Welcome back to Six on History
PS: If you like what you find on the "Six on History" blog, please share w/your contacts.
Click here for Detailed Search Help Thanks John Elfrank
VATICAN CITY — "The Vatican has expressed concerns to the Italian government about a gay rights bill working its way through Parliament, prompting cries on Tuesday of church interference from liberal politicians, gestures of gratitude from conservatives and renewed tensions in the historically complicated relationship of neighboring governments that both call Rome home.
The Vatican confirmed Tuesday morning that the Holy See’s foreign minister, Archbishop Paul Richard Gallagher, hand delivered a letter at a Vatican event last week to the Italian ambassador to the Holy See expressing deep reservations about the bill.
Advocates for the legislation say it offers overdue protections to L.G.B.T. Italians from violence and discrimination. But the Vatican said on Tuesday that the bill infringed upon guaranteed religious liberties, and risked exposing the church’s core beliefs, such as limiting the priesthood to men, or only recognizing marriage between a man and a woman, to charges of criminal discrimination.
“This poem began, as queer adulthood can begin, by reanimating the play intuited in childhood. What populates my playroom? This speaker’s lyric preoccupation is not identity but privacy, their tension between interiority and interaction, their resistance stemming not from shame but from a self-possession that, through the “quiet heft” of its observation, participates. The felt flowers are, after all, present and available in their clear container. Privacy, the poem taught me, does not preclude the world.”
—Noah Baldino
" ... I'm far from the only Black person to be disillusioned by mainstream Pride celebrations. Jaelynn Scott, executive director of the Lavender Rights Project, an organization based in Tacoma, Washington, which provides free and low-cost legal services to marginalized communities, tells Mic that Pride had issues with overwhelmingly whiteness even when she came out in the mid-90's. Because of that, Scott says, "Pride never really resonated with me growing up."
"In Mississippi, we really didn't come out. We weren't doing the rainbow flags. That wasn't the way we celebrated. We celebrated at Splash Houston and other specifically Black queer events," Scott explains. That disconnect didn't only stem from Pride consistently centering the experiences of white, cis gay men. As Scott says, "Pride didn't have meaning to me because I also didn't know the history."
Let mainstream events today tell it and Pride is brought to you by AT&T, Comcast, Walmart, and other corporations that are quick to slap a rainbow over their logo while donating to anti-LGBTQ+ politicians. The multi-day resistance against a police raid of the Stonewall Inn in New York City that launched the modern gay rights movement as we know it — including Pride — is ignored. After all, acknowledging the Stonewall Riots, and Pride's origins as a response to police brutality, certainly wouldn't help in ongoing efforts to make queerness more palatable to the mainstream.
It's hard to bury history forever, though. The Stonewall Riots took place relatively recently, in 1969. Before her death, Marsha P. Johnson, a founding member of the Gay Liberation Front who co-founded Street Transvestite Action Revolutionaries (STAR) alongside Sylvia Rivera, often spoke about her involvement in the riots. Through her legacy and the legacy of the other people who made a stand at Stonewall 50 years ago, many LGBTQ+ people of color have taken up the rallying cry that "the first Pride was a riot." It's not only a protest maxim against mainstream Pride's exclusionary practices, but it helps people of color forge connections with a celebration that can sometimes feel like it's not welcoming them.
"After I learned the history that Black trans women and Latinx trans women were the start of Pride and kept the movement going, I've reclaimed Pride for myself," Scott says. 'I think as an organization and a community ... that's what we've been doing: a constant sort of reclaiming Pride for us, and moving away from this white gay corporate pride.' ... "
" ... But Chappelle took it a step further: “I’m jealous. I’m not the only Black person that feels this way,” he said. “We Blacks, we look at the gay community and we go, ‘God damn it! Look how well that movement is going!’ And we’ve been trapped in this predicament for hundreds of years. How the f— are you making that kind of progress?”
The flaw here is that despite Chappelle claiming that he’s talking to the white community, he failed to offer any context to race and sexuality — in particular, how the Black community is grappling with acceptance.
RELATED STORIESIn The Closer, Chappelle recounts a story about having the cops called on him by a gay white man in Texas. “And this, the thing that I’m describing, is a major issue that I have with that community,” he said. “Gay people are minorities — until they need to be white again.”
Chappelle is addressing white people, but he does very little to protect the queer and transgender Black men and Black women who live in both worlds and fight both fights. At The Closer’s conclusion, Chappelle pleads for the LGBTQ community to stop “punching down” on his people. “Punching down,” in essence, is what Chappelle has been doing the last several years to a community that includes people who look like him. Even if they aren’t his intended targets, that’s nearly unforgivable to a man who says he fights for Black folks every day. ... "