few comments

[Franck Tanoh]

Good job guys,

Few notes after a quick glance:
- you need a 'submitted by' in case the person who submitted it is
not the creator of the shim.
- submitted shim should have a minimum info. I think the description
is a key point and should be mandatory.
- the class you assign a shim service to when you are uploading it
doesn't seem to appear anywhere. i would love to search by class.
- 'expand all/hide all' under category doesn't seem to do anything.
- the categories list needs some review: things like net or metadata
don't make too much sense.

Franck

--
"Science knows no country, because knowledge belongs to humanity, and
is the torch which illuminates the world." - Louis Pasteur

[Mannie Tags]

Hello,

Thank you for the feedback, it is greatly appreciated.

> Good job guys,
>
> Few notes after a quick glance:
> - you need a 'submitted by' in case the person who submitted it is
> not the creator of the shim.

Note taken; we will look into the ownership aspect of shims in more
detail.

> - submitted shim should have a minimum info. I think the description
> is a key point and should be mandatory.

Apart from the description, is there any other information you deem
vital and should be mandatory?

> - the class you assign a shim service to when you are uploading it
> doesn't seem to appear anywhere. i would love to search by class.

In order of preference, would you be able to provide us with a list of
the fields by which you prefer to browse shims?

> - 'expand all/hide all' under category doesn't seem to do anything.

The 'expand all/hide all' links should, effectively, expand or
collapse the category hierarchy; since there are not sub-categories,
nothing appears to be happening. I suppose I should have mentioned
this somewhere at an earlier point in time; my apologies.

> - the categories list needs some review: things like net or metadata
> don't make too much sense.

I agree, some categories don't make much sense at all. With your
help, we would like to use more appropriate and meaningful categories
in the library. Your input on which categories (and/or sub-
categories) you consider appropriate would be greatly appreciated.
Just a thought; would some of the classes (you assign to shim services
at upload) best serve as categories or classes?

> Franck

Regards,
Mannie