Six on Israeli Annexation of West Bank and Jordan Valley: Palestine and Israel: Mapping an annexation; US seeking Israeli gesture toward Palestinians to offset annexation; Burying the Nakba: How Israel systematically hides evidence of 1948 expulsion

4 views
Skip to first unread message

philip panaritis

unread,
Jul 1, 2020, 2:28:01 PM7/1/20
to Six on History
If you like what you find on the "Six on History" blog, please share w/your contacts.                                                                                                
Here is the link to join: https://groups.google.com/d/forum/six-on-history                                           

And please don't forget to check out the pertinent images attached to every post                                 

johnelfrankdana_new - six-on-history-help 

 
                                                                                                               
How to Search past posts/articles by topic or issue: Click here    h/t to John Elfrank-Dana   



Six on Israeli Annexation of West Bank and Jordan Valley: Palestine and Israel: Mapping an annexation; US seeking Israeli gesture toward Palestinians to offset annexation; Burying the Nakba: How Israel systematically hides evidence of 1948 expulsion of Arabs; If Israel goes through with West Bank annexation, everyone loses; As Netanyahu Annexes the West Bank, Where Are the Democrats?; Israel undeterred by international opposition to annexation




Palestine and Israel: Mapping an annexation

What will the maps of Palestine and Israel look like if Israel illegally annexes the Jordan Valley on July 1?


"The current map of Palestine is often described as resembling "Swiss cheese". Over the past century it has been carved up, walled-in and filled with hundreds of illegal Israeli settlements and military checkpoints.

Now, in the latest round of Israel's ongoing occupation and policy of land-grabs this map could become even more disjointed. On July 1, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is expected to announce Israel's annexation of the Jordan Valley and northern Dead Sea.

Annexation is a term used when a state unilaterally incorporates another territory within its borders. Annexing the Jordan Valley would mean that Israel would officially consider it part of the state of Israel.

"International law is very clear: annexation and territorial conquest are forbidden by the Charter of the United Nations," said Michael Lynk, the UN independent expert on human rights in the Palestinian territories.

To understand what annexation will look like on the ground and how we got here, Al Jazeera has compiled a collection of historic and present-day maps for you to explore."




US seeking Israeli gesture toward Palestinians to offset annexation

"The Trump administration is reportedly pushing Israel to offer the Palestinians some sort of compensation in exchange for the unilateral annexation of some of the West Bank land they want for their future state.

Among the ideas is transferring an area to the Palestinians where they can build without limits, or redefining some Area C lands, where Israel maintains full control, as Area B, where Palestinians have civil control, Channel 12 reported Tuesday.

Meanwhile, the Kan public broadcaster reported that Israeli officials have passed along to the White House a slightly edited version of the Trump peace plan’s conceptual map that better connects a group of at least 15 isolated settlements to the rest of the West Bank territory the proposal envisions Israel annexing.


While the plan sees these communities being transformed into enclaves surrounded by the future Palestinian state, the report said that the edited map drawn up by the Israeli team would allow for the annexation of additional land surrounding those settlements so that they do not remain enclaves. In exchange, the Israeli side redrew the conceptual map to give to the Palestinians land in the Judaean Desert that Israel views as less integral."

US seeking Israeli gesture toward Palestinians to offset annexation — TV report






Gideon Levy: Burying the Nakba: How Israel systematically hides evidence of 1948 expulsion of Arabs

"Since the start of the last decade, Defense Ministry teams have been scouring Israel’s archives and removing historic documents. But it’s not just papers relating to Israel’s nuclear project or to the country’s foreign relations that are being transferred to vaults: Hundreds of documents have been concealed as part of a systematic effort to hide evidence of the Nakba.

The phenomenon was first detected by the Akevot Institute for Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Research. According to a report drawn up by the institute, the operation is being spearheaded by Malmab, the Defense Ministry’s secretive security department (the name is a Hebrew acronym for “director of security of the defense establishment”), whose activities and budget are classified. The report asserts that Malmab removed historical documentation illegally and with no authority, and at least in some cases has sealed documents that had previously been cleared for publication by the military censor. Some of the documents that were placed in vaults had already been published.
An investigative report by Haaretz found that Malmab has concealed testimony from IDF generals about the killing of civilians and the demolition of villages, as well as documentation of the expulsion of Bedouin during the first decade of statehood. Conversations conducted by Haaretz with directors of public and private archives alike revealed that staff of the security department had treated the archives as their property, in some cases threatening the directors themselves.

Yehiel Horev, who headed Malmab for two decades, until 2007, acknowledged to Haaretz that he launched the project, which is still ongoing. He maintains that it makes sense to conceal the events of 1948, because uncovering them could generate unrest among the country’s Arab population. Asked what the point is of removing documents that have already been published, he explained that the objective is to undermine the credibility of studies about the history of the refugee problem. In Horev’s view, an allegation made by a researcher that's backed up by an original document is not the same as an allegation that cannot be proved or refuted."


If Israel goes through with West Bank annexation, everyone loses

"If all goes well, or wrong — it depends on where you stand — then on July 1, just a few days away, a most dramatic event will occur in the Middle East: Israel, perhaps with the blessing of the Trump administration, will officially annex 30 percent of the West Bank. For those of us who still believe that Israelis and Palestinians can live in peace and prosperity next to each other in their own respective states, this move is nothing less than a death blow to the two-state solution.

To make things worse, Israel is pursuing this Earth-shattering move without any serious debate, because we now are struggling with the health and economic damages of the COVID-19 crisis.

Looking back at the scores of op-eds I have written for the Herald over the past 20 years, in many of them I have advocated the two-state solution, warning against any moves that might doom Israel to become one, bi-national state.

