The following commentary is reprinted with permission from:
THE MT VOID
01/03/25 -- Vol. 43, No. 27, Whole Number 2361
- - - - - - - - - -
OMNI LOOP (2024) [with SPOILERS]
Film review by Mark R. Leeper and
Evelyn C. Leeper:
We meet Zoya in the hospital,
where the doctor is explaining that she has a black hole insideher which is slowly growing and will kill her in about a week. (Plot hole #1: Why won't it keep growing and absorb the wholeEarth?)But Zoya has some magic pills, which when she takes on, she jumpsback to a week earlier. (Plot hole #2: This reeks of "Star Trek"and "tech-tech-tech".) So the basic plot is GROUNDHOG DAY, butwith a week instead of a day. (It's *not* a plot hole inGROUNDHOG DAY, because that is a fantasy, not science fiction.)Zoya finds herself wishing she had made different decisions in herlife and wanting to extend the range of the pills so that she cango back further. She happens to (literally) run into Paula, whois working on questions of time at the local community college(really?) under Zoya's old professor (really?) and they steal thenanoscopic man that was created when the professor was working onshrinking people (really?). (This is like THE INCREDIBLESHRINKING MAN ... well, sort of.)Plot hole #3: The pills regenerate, so they never get used up. Actually, it's not clear why there is more than one pill--Zoyasays taking multiple pills doesn't make a difference.So they are working to solve the problem of how to increase thetime span. Plot hole #4: Paula claims they have all the time inthe world, but after a week of work, Paula "resets", so Zoya hasto re-convince her and also bring her up to speed each time. Plothole #5: How do they keep all the knowledge--which seems toinvolve complex equations and diagrams filling a notebook--thatthey have gained during reset? How does the notebook with theirwork stay in existence? Why is the nanoman still in the lab eachtime?We eventually find out that Zoya found these pills when she wastwelve, and used them to do well in school (after she knew theanswers on a test, she would jump back to take the test again). And in fact, Zoya did not like the work of science--she liked thesolutions. She claimed her husband disparaged her work and madeher decide to become a wife and mother (and textbook writer)rather than a research scientist. But we find out that memory isnot reliable as we see the discussion and realize that he wasactually very supportive. So we also learn that basing thereasons for time travel on one's memory is a risky proposition. In spite of this, we discover that everyone wants to go back;everyone has regrets.At one point Zoya tries to find someone she had worked with beforewho turned out to be "successful", and discovers that ultimatelyhe was not satisfied, and his son did not think his father was asuccess in what mattered. The father also seems to have kept(stolen?) Zoya's work that supposedly Zoya's mother had. Plothole #6: How did he get it?Eventually, Zoya realizes that she is wishing for what the sondiscounts as unimportant, but that she has what the son sees assuccess. And that she would lose a lot of the good along with thebad if she is successful.Or as Billy Rose and Mort Dixon wrote in 1928, "If you want therainbow, you must have the rain."Paula asks Zoya what happens when she loops back, but this assumesthat that particular time line goes on even when she loops back. This clearly involves some deep discussion of the nature of time.The casting is a good example of diversity without a sledgehammer, just as John Carpenter did it forty years ago.(The title seems to refer to the constant looping Zoya is doing,and perhaps it does, but the Omni Loop is an actual part of theMiami Metromover system. However, there is no 1209 UniversityDrive, Princeton, NJ.) [-ecl]Released streaming 20 September 2024.Film Credits:<https://www.imdb.com/title/tt28150132/reference>What others are saying:<https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/omni_loop>