Tucker Carlson just delivered one of the most seismic media moments in the last 77 years of U.S.–Israel politics.

[Sid Shniad]

The Anti-Zionist                                                                                                                             December 12, 2025

Tucker Carlson just delivered one of the most seismic media moments in the last 77 years of U.S.–Israel politics.

I’m saying this purely as media analysis, not political endorsement. To put it mildly, I do not align with Tucker Carlson's politics in any way, shape or form.

But what happened on his show with UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese was a historic break in the propaganda regime that has governed American discourse on Israel for generations.

Tucker detonated the pro-Israel lobby’s greatest weapon: narrative control

For nearly eight decades, the pro-Israel lobby has enforced a rigid formula:
unconditional support,
bipartisan obedience,
and brutal punishment for anyone who names Israel’s crimes.

Tucker spent the first 50 minutes explaining exactly how that machinery works:
the censorship,
the smears,
the political fear,
the media capture,
the systematic silencing of truth.

He said out loud what presidents, senators, and editors have whispered privately for decades.

Then he brought out Francesca Albanese — and gave her full legitimacy
Not a fringe critic.
Not a shock jock guest.

But the UN Special Rapporteur: the highest-status human rights voice on Palestine, and allowed her to calmly detail:
unlawful occupation,
war crimes,
deliberate targeting of civilians,
genocide,
and the coordinated international effort to silence her.

Tucker framed her as a persecuted truth-teller, sanctioned and smeared because her findings threaten powerful interests.

This is the nightmare scenario the lobby has spent generations trying to prevent.

He didn’t just challenge support for Israel — he dismantled its ideological pillars

Tucker directly attacked the foundations that have anchored U.S. support for Israel since 1948:
The “moral beacon” mythology
The neocon narrative of shared values
The theological claims of Christian Zionism
The idea that supporting Israel is patriotic, necessary, or righteous

He replaced all of it with two devastating frames:
→ International law (via Albanese)
→ “America First” national interest (via his own base)

Together, these form the first coherent, politically viable right-wing critique of Israel in modern American history.

He created a new permission structure for the conservative base who tune into his show religiously
For decades, conservatives were told that questioning Israel was:
forbidden,
immoral,
un-Christian,
and unpatriotic.

That era is over.
Tucker just legitimised:
questioning the alliance,
opposing military aid,
calling out war crimes,
and rejecting the neocon consensus.

He gave his audience, millions of them, a framework that is:
mainstream,
legal,
moral,
and aligned with their worldview.
That cannot be walked back.

And yes: this was a death knell
A propaganda regime that has relied on total control cannot survive fracture.

The bipartisan spell has held for 77 years
because both parties enforced it.

Last night, one of the most influential right-wing media figures did what no Republican, no Democrat, and no mainstream journalist has ever dared to do:
He cracked the consensus.
He broke the silence.
He told the truth plainly.
And he handed the American right a legitimate pathway out of the pro-Israel orbit.

That is a tectonic shift.
And once the ground moves like this —
it does not move back.

-----

If you want the analysis institutions won’t touch and the media won’t print, you can now support my work on Patreon.

Patreon → https://www.patreon.com/c/TheAnti_Zionist

-----