The policy of divide and rule among followers of faiths and ethnic groups is a British policy
smm...@gmail.com
Today i would like to share one reply from Hujjatul islam sayyid
mohamad moosvi...on the matter of the sermons of Martyr Ayatullah
Murtada Mutahhari..
Hujjatul islam sayyid mohamad moosvi.
Question ........
Question: Assalamun Alaykum Few days ago I did read the Sermons of
Martyr Ayatullah Murtada Mutahhari called 'Ashura - Misrepresentations
and Distortions. And I shocked that Hadhrat Qasim was not married in
Karbala and other stories fabricated about the Karbala. So from where I
can get authentic narrations/story of Karbala? Because in India and
Pakistan these types of stories are very common in Majlisis. And tell
me what our scholars are doing to prevent this? Because if whatever
written in the sermons of Martyr Ayatullah Murtada Mutahhari than these
things are very big sins. I m confused now please immidiately guide me
to authentic book or source about the Karbala
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Answer: Assalamu alaikum wr wb,
Different opinions about hisorical events should not make us confused.
Many historians say that Hadhrat Qasim got married in Karbala as it is
recited in Majlises, so, we do not take one scholar's statement for
granted like Quran or Ma'sooms statements. Many books contain details
of the tragedy of Karbala in cluding Bihar al Anwar by Majlisi, Maqtal
Abi Makhnaf, Maqtal al-Khawarizmi, Al-Lohoof by Ibn Taawoos and many
other books.
We should not make such matters (like the marriage of Hadhrat Qasim) as
an issue causing dispute among Mo'mineen. We should focus on mourning
the tragedy, getting its great aims and teaching ourselves and others
the great lessons of self purification and justice. Even if one can
prove that a certain incident did not happen in Karbala, we should
always have the possibilty of other scholars reaching to a different
result, so, we do not make it an issue of dispute, unless it carries an
insult to our respected leaders and our high values of Islam.
Wassalamu alaikum wr wb Mohammad al-Musawi
http://www.themaliks.co.uk/wabil/asp/viewQuestion.asp?faq=2304
I hope people will understand whjat he said? and who are those who
create doubts in minds of momineen and create dispute among us..
Also visit video lecture of Hujjatul islam sayyid mohamad moosvi. on
the same issue.....
Azadari By Hujjatul islam sayyid mohamad moosvi
http://www.youtube.com/group/shiastrength
Supreme Leader of the Islamic Revolution Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei
also said...The policy of divide and rule among followers of faiths and
ethnic groups is a British policy and they are very expert in n
pursuing that policy and they have taught the Americans how to sow the
seeds of discord among muslims..
wassalam
Yasmin Qasim
qasim,and now adays it has become a common practice to say that it is a
bidat to do the mendhi and other rituals regarding shahzada qasim also known
as Abdullah inbe hassan. some moulana say that the nikah took place just to
respeect the wasiyat of imam Hasan.not only in india pakistan but when i
visited karbala several times and happened to go to the hujra of of qasim
ibne Hasan in the khaima gah each time i saw that newly wed couples come
there for the blessing on enquiring they said that they did manat there .the
place was full of henna[mendi]on the walls and every where and lots of
flowers and sweets were brought to pay tribute to shahzada qasim. if it is
exergerated in india and pakistan how about it taking place right there in
karbala IF THERE IS NO FACT TO IT...this is my question......darood bar
Mohammad wa AlleyMhoammed!!......Y qasim...austin texas...usa