section 3d
Forseeable consequences to Hillsboro's
Elementary
But the vision of the Comprehensive Plan is being
discarded, especially with the County's
continued interest in siting the next western elementary
school (ES-25) at Cangiano's Wheatland Farm. Will their ES
plans facilitate going back to Wheatland Farm for
MS/HS-10? It's a real possibility and appearing alarmingly similar
to Fields Farm. At the very least, many believe a Wheatland
elementary school will, upon opening, result in the immediate closure of
Hillsboro Elementary School. Since acquiring adjacent land is the only way
Hillsboro ES could ever be expanded, why would the County dismiss
an offer made to them for the parcel behind that school, which has frontage
on paved Mountain Road? And considering that option is "possible" how can they instead justify
land banking in a rural area far from any Town or Village, based
on by-right lots that don't even have final plat approval?
Site acquisition recent
history:
This situation underscores the ongoing
difficulty Loudoun County Public Schools (LCPS) and the Board of
Supervisors (BOS) have with acquiring school sites in a
timely cost-effective manner. In 2007, voters County-wide
approved bonds for acquiring school sites. As a result, land
acquisition funding was set aside (budgeted) for a future high school
(HS-10) in northwest Loudoun, specifically north of Route 9. The
urgency to acquire that site clearly existed with the February
2009 LCPS (binding) contract for $11.4M for 170 acres
(Cangiano's Wheatland Farm). However, since LCPS' Wheatland
proposal failed last May and public support of the McDonough Assemblage
grew, the urgency to acquire a HS-10 site simply
evaporated.
Lack of urgency illogical
The McDonough Assemblage contract terms were well
known to officials, yet without urgency, time was literally running
out. Without even a letter of intent from the County, a year is
understandably too long for the landowners in the Assemblage to be expected to
wait. Supervisor Burton sensed some urgency in May 2009 when he said
expressed the desire to purchase the land soon. His rationale
was the bonds for the HS-10 land purchase had already been sold and
Loudoun taxpayers had begun paying interest on the
bonds. What he won't say is that without actually being invested
in land, their value further erodes as the real estate market rebounds
and land prices recover.
LCPS' repeated waste of limited funding
Including their attempt to acquire a site for the MS-10, LCPS has
now wasted over 4 years and nearly $2M on failed
contracts for two (2) sites, both in Wheatland, closer to
Purcellville than Lovettsville. LCPS figured out they need MORE money
and waited until last week (April 20) to ask Supervisors for an
additional $372k for MORE site studies. But their
request simply came too late for keeping the McDonough Assemblage option on
the table. Lenah, Rouse, Sycolin Creek, Fields Farm and now McDonough
- school siting failures like these have become LCPS'
signature.