The Kelly paper (IPCC)

[Eric Gisin]

Here are a physicists' impressions of IPCC and climate science, in particular temp records from
tree rings.

http://bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2010/6/22/the-kelly-paper.html (below)
http://bishophill.squarespace.com/storage/kelly%20paper.pdf (14 pages)
http://climateaudit.org/2010/06/22/kellys-comments/ (McIntyre)

Jun 22, 2010
The most interesting of the attachments to Professor Hand's emails is a paper by one of his fellow
panellists, Michael Kelly, who is Professor of Electronics at Cambridge.

The paper records Professor Kelly's impressions as he reads through some CRU papers. I can't really
do justice to this paper as a short summary. For the moment, I've extracted the relevant pages from
the full download and you can just read it. I think Steve M will probably have something to say on
Kelly's work, which seems fairly frank.

The download is here.

Kelly on CRU

Update on Jun 22, 2010 by Bishop Hill
McIntyre's take on the Kelly paper is here.

[Sam]

NEWS: Experto Crede: Climate Expertise Lacking among Global Warming
Contrarians
A majority of scientists who dispute global warming lack the
climatological expertise to do so
http://links.email.scientificamerican.com/ctt?kn=29&m=35009740&r=NTM5NzIyNzc5MgS2&b=2&j=NzYzOTIwNDkS1&mt=1&rt=0