a little late to this conversation, but I wanted to add that for anyone who has been eyeing the Adventure Series or La Ruta Loca, mixed terrain permanent routes are an excellent way to get practice with riding dirt on brevets.
There is a huge range of difficulty levels of the various bay area mixed terrain perms you can do, which will help you determine what tire size you want to use. Doing perm routes with dirt sections will also help you set expectations for yourself as to how long these routes will take you, and whether you and your bike are prepared for mixed terrain brevets.
In the Search bar at the top of the RUSA website, click the dropdown for Permanent Routes, then on the search page there is a check box for "Contains unpaved sections".
Possibly one of the easier mixed terrain perms in terms of technical sections is Mount Tam to Marshall, in which you ride up Old Railroad Grade to the top of Mount Tam, then eventually ride out to Marshall. There are no technical high-speed descents as the descent down Tam is on Ridgecrest Boulevard.
Possibly the hardest 200k mixed terrain perm is Peninsula Open Space Tour which may be harder than Marin Mountains 200k. more info here:
https://ridebike.org/rusa/perm/
You can look at the results for various perms on the RUSA results page to see how long it has taken people to do them, to get a sense of how long it might take you.
One final thing to note is that there are several factors that make bikes better or worse for mixed terrain riding, and tire size is only one of these factors.
- Dirt climbs can be steeper than paved ones, so it's helpful to have a wider gear range.
- Dirt descents can be steeper too, so it's also nice to make sure that you have really effective brakes that are working properly.
- Being able to carry more water or a little extra food can be helpful since these routes often have fewer controls in urban areas--you may only have access to a poorly-stocked rural convenience store with limited resupply options. Route research prior to the ride is key here.
- Steel frames can be better for long mixed terrain rides for their durability and comfort, but as with all these factors, it's highly personal and you should experiment to find out what works best for you.
All this said, mixed terrain brevets and perms are suuuuper fun and I hope everyone gets to experience the unique sense of freedom one has when riding them! If you are Adventure Series-curious, one great way to learn is to volunteer for one. Observe the riders' gear, and cheer them on :)
Happy cycling,
Juliayn