Six on Bolivia: OAS Should Retract Its Press Release on Bolivian Election; The Trump Administration Is Undercutting Democracy in Bolivia; FAIR: The Bolivian Coup Is Not a Coup—Because US Wanted It to Happen; Bolivian president Evo Morales resigns aft

0 views
Skip to first unread message

panaritisp

unread,
Nov 11, 2019, 10:23:54 PM11/11/19
to Six on History
If you like what you find on the "Six on History" blog, please share w/your contacts. 

And please don't forget to check out the pertinent images attached to every post
How to Search past posts/articles by topic or issue: Click here    h/t to John Elfrank-Dana
Thanks John and Gary

 

Six on Bolivia: OAS Should Retract Its Press Release on Bolivian Election; The Trump Administration Is Undercutting Democracy in Bolivia; FAIR: The Bolivian Coup Is Not a Coup—Because US Wanted It to Happen; Bolivian president Evo Morales resigns after election result dispute; Morales urges Bolivian opposition to 'pacify the country' after riots



OAS Should Retract Its Press Release on Bolivian Election, CEPR Co-Director Says 




The Trump Administration Is Undercutting Democracy in Bolivia

"M
ultilateral organizations like the Organization of American States (OAS) have a certain perceived impartiality because they are, in theory, controlled by a diverse group of nations. But sometimes a great power can wield a disproportionate influence. It could theoretically be a coincidence that both the Trump administration and the OAS have tried—without offering any evidence—to discredit Bolivia’s national election in the past couple of weeks. But it’s more likely that this dangerous, ugly, and destabilizing operation is being pushed by Washington.

On October 20, Bolivians went to the polls to choose their president and congress. Evo Morales, the country’s first indigenous president in a country with the largest proportion of indigenous people in Latin America, was on the ballot for reelection. His main opponent, former president Carlos Mesa, is vastly preferred by the Trump administration. Since Morales was elected in 2005, the US government has been hostile, and Bolivia has not had ambassadorial relations with the United States since 2009. Morales is one of the last remaining members of a cohort of independent, left presidents who have been opposed, and in some cases removed with the help of, the United States.

When the official tally was done, Morales had 47.1 percent of the vote, with 36.5 percent for Mesa in second place. This meant that Morales had won the presidency without going to a runoff, because the rules allow for a first-round win for a candidate that gets at least 40 percent of the vote and a 10-point margin over the closest competitor."


Bolivian president Evo Morales resigns after election result dispute

"Evo Morales has announced he will resign as president of Bolivia after the military called for him to step down and the police withdrew their support following weeks of unrest over disputed election results.


In a televised address, Bolivia’s president of nearly 14 years said he was stepping down for the “good of the country”. but added in an attack on opponents whom he had accused of a coup attempt: “Dark forces have destroyed democracy.”

Morales, Bolivia’s first indigenous leader, later said on Twitter that the police had an “illegal” warrant for his arrest and that “violent groups” had attacked his home in Cochabamba, a city in central Bolivia."

[President's home ransacked, threats from the Army, the Police resign, and he narrowly avoids arrest? - sounds like an "election dispute" to me.]



Allies denounce ‘coup’

"Latin American leftist allies rallied to denounce what they called a coup against one of their own.

Venezuela’s President Nicolas Maduro said Morales and Bolivia’s indigenous communities were “victims of racism.”

Hooded demonstrators overran Venezuela’s embassy in La Paz on Sunday, the country’s ambassador, Crisbeylee Gonzalez, told state news agency ABI.

Cuba’s Foreign Minister Bruno Rodriguez described Morales as “a protagonist and a symbol of the rights of the indigenous peoples of our Americas.”

And Brazil’s Luis Inacio Lula da Silva said the coup that removed Morales was evidence of “an economic elite in Latin America that did not know how to share democracy with poor people.”

Argentina’s Fernandez said a coup had been carried out “by the joint actions of violent civilians, police personnel who confined themselves to their barracks, and the passivity of the army.”

On Monday, the Russian government, also an ally of Morales, said violent action by the opposition had forced Morales out, while UN secretary general Antonio Guterres called for “restraint” from all sides."    (AFP)





The Bolivian Coup Is Not a Coup—Because US Wanted It to Happen

View this email in your browser 

FAIR

The Bolivian Coup Is Not a Coup—Because US Wanted It to Happen

                     

by Alan MacLeod

NYT: Bolivian Leader Evo Morales Steps Down

When the military forces the elected president to "step down" (New York Times11/10/19), there's a four-letter word for that.

Army generals appearing on television to demand the resignation and arrest of an elected civilian head of state seems like a textbook example of a coup. And yet that is certainly not how corporate media are presenting the weekend’s events in Bolivia.

No establishment outlet framed the action as a coup; instead, President Evo Morales “resigned” (ABC News11/10/19), amid widespread “protests” (CBS News11/10/19) from an “infuriated population” (New York Times11/10/19) angry at the “election fraud” (Fox News11/10/19) of the “full-blown dictatorship” (Miami Herald11/9/19). When the word “coup” is used at all, it comes only as an accusation from Morales or another official from his government, which corporate media have been demonizing since his election in 2006 (FAIR.org5/6/098/1/124/11/19).

The New York Times (11/10/19did not hide its approval at events, presenting Morales as a power-hungry despot who had finally “lost his grip on power,” claiming he was “besieged by protests” and “abandoned by allies” like the security services. His authoritarian tendencies, the news article claimed, “worried critics and many supporters for years,” and allowed one source to claim that his overthrow marked “the end of tyranny” for Bolivia. With an apparent nod to balance, it did note that Morales “admitted no wrongdoing” and claimed he was a “victim of a coup.” By that point, however, the well had been thoroughly poisoned.