Each time, I brought up a different argument to reinforce my case. Once I wrote that if Israel annexed the West Bank, there would be the same number of Arabs and Jews between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. In that case, if there was “ one person, one vote,” Israel would lose its Jewish character. If not, then it loses its democracy, and becomes an apartheid state.

Then came the security argument of having to send IDF soldiers to patrol the alleys of the vicious Kasbah in Nablus again, augmented by threats of the collapse of peace with Jordan and the deterioration of relations with the Arab states, which had just warmed up toward Israel.

This was followed by the economic reasoning of why annexation was crazy. Going to Hadassah Hospital in Jerusalem frequently and realizing the burden of the overstretched public-health system, I wondered how it would look having to cater for the needs of 2 million more Palestinians from the West Bank.

And I continue to caution against the damage annexation might cause to Israel’s image around the world as a liberal democracy and to our country’s U.S. support, which has always been bipartisan.

Still, much to my horror, my government nevertheless is going through with it on July 1.

Retired generals are warning against the move’s security ramifications, calling it “A Disaster in the Making.” One hundred leading jurists are predicting that it would put Israel in a dire spot in the arena of international law. The European Union is threatening Israel with sanctionsKing Abdullah of Jordan and leaders of the Gulf have sounded the alarm. In the United States, presidential candidate Joe Biden, as well as staunch supporters of Israel like Democratic Sens. Chuck Schumer, Bob Menendez and Ben Cardin appealed to Israel not to annex.

And still, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, mesmerized by the Trump deal that even its architect, Jared Kushner, has second thoughts about, is moving ahead with this hazardous enterprise.

Being a sworn optimist, I can’t just resign myself to the fact that the Zionist dream that I inherited from my parents — to live in a Jewish and democratic state in the land of Israel — is going to be crushed next week just like that."






As Netanyahu Annexes the West Bank, Where Are the Democrats?

The early moves from Biden have been disappointing.

"T
omorrow, July 1, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is expected to move forward with his campaign promise to annex significant sections of West Bank territory. As of this writing, the full extent of Netanyahu’s plan is not known, but he is expected to annex the fertile Jordan Valley as well as several large settlement blocs. Annexation also comprises parts of Donald Trump’s so-called Deal of the Century, which calls for Israel annexing over 30 percent of the West Bank.

Netanyahu’s motives are opaque. As Israeli analyst Akiva Eldar observes, previous Israeli prime ministers have adopted policies of “quiet, creeping annexation,” while Netanyahu’s is already loud and imperious. The Israeli prime minister is also looking for Trump’s approval, which may explain the rush. Gains must be consolidated now before there is a change in American administrations and, possibly, American policy.

So where are the Democrats on this issue? The question is important not only because unilateral annexation will cement “a vision of a 21st century apartheid,” as a UN council of human rights experts stated recently, but also because the Democratic response, particularly from presumptive presidential candidate Joe Biden, could offer a sense of what the party’s foreign policy platform will be."





 Israel undeterred by international opposition to annexation
"JERUSALEM

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appears determined to carry out his pledge to begin annexing parts of the occupied West Bank, possibly as soon as Wednesday.

His vision of redrawing the map of the Holy Land, in line with President Donald Trump’s Mideast plan, has been welcomed by Israel’s religious and nationalist right wing and condemned by the Palestinians and the international community.

But with opponents offering little more than condemnations, there seems little to prevent Netanyahu from embarking on a plan that could permanently alter the Mideast landscape."


A Palestinian man during a protest marking the 72nd anniversary of Nakba and against Israeli plan to annex parts of the occupied West Bank, in the village of Sawiya near Nablus, May 15, 2020.jpg
A protester holds a Palestinian flag during clashes with Israeli troops at a protest in the West Bank village of Bilin on Friday. The demonstration marks the 12th anniversary of a campaign against the Israeli barrier..jpg
Aida Boys School, Bethlehem, West Bank.jpeg
An Israeli flag flies near the minaret of a mosque at an Israeli settlement in the the old city of the West Bank town of Hebron.jpg
Israel_Annexation_49578 This Monday, June 29, 2020 photo shows the Israeli settlement of Maale Adumim, in the West Bank..jpg
People stage a protest in Brussels against Israel's plan to annex parts of the Jordan Valley and against illegal Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank.jpg
As Israel turns 70, many young American Jews turn away.html
whose_terrorism.pdf
‘It’s a war crime’ Thousands rally in Tel Aviv against Netanyahu annexation bid Israel.jpg
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel had spoken with Mr. Pompeo before the attack and seemed to hint at something hours before the strike. Iran.jpg
Ariel University, located in a West Bank settlement, has 15,000 full-time students and is growing quickly.jpg
Christian worshipers light candles inside the Church of the Nativity in the West Bank city of Bethlehem.jpg
Flames are seen during a raid by Israeli forces on a house in which Palestinian Hamas fighter Mohammad al-Fakih was hiding out in the West Bank village of Surif, near Hebron.jpg
Blind and visually impaired Palestinian students attend a class, where they are taught English through song and music, at a school in the West Bank city of Hebron Wednesday.jpg
Palestinian children hold onto a pillar symbolizing the Kaaba as they learn about the Muslim idea of the Hajj or the 'pilgrimage' to Mecca, in a school in the West Bank city of Hebron,..jpg
Blind and visually impaired Palestinian students attend a class, where they are taught English through song and music, at a school in the West Bank city of Hebron Wednesday.jpg
Aida Boys School, Bethlehem, West Bank.jpeg
A Palestinian protester uses a sling to hurl stones towards Israeli troops during clashes in the West Bank village of Tuqu near Bethlehem.jpg
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages