You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Copy link
Report message
Show original message
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to SFABC (nj) Movie Group
The following commentary is reprinted with permission from
THE MT VOID 04/17/26 -- Vol. 44, No. 42, Whole Number 2428
= = = = = = = = = =
OUTLAND (1981) (film review by Evelyn C. Leeper)
Sometimes you just watch to watch a trashy science fiction movie, which is why I watched OUTLAND. Described as HIGH NOON in space, this gets the science rather spectacularly wrong, as well as being a totally unoriginal plot. Were it not for Sean Connery and Frances Sternhagen, there wouldn't be any reason to watch this at all.
For starters, they are on Io, which the introduction says has one-sixth Earth gravity. But everyone is clearly operating in normal 1G Earth gravity. Partway through, they introduce a zero-gravity room, entirely surrounded by a 1G environment. I suppose this implies they have anti-gravity, but nothing is ever said about this, and even some of the scenes outside the base (including falling) seem to be Earth gravity. Certainly it would be easier to work in a lower-gravity environment. On the other hand, having people firing projectile weapons (or playing golf) in a non-familiar gravity would be near impossible, so the filmmakers were stuck.
Also, in the zero-gravity room, blood flows *up* rather than just hangs there.
Having projectile weapons in a station on a zero-atmosphere moon seems ill-advised, especially since the villain's "best men" don't seem to realize that shooting a hole in an outside wall is a bad idea. For that matter, in this movie (as in many others) vital tubes and connectors to the spacesuits seem very tenuously attached.
I also have a real problem with the whole idea that if he has a one-year tour of duty, and his wife doesn't like it, that's the end of the marriage. Apparently the writers never knew any military families. (Later on, it turns out that the one year on Io is apparently in addition to one year deep sleep each way. This makes no logistics sense.)
And while Sternhagen is an interesting character, this film still fails the Bechdel test. (Connery's wife and son serve no useful function in the plot. You expect that she will come back, or they will be threatened somehow, but nothing of that sort happens.)