CNN (11/10/19) dismissed the results of the recent election, where Bolivia gave Morales another term in office, as beset with “accusations of election fraud,” presenting them as a farce where “Morales declared himself the winner.” Time’s report (11/10/19) presented the catalyst for his “resignation” as “protests” and “fraud allegations,” rather than being forced at gunpoint by the military. Meanwhile, CBS News (11/10/19) did not even include the word “allegations,” its headline reading, “Bolivian President Evo Morales Resigns After Election Fraud and Protests.”

Delegitimizing foreign elections where the “wrong” person wins, of course, is a favorite pastime of corporate media (FAIR.org5/23/18). There is a great deal of uncritical acceptance of the Organization of American States’ (OAS) opinions on elections, including in coverage of Bolivia's October vote (e.g., BBC11/10/19Vox11/10/19Voice of America11/10/19), despite the lack of evidence to back up its assertions. No mainstream outlet warned its readers that the OAS is a Cold War organization, explicitly set up to halt the spread of leftist governments. In 1962, for example, it passed an official resolution claiming that the Cuban government was “incompatible with the principles and objectives of the inter-American system.” Furthermore, the organization is bankrolled by the US government;



indeed, in justifying its continued funding, US AID argued that the OAS is a crucial tool in “promot[ing] US interests in the Western hemisphere by countering the influence of anti-US countries” like Bolivia.

CEPR: What Happened in Bolivia's 2019 Vote Count?

Corporate media ignored CEPR's finding (11/19) that "neither the OAS mission nor any other party has demonstrated that there were widespread or systematic irregularities in the elections."

In contrast, there was no coverage at all in US corporate media of the detailed new report from the independent Washington-based think tank CEPR, which claimed that the election results were “consistent” with the win totals announced. There was also scant mention of the kidnapping and torture of elected officials, the ransacking of Morales’ house, the burning of public buildings and of the indigenous Wiphala flag, all of which were widely shared on social media and would have suggested a very different interpretation of events.






Words have power. And framing an event is a powerful method of conveying legitimacy and suggesting action. “Coups,” almost by definition, cannot be supported, while “protests” generally should be. Chilean President Sebastian Piñera, a conservative US-backed billionaire, has literally declared war on over a million people demonstrating against his rule. Corporate media, however, have framed that uprising not as a protest, but rather a “riot” (e.g., NBC News, 10/20/19Reuters11/9/19Toronto Sun11/9/19). In fact, Reuters (11/8/19) described the events as Piñera responding to “vandals” and “looters.” Who would possibly oppose that?

Morales was the first indigenous president in his majority indigenous nation—one that has been ruled by a white European elite since the days of the conquistadors. While in office, his Movement Towards Socialism party has managed to reduce poverty by 42% and extreme poverty by 60%, cut unemployment in half and conduct a number of impressive public works programs. Morales saw himself as part of a decolonizing wave across Latin America, rejecting neoliberalism and nationalizing the country’s key resources, spending the proceeds on health, education and affordable food for the population.

His policies drew the great ire of the US government, Western corporations and the corporate press, who function as the ideological shock troops against leftist governments in Latin America. In the case of Venezuela, Western journalists unironically call themselves “the resistance” to the government, and describe it as their No. 1 goal to “get rid of Maduro,” all the while presenting themselves as neutral and unbiased actors.

The media message from the Bolivia case is clear: A coup is not a coup if we like the outcome."

© 2018 Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting. All rights reserved. 
You are receiving this email because you signed up for email alerts from 
Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting

Our mailing address is:
FAIRNESS & ACCURACY IN REPORTING
124 W. 30th Street, Suite 201
New York, NY 10001

FAIR's Website


Supporters of Bolivian President Evo Morales and opposition supporters clash during a protest after Morales announced his resignation on Sunday in La Paz, Bolivia, on November 11, 2019.jpeg
An aerial view of the Andina and Los Bronces mines, and of a glacier located in the Andes mountains above Santiago, Chile.jpg
Tinkuy is a traditional dance of the Andes. Men dressed like huallatas, geese native to the area, dance and run before beginning the theatrical courtship with the single women of the community. Highlands of Písac, Peru.jpg
Antonio Borges Serum, of the ethnic group 'Hunikui' from Acre, Brazil, listens to a speech during a meeting by Amazon indigenous in Puerto Maldonado, Madre de Dios province, Peru.jpg
evo-morales-anti-imperialist-school.jpg
Rubbish landfill is seen after a landslide in Alpacoma, near La Paz, Bolivia, in January..jpg
Mariposas Nocturna, A Study of Diversity and Beauty, collects fifty-one of his moth grids and will be published by Princeton University Press in September 2017.......jpg
Opponents of Morales have branded the result of the presidential elections a fraud, citing alleged irregularities in the vote count Bolivia.jpg
Aymara men hold images of Ernesto Che Guevara as they attend a ceremony in Vallegrande, Santa Cruz, Bolivia, on Oct. 9 to commemorate the 50th anniversary of Guevara's death..jpg
An Abandoned Train Rusts Around Uyuni, Bolivia.jpg
Laguna Colorada, Potosi, Bolivia, color from the pigment of red algae and other sediments such as carotene which photosynthesizes. The intensity of red changes depending on the sun and is home to three species of Andean f.jpg
photographs-che.jpgThe Bolivian government poses with the corpse of revolutionary Che Guevara, 1967.jpg
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages