Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Adam Yoshida - Please Introduce Yourself

8 views
Skip to first unread message

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
Yo! Just on the side, I'm sorta curious about this Adam
Yoshida cat. I'm pretty new hear, so I'm not up on the
whole group culture thing and shit like that. So, AY,
if can find the time tell me a little about yourself and
your history with the group. You seem to come up a
lot in discussion.

Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

Would you not prefer to read biographies of Hitler, Stalin, Ghengis
Khan and Attila the Hun?

Eugene L Griessel eug...@dynagen.co.za

www.dynagen.co.za/eugene
SAAF Crashboat Page - www.dynagen.co.za/eugene/eug3.htm
Snake Page - www.web.netactive.co.za/~sean

Brian Allardice

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
In article <3916421...@news1.mweb.co.za>, eug...@dynagen.co.za says...

>
>Would you not prefer to read biographies of Hitler, Stalin, Ghengis
>Khan and Attila the Hun?


Why pick on Attila... he was a honey of a guy

Cheers,
dba


loki

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
"Eugene Griessel" <eug...@dynagen.co.za>

> rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:
>
> >Yo! Just on the side, I'm sorta curious about this Adam
> >Yoshida cat. I'm pretty new hear, so I'm not up on the
> >whole group culture thing and shit like that. So, AY,
> >if can find the time tell me a little about yourself and
> >your history with the group. You seem to come up a
> >lot in discussion.
>

> Would you not prefer to read biographies of Hitler, Stalin, Ghengis
> Khan and Attila the Hun?

You give Adam too much credit. He's still a baby. I think that
in his case he'll turn into a petty tyrant in his own home and no
where else.

Loki


Adam Yoshida

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
On 08 May 2000 03:43:46 GMT, rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

>Yo! Just on the side, I'm sorta curious about this Adam
>Yoshida cat. I'm pretty new hear, so I'm not up on the
>whole group culture thing and shit like that. So, AY,
>if can find the time tell me a little about yourself and
>your history with the group. You seem to come up a
>lot in discussion.

Oh, well I'm a 16 year old from Vancouver, British Columbia. In the
past I've been extremly active in this group.

My infamy comes from the fact that much of my activity in this group
came in the form of crossposted messages with rec.aviation.military
which generally turned into violent flame-wars.

Mainly I would advocate the construction of a much larger US military
but I can also recall coming out in favor of military action against
North Korea, China, Iraq, Serbia, and probably a few others (France
once, I think). My posititions and that my posts were often two pages
long, did not make me the most popular guy here.

I spend a lot more time on soc.history.what-if these days where I...
Engage in longer political flame-wars.

Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.

Adam Yoshida

"Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice, and moderation in the pursuit of Justice is no virtue"
-Barry Goldwater

loki

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
"Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote

>
> Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
> listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.

Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over. First a
development in my own life last night and now this.

This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
listening to.

Loki


Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
"loki" <lo...@inlink.com> wrote:

I, too, am stunned and have been wondering who else has access to Mr
Yoshida's machine. Perhaps Adam "to hell with soreheads, use nuclear
warheads" Yoshida is painfully crawling into adulthood?

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
lo...@inlink.com (loki) wrote in <AtCR4.3316$Xc.1...@news1.primary.net>:

>"Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote
>>
>> Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
>> listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.
>
>Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over. First a
>development in my own life last night and now this.
>
>This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
>listening to.

It seems to me that AY's "troll" status comes purely
from other posters perceptions of his youth and
his adherence to the cult of the offensive. Personally,
I think this reflects more of an intellectual
failure on the part of other participants rather
than a character flaw in Adam.

Perhaps responding with something better measured
than ad hominems and sarcasm might enrich the
discussion as well as Yoshida's world view. Having
browsed through some of his arguments, (in the
General Secretary Reagon thread) he has
demonstratable weaknesses in his analytical skills.
Still he's formulating newer ideas at an incredible
speed. A lot of folks hinge immutably to their
establish prerogatives; particularly amongst
the pacifists. In many ways, Yoshida's lucky enough
to still be in high school--college is a place
where you can easily turn your world view into
dogmatism; given rise to faulty conclusions that
rise empirically thereof.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
adamy...@home.com (Adam Yoshida) wrote in <3916d19b.1273076@news>:

>On 08 May 2000 03:43:46 GMT, rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:
>
>>Yo! Just on the side, I'm sorta curious about this Adam
>>Yoshida cat. I'm pretty new hear, so I'm not up on the
>>whole group culture thing and shit like that. So, AY,
>>if can find the time tell me a little about yourself and
>>your history with the group. You seem to come up a
>>lot in discussion.
>
>Oh, well I'm a 16 year old from Vancouver, British Columbia. In the
>past I've been extremly active in this group.
>
>My infamy comes from the fact that much of my activity in this group
>came in the form of crossposted messages with rec.aviation.military
>which generally turned into violent flame-wars.

Cross-posting is an issue finally losing momentum. In this
day and age, the rapid rate of information transfer, increased
bandwidth, and just general computer and network performance
allow a great many users to access these groups and keep
track of interesting discussions. Cross-posting, much like
spam, is an antiquated concern of an era where providers
could charge their customers by email or news posting.

On the other hand, you also present yourself in a way
that doesn't take into account your audience. Despite
the real or self-perceived assessment of your breadth
of knowledge, you do lack experience in a number of fields
that interest you. That thought, regardless of how
significant should be, will bear on the minds of many
individuals engaging you. If you're trying to argue a
point convincingly, take into account your lack of
experience and use others' to back up your perceptions.
On the flip side, do you expect someone to argue convincingly
based on their personal experiences alone? The breadth
of experience backing your point determines the strength
of your evidence.

>Mainly I would advocate the construction of a much larger US military
>but I can also recall coming out in favor of military action against
>North Korea, China, Iraq, Serbia, and probably a few others (France
>once, I think). My posititions and that my posts were often two pages

>long, did not make me the most popular guy here.

So long as you hold positions and argue for them, you're doing
your bit to enrich discussion. Take mind to keep readdressing
your positions. Not a single one of us should presume to have
a monopoly on absolute truth, and we should continue to reassess
our world view models when possible.

At this stage in my life, I look favorably upon balance of power
arguments. I feel that the United States in this century has
reached an apex that we do not want to fall from, and that we
should carefully create and maintain balances that support our
economic and political supremacy. As such, I'd disagree with
some of your proposed measures, because you fail to attribute
the means to achieve such lofty expectations as the neutralization
of the PRC by act of force. Many of your expectations are
predicated on a weak sovereignty argument, something that I'm
particularly concerned about. If you argue that America can
and should violate the sovereignty of other nations to achieve
national interest goals, then I would agree with you--the US
should pursue its goals in measured actions that make full and
proper use of the available means. However, I do not agree
we have the means (or will have the means) to enforce the solution
of American hegemony (as you propose). Nor do I believe that
America has the ability (or the interest) to enforce an international
system weakly predicated on the notion of "international law."
It is the ultimate sacrifice of national sovereignty in the name
of a flawed for legalistic world order.

I'm more interested, therefore, in setting up a balancing dyad
between--for example--China and Japan. Using two regional powers
to stabilize the system and therefore prevent excessive interference
in American interests in the region.

>I spend a lot more time on soc.history.what-if these days where I...
>Engage in longer political flame-wars.
>

>Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
>listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.

Listen to as many people as possible, then determine what
argument appeals to you and why.

Prez

loki

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
"Presley Cannady" <rev...@mit.edu> wrote

>
> It seems to me that AY's "troll" status comes purely
> from other posters perceptions of his youth and
> his adherence to the cult of the offensive. Personally,
> I think this reflects more of an intellectual
> failure on the part of other participants rather
> than a character flaw in Adam.

Um, no. Adam has freely admitted he's a troll.

> Perhaps responding with something better measured
> than ad hominems and sarcasm might enrich the
> discussion as well as Yoshida's world view. Having
> browsed through some of his arguments, (in the
> General Secretary Reagon thread) he has
> demonstratable weaknesses in his analytical skills.
> Still he's formulating newer ideas at an incredible
> speed. A lot of folks hinge immutably to their
> establish prerogatives; particularly amongst
> the pacifists. In many ways, Yoshida's lucky enough
> to still be in high school--college is a place
> where you can easily turn your world view into
> dogmatism; given rise to faulty conclusions that
> rise empirically thereof.

Which we are quite certain he will do...

Loki


Glenn Dowdy

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
loki wrote in message ...
>"Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote

>>
>> Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
>> listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.
>
>Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over. First a
>development in my own life last night and now this.
>

Congratulations! When are you due?

--
Glenn Dowdy

"You really need to urgently learn the lesson that
civilised debate demands that you recognise that
others may sincerely hold opinions contrary to your own."
Keith Willshaw


Siegenthaler

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
: Would you not prefer to read biographies of Hitler, Stalin,

Ghengis
: Khan and Attila the Hun?


Leave Attila out of this, DAMMIT!!!
--
-- -- -- --
Med vennlig hilsen,

Siegenthaler

"It is better to be violent, if there is violence in our hearts,
than to put on the cloak of non-violence to cover impotence."

Mahatma Gandhi
----------------------------------------------------------
For Online Lottery
http://www.pluslotto.com/default.asp?urlref=3300016478412


Message has been deleted

loki

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
"Glenn Dowdy" <glenn...@agilent.com> wrote

>
> Congratulations! When are you due?

<chuckle> It's not that cold...

Loki


Olivers

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
loki wrote:
>
> "Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote
> >
> > Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
> > listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.
>
> Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over. First a
> development in my own life last night and now this.
>
> This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
> listening to.
>
...in defense of the lad at whom I've cast the occasional grenade...

He has to some extent moderated a bit when it comes to inflammatory
polemics.

We have a joint and several obligation to educate and acculturate him
(since wherever he is up on the Northern rim, his educational
opportunities seem sketchy at best).

He is a Canadian, a nationality troubled by shoulder chips and
whetstones, given to wild ideas, indefensible positions, useless
inventions, tearful posturing and postwar claims of "We wuz fucked by
(insert Brits, merkins, Ottawa, assorted Duboukirs/Dubuggers? as
necessary to meet the situation)". Canadian military participation,
whatever the result, seems always followed by painful recriminations and
much self-flagellation. No wonder Adam's a bit skewed, but fortunately
he's not from Oz, where the do breed'em up right strange.


--
TMOliver - el pelon sinverguenza

"Alle kunst ist unsonst,
wenn ein Engel in das Kundloch prunst."

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
lo...@inlink.com (loki) wrote in <uLDR4.3321$Xc.1...@news1.primary.net>:

>
>Um, no. Adam has freely admitted he's a troll.

And I freely admit to being God.

>> Perhaps responding with something better measured
>> than ad hominems and sarcasm might enrich the
>> discussion as well as Yoshida's world view. Having
>> browsed through some of his arguments, (in the
>> General Secretary Reagon thread) he has
>> demonstratable weaknesses in his analytical skills.
>> Still he's formulating newer ideas at an incredible
>> speed. A lot of folks hinge immutably to their
>> establish prerogatives; particularly amongst
>> the pacifists. In many ways, Yoshida's lucky enough
>> to still be in high school--college is a place
>> where you can easily turn your world view into
>> dogmatism; given rise to faulty conclusions that
>> rise empirically thereof.
>
>Which we are quite certain he will do...

I'm speaking specifically of Adam's opposition,
who have replied from equally absolutist moral
positions. Of course, the problem lies in the fact
that we can't expect folks to write papers
supporting their positions for the sake of
newsgroup discussion.

Prez

Arved Sandstrom

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
Hey, I was in my early 20's and _still_ an exponent of strategic
nuclear warfare, not to mention bio and chemical. :-)

As is often the case, a spell of active duty in the military actually
grew me up. :-)

Arved Sandstrom

On Mon, 08 May 2000 17:22:29 GMT, eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene
Griessel) wrote:

>"loki" <lo...@inlink.com> wrote:
>
>>"Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote
>>>
>>> Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
>>> listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.
>>
>>Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over. First a
>>development in my own life last night and now this.
>>
>>This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
>>listening to.
>

Ogden Johnson III

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
On 08 May 2000 17:22:38 GMT, rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:


>It seems to me that AY's "troll" status comes purely
>from other posters perceptions of his youth and
>his adherence to the cult of the offensive. Personally,
>I think this reflects more of an intellectual
>failure on the part of other participants rather
>than a character flaw in Adam.

Before accusing people in the ng of 'an intellectual failure', I would
suggest you do a deja.com search on Adam's posts, particularly those
in sci.military.naval, and follow some of the resulting threads.

Perceptions of youth be damned. There are a number of 'youthful'
posters here who are respected - Chris Manteufel [sp certainly
mangled] for one, and he is approximately Adam's age, perhaps a tad
younger.

OJ III

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
Arve...@chebucto.ns.ca (Arved Sandstrom) wrote in
<39174e16...@news.dal.ca>:

>Hey, I was in my early 20's and _still_ an exponent of strategic
>nuclear warfare, not to mention bio and chemical. :-)
>
>As is often the case, a spell of active duty in the military actually
>grew me up. :-)

Amen to that.

Prez, MIT NROTC

loki

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
"Presley Cannady" <rev...@mit.edu> wrote

>
> And I freely admit to being God.

Fine, I'll pay as much attention to you as I do to him...

> I'm speaking specifically of Adam's opposition,
> who have replied from equally absolutist moral
> positions. Of course, the problem lies in the fact
> that we can't expect folks to write papers
> supporting their positions for the sake of
> newsgroup discussion.

Yep. I come here for enjoyment, not to write
dissertations.

Loki


loki

unread,
May 8, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/8/00
to
This child (and I'm a grandmother so to me this *is* a child)
has too much time on his hands.

*plonk*

Loki

"Presley Cannady" <rev...@mit.edu> wrote in message
news:8F2ED2847re...@18.247.2.125...
> o...@x-press.net (Ogden Johnson III) wrote in
> <p2kehscrm4v3adbit...@4ax.com>:


> >
> >Before accusing people in the ng of 'an intellectual failure', I would
> >suggest you do a deja.com search on Adam's posts, particularly those
> >in sci.military.naval, and follow some of the resulting threads.
>

> I've been doing that all night. I've seen Adam's posts. They're
> controversial, but the replies fall into two clear categories:
> legitimate responses and ad hominems. The reason I specify
> this clear division is that it you can legitimately use
> ad hominem to raise questions about Adam's analytical abilities.
> However, in general I see ad hominems followed by equally
> non-contributive non-arguments. Particularly in the Adam-jackpoint
> discussion regarding the winnability of the Vietnam war.
>
> To say someone speaks from faulty positions or ignorance is
> one thing. However, to solely rail on Adam's arguments
> as trollish and not provide anything remotely useful
> to the conversation does not speak well for the assailant.


