protocol SIRI and space in stop id

Cédric MONJAL

unread,

Jan 10, 2020, 8:45:52 AM1/10/20

to SIRI Developers

Hello,

I have a question which is simple so the reponse should be very complex and i don't find the result on the web.

My internet service provider says me my stops identifiants which containt space can't be find with their requests with the SIRI protocol.

Is it true ?

My SAE provider says me it's possible so is it depreciate by SIRI protocol ?

thanks

Christophe Duquesne

unread,

Jan 10, 2020, 9:50:25 AM1/10/20

to SIRI Developers

Hello Cédric

When a Stop Database registry is not available (at national level, like in UK for NAPTAN, or at regional level as in Ile-de-France), SIRI offers a StopDiscovery service: this Service is not mandatory, but quite often available. Another way to go can be to have a NeTEx data set to get all the required informations about Stops. Anyway it is a non sense to develop a SIRI service (especially Stop Monitoring) if Stop IDs are not shared somewhere.

Cordialement

Christophe

Cédric MONJAL

unread,

Jan 13, 2020, 4:50:22 AM1/13/20

to SIRI Developers

Bonjour Christophe,

merci de prendre du temps pour moi. Mes identifiants d'arrêts sont bien partagés, mais mon prestataire internet ne fait aucune demande en mode requêtes sur ma base de données partagées sur les identifiants comportant des espaces.

Il me dit le protocole SIRI me l'interdit.

As tu de la doc sur laquelle je peux m'appuyer ?

Cdt

Le vendredi 10 janvier 2020 14:45:52 UTC+1, Cédric MONJAL a écrit :

Reply all

Reply to author

Forward