[SindhTalk] Sindhis 'n Panahgeers: Is Rapproachment Possible? "NO," says Sindh!

2 views
Skip to first unread message

Ahmed Makhdoom

unread,
Aug 21, 2011, 11:53:16 AM8/21/11
to wsc-n...@yahoogroups.com, sind...@yahoogroups.com, jeay_...@yahoogroups.com, worldsi...@yahoogroups.com, Sindh...@yahoogroups.com, sindhi-baloch...@yahoogroups.com, Hyderab...@yahoogroups.com, sindh...@yahoogroups.com, Sindhiat Sindhiat, sind...@ymail.com, indus_...@yahoo.com, baloc...@yahoogroups.com, stpp...@yahoo.com, SindhM...@gmail.com, ser...@yahoogroups.com, sind...@yahoogroups.com, jeay sindh students fedration, sindh...@yahoogroups.com, sind...@yahoogroups.com, Sindhi Sangat UK, Secular...@yahoogroups.com, baloc...@yahoogroups.com, Sindh Today, Sindh National Council, educat...@yahoo.com, social...@yahoogroups.com, Sindhi Sangat UK, Law-Justice...@yahoogroups.com, Info...@yahoo.co.uk, mks...@gmail.com, Hyder Junejo, sindh...@gmail.com, indus_...@yahoo.com, stpp...@yahoo.com, mcr_aw...@yahoo.com, kawi...@yahoo.com, kawis...@yahoo.com, ib...@hyd.wol.net.pk, awamia...@yahoo.com, daily_...@hotmail.com, sas...@hotmail.com, sapac...@gmail.com, sana_...@yahoo.com, hrc...@live.com, uroo...@thenews.com.pk, sob...@yahoo.com, shagird...@gmail.com, in...@sindhisangat.com, dail...@khi.wol.net.pk, dail...@cyber.net.pk, in...@gpc.com, awam...@yahoo.com, ai...@sindhtelegraph.com, knewsul...@gmail.com, Baluch Sarmachar, con...@sindhishaan.com, in...@sahkar.org.pk, sindhise...@yahoo.com, WS...@worldsindhi.org, wesi...@live.com, info...@gmail.com, nisar...@yahoo.com, maz...@me.com, educat...@googlegroups.com, "Mohammad Kha...@yahoo.com, pressp...@googlegroups.com
 

My humble response to this article in Daily "Dawn”

http://www.dawn.com/2011/08/21/rapprochement-is-possible.html

 

سانئِيَمِ! سَدائِين ڪَرِين، مَٿي سِنڌُ سُڪارَ دوستَ! مِٺا دِلدارَ، عالَمُ سَڀِ آبادِ ڪَرِين؍

(شاھُ ڀٽائيؒ)

 “Oh Lord! May Thee Bless my Sindh with bounties in abundance,

Oh My Friend, my Beloved! Glorify Universe all with Thine exuberance.”

(Shah Bhittai: Translated by Ahmed Makhdoom)

 

مانوارا  سُنھڻان مِٺِڙا ساٸين؍

خوش ھجو شال سسداٸين؍

ٻَٻُرَن کان ٿا بيرَ گهُرو، نانگَن کان ٿا خيرَ گهُرو،

 

Rapprochment between Sindhis and Panaahgeers? Rubbish! Not possible at all! They continue with the policies of encroachment and enforcement – what rapprochement? Nonsense! Remember the story of a dog with a twisted tail? I have written this story here over and over again. I need not write it, any more!

 

Sir, 65 years have gone by since the Panaahgeers gate-crashed into peaceful, docile and naive Sindh. They came seeking refuge, they saw, they occupied and they became owners of that great and gregarious land, we call, ‘SINDH.’

 

Sir, 65 years – did they embrace your culture? Did they accept your language? Did they follow the way of life of 7,000 to 10,000 years old civilised people of Sindh?  Did they revere the hands that fed them? Did they thank the souls that sheltered them? Did they sing the songs of love, peace, harmony, sacrifice, humility and patriotism as taught by that greatest Sage, Sufi and Saint of Sindh, Shah Abdul Latif Bhittai?

 

Not at all! The answer to all these questions is resounding, “NO!” For 65 years the tail has remained twisted! Another 100 years, it will still be twisted! But, by that time Sindh will be in pieces, Sind will not remain as ‘Sindh,’ the way it has always been. She will be dead and gone! Mother of all Mothers will be exterminated forever and forever!

 

Sindh and Sindhis have paid a very hefty price for sticking up to their ideals and helping those wretched and miserable beings who came looking for bread and butter, shelter and sustenance. Thee Panaahgeers got more than what they have bargained for! And, the children of gregarious Mother Sindh, lost ALL that they had protected and preserved, emulated and embraced, owned and possessed for centuries.

 

This Article is nothing more than an apologetic statement. It is naive to think of something that is not at all possible! And, naivety and gullibility never pays!

 

ڪُڇان تَہ ڪافَرُ ٿيان؍ ماٺ ڪيان تَہ مُشرِقُ؍

رِڍُن آڏو رباب وڄائيندي ورهيه ٿيا؍

واڪا ڪرڻ مون وس ٻڌڻ ڪم ٻروچ جو

شالَ سِنڌڙِي تُنھِنجا ٻَچڙا جيٸن؍

خادم دٸاگوُ احمد مخدوم؍ Ahmed Makhdoom/Malaysia 22.08.2011

Long Live Sindh! Long Live Sindhyata! Long Live Sindhi Nation

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
-^--------------------------------------------------------------

METTA TONIC - THE MOTHER OF ALL TONICS
Nutritional Energy Drink | Herbal Concentrate
Nourish Strengthens Revitalizes

http://web.sindhhealth.com/Home/metta-tonic

-^--------------------------------------------------------------

Selected postings from sind...@yahoogroups.com ("SindhTalk")
would be published on http://talk.sindh.ws. By posting on
"SindhTalk", unless specifically requested, you allow moderator
to post your contribution / articles, whole or in part, on the
said web site / blog.

-^--------------------------------------------------------------
.

__,_._,___

Ameeri Baloch

unread,
Oct 21, 2011, 2:24:54 PM10/21/11
to sind...@yahoogroups.com
 

Dear Saaeen: I forward your valuable article to balochi_culture forum.
Ameeri

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
-^--------------------------------------------------------------

METTA TONIC - THE MOTHER OF ALL TONICS
Nutritional Energy Drink | Herbal Concentrate
Nourish Strengthens Revitalizes

http://web.sindhhealth.com/Home/metta-tonic

-^--------------------------------------------------------------

Selected postings from sind...@yahoogroups.com ("SindhTalk")
would be published on http://talk.sindh.ws. By posting on
"SindhTalk", unless specifically requested, you allow moderator
to post your contribution / articles, whole or in part, on the
said web site / blog.

-^--------------------------------------------------------------
.

__,_._,___
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages