Hi Daryl,
One of the biggest reasons igo is becoming popular around the world is
not only the universal pieces, but also the simplicity of the rules.
"Put a stone anywhere on the board, if it's surrounded it's captured,
and whoever surrounds the majority of the board wins" is, basically,
all you need to know about igo's rules in order to play the game.
With shogi, however, you have to learn and memorize 10 different
movement types for each of the 8 pieces, as well as learn to recognize
different types of images, whether they're kanji or pictures. It also
takes a bit more to understand the basics of shogi than it does with
igo.
One of the reasons shogi does not do well outside of Japan is the wide
variety of similar games. The West has chess, China has xiangqi,
Thailand has Makruk, Korea has Janggi, etc. To players of these
games, shogi is "just another chess type." Because of this, they tend
to not take shogi very seriously.
One last reason that igo is more popular than shogi is that igo has
national associations devoted to constantly popularizing the game. I
know Europe has the FESA for shogi, but as has been explained in this
line of messages, the USSF doesn't do much popularization. If you
look at the American Go Association, you see that they constantly make
efforts to go to various types of cultural and gaming events to
introduce new players to the game. They also have a national database
of igo players, so that you can simply look up online to see if there
are any igo players near you. Not to mention they release a
newsletter very often, and they actively participate in helping
beginning igo clubs.
These are all things I think the USSF should be doing if we plan to
make shogi more popular in the US.
Thanks,
Eric De Las Casas
On Dec 1, 5:58 pm, Daryl Lakes <
dla...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> As a new Shogi player, I agree that it would be nice to see Shogi popularity increased. What I have found is that in Japan, Shogi is more popular then Go. Outside of Japan, Go is fairly popular, but shogi is nearly unheard of. If you use Google (or Youtube for videos etc) you will find a massive amount of Go links in English but finding shogi links is like finding a needle in a haystack. I am not sure why this is. I would think that western chess players at least would be attracted to Shogi. Why does Go do well outside of Japan but not Shogi? One guess I might offer is that a Go set has 'universal' pieces and board. Small round dots are easy to understand. In Shogi, the pieces are very intimidating to a non Japanese person. The only reason I became interested is I (by accident) stumbled upon a video series on Youtube (Hidechi) and saw it was possible to use westernized pieces. I can not say that letting people know that it is possible to play Shogi with
> less intimidating pieces would help promote, but it did in my case.
>
> --- On Tue, 12/1/09, Eric De Las Casas <
edel...@gmail.com> wrote: