The shared MIS raises serious concerns, as several key expenses appear to have not been accounted for. Kindly provide clarification on the following items that are not reflected in the maintenance charge calculation at the earliest:
1. FMD Bill
• Why is the JLL/Bridgestone FMD bill not reflected in the MIS?
• Given that this is a recurring expense, on what basis has it been excluded from maintenance calculations?
• If the bill is delayed by one month, why has the average of the previous two months not been considered?
2. Income Tax (₹4 Lakhs)
• Why were ₹9.8 lakhs (~₹0.5/sq. ft) collected as advance income tax in Q3, while no corresponding advance tax payments are visible in Q3 or Q4?
• Why does the current MIS reflect only ₹4 lakhs as an income tax expense?
• Why have these ₹4 lakhs not been included in the maintenance charge calculation?
3. ASD Adjustment
• ASD was already collected earlier and adjusted in subsequent months by Sobha. Kindly confirm this understanding.
• Has Sobha formally decided to waive off the ASD amount from the last quarter billing?
• If not, why has this amount not been included in the maintenance charge calculation?
4. Borewell Tax
• Has the borewell tax already been paid by Sobha?
• If not, why has this expense not been included in the maintenance charge calculation?
Given the seriousness of these discrepancies, the Association is requested to provide a detailed and transparent clarification at the earliest. Issuing maintenance charges based on incomplete or misleading financials will not be acceptable.
Regards,
Anil Ch