Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Perjury?

2 views
Skip to first unread message

amacm...@aol.com

unread,
Dec 24, 2010, 3:37:54 PM12/24/10
to
With perjury very much in the news, I would like to put forward a
hypothetical situation.

Someone makes statements against an organisation that the organisation
claims is defamatory.

The organisation decides to take this person to court for defamation.

Two of the witnesses are the female CEO of the organisation and a male
described as an "independent expert witness".

Some days before the hearing the defendant receives a phone call from
a woman, who refuses to give her name, saying that the independent
witness is not as "independent" as he might seem. He has left his
wife and is "co-habiting" with the CEO of the organisation.

During the subsequent hearing the defendant, who is representing
himself, asks the expert witness under oath if his home address, which
he has given to the court, is the only address at which he stays. He
replies "yes".

The organisation wins the case against the defendant.

This is then reported to the police, complete with the court
transcript. They decide to take no action as they say it might not
have affected the outcome of the case.

However, if the expert witness was lying under oath in the dock, would
this not amount to perjury?

Any thoughts about this?


0 new messages