From Dan Rogers, Ph.D we had:
[snip]
This is just getting silly. I can't believe that anyone would be
talking about the
so-called 'Carkhuff scales' this way. I am now convinced that you are
not trained or
experienced as a therapist and that you certainly don't have any
familiarity with the
research literature. Gad!! And a 'supplemental scoring system for the
CPI' to select
potential peer counselors? Oh, man! you have got to be kidding?
I suspect you meant to post this to alt.aliens.spandex or some similar
group.
[snip]
If indeed you teach counseling, you show either a lack of familiarity
with a huge part
of relevant literature. Or, you don't teach in an accredited program.
You did not
post from any educational institution, so I suspect that you define
teaching in your
own way.
You also need to know the difference between counseling and
psychotherapy.
I really wouldn't have responded to your post at all, except that you
are promoting a
very fuzzy sort of thinking that needs to be stopped. You are simply
wrong.
Edna (a therapist) wrote:
Dan, Thank you...
I enjoy reading your post enourmosly. I think we all answered to Brad
once before
realizing the waste of time it is. He has been posting his ignorance in
this
group for months. I wouldn't worry about him if I were you. Just ignore
him -
like the rest of us.
--
edna
Paul Berhardt wrote:
I'll be quite clear. I think that Brad is an idiot. I have tried to
give him the time of day. I have tried to argue rationally. I have read
his disjointed and strange postings and have concluded that he is
simply and idiot.
+=================================================================+
Paul Bernhardt, Grad Student in Educational Psychology at U of Utah
+=================================================================+
Then DR. Matt G. wrote:
Yeah, it is unfortunate that the responses have deteriorated to the
level
of analysis that I have seen. It appears that BRAD is a "brain stem".
best always,
Mike
la...@netcom.com
"`Anyone replying to BRAD hasn't learned from experience. We had a
little
peace and reasoned discussion while he found a new server who hasn't yet
been complained to about his incessant rambling diatribes and
harassment.
Please don't feed the monster and maybe, like his idol, Nixon, he will
fade away and die."