>
> >Perceptions of youth be damned. There are a number of 'youthful'
> >posters here who are respected - Chris Manteufel [sp certainly
> >mangled] for one, and he is approximately Adam's age, perhaps a tad
> >younger.
>

> I'm not consigning youth (which includes myself) to
> ignorance. I'm saying that Adam's youth may be a factor
> in his argumentation. This is not to say he is intellectual
> immature, but that the availability of information to
> cultivate his thoughts may be limited. The point I'm
> making is Adam's arguments aren't that much worse from
> many of the counter-arguments; superficiality is very
> difficult to avoid in informal settings such as newsgroups.
> It's not a condemnation, but an assessment of the
> intellectual limits that this form of communication imposes
> on us (as opposed, say, to a forum employed by professional
> students and practitioners of security and military studies).
> The quality of discussion falls as a result of both
> our time constraints and the hobbyish prioritization of
> our interests.
>
> Prez

fitter1st

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
On Mon, 8 May 2000 12:00:07 -0500, "loki" <lo...@inlink.com> wrote:

>"Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote
>>
>> Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
>> listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.
>
>Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over. First a
>development in my own life last night and now this.
>
>This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
>listening to.
>

>Loki
>
>
>
Scary shit, ain't it....


Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to

Brian Allardice

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
In article <39175579...@news.mindspring.com>, fitter1st says...

Well, he caught a lot of guys with his history of HMS Vanguard......

Cheers,
dba

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
d...@uniserve.com (Brian Allardice) wrote in
<95784192...@neptune.uniserve.ca>:

>
>Well, he caught a lot of guys with his history of HMS Vanguard......

I don't doubt it. There's a wealth of information
amongst all the participants here. However, how
useful is all that history beyond demonstrating the
poster's erudition?

I'm discussing a similar situation on alt.books.tom-clancy
regarding Keegan's AHW. He's a very astute historian
in that he has a very keen sense of the personal
realism of history. However, how does this 1) enrich
the reader's understanding of the conduct of war
in general, and 2) contribute to the reader's ability
to arrive at sensible solutions regarding problems
thereof? It quite plainly doesn't.

I've seen posts that go over every minute detail of
the Siege of Mantua and Mapolean's decision to
fall back on two enemy columns. I do not, however,
see discussion of July 30 event in the same manner
as say Clausewitz's discussion on analysis (Book 2,
Chap 5 - Vom Kriege). I've seen detailed discussions
on specific ships within Task Force 58, intriguing
debates on choices made by on-scene commanders in
a very tight, expert context. However, when the
scope is broadened to issues that move beyond the
relatively continguous and therefore inconspicuous
specifics of the engagement (for example, explaining
World War I's origins), the argumentation somehow
falters.

I think that's where a great deal of the friction
in discussions over general political discussions
comes in. Like historical discussions, drawing
lessons to formulate a "right" world view requires
an analytical mind--however, since it falls out
of the realm of historical study methodical
approaches in political discussions are sorely
overlooked.

Prez

Juergen Nieveler

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
Arve...@chebucto.ns.ca (Arved Sandstrom) wrote in <39174e16.2818947
@news.dal.ca>:

>Hey, I was in my early 20's and _still_ an exponent of strategic
>nuclear warfare, not to mention bio and chemical. :-)
>
>As is often the case, a spell of active duty in the military actually
>grew me up. :-)
>

You too? :-)

Well, can't complain about NBC-Training, I really had to use it in civilian
life.... the chemical industry can be a dangerous place ;-)

--
Juergen Nieveler
Support the ban of Dihydrogen Monoxide: http://www.dhmo.org/
"The people united can never be ignited!"- Sgt. Colon, Ankh-Morpork Watch
PGP-Key available under www.netcologne.de/~nc-nievelju/

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
lo...@inlink.com (loki) wrote in <zyLR4.3366$Xc.1...@news1.primary.net>:

>This child (and I'm a grandmother so to me this *is* a child)

I'm sorry, but you're going to have to do better than
that to impress me. I've never met you. Having
grown up in projects where grandmothers were as young as
thirty years old and still lacking common sense.

>has too much time on his hands.
>
>*plonk*
>
>Loki

You seem to be easily upset there for a
grandmother, Loki.

Prez

David Crompton

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to

Presley Cannady wrote:

I don't doubt it. There's a wealth of information

> amongst all the participants here. However, how
> useful is all that history beyond demonstrating the
> poster's erudition?

Erm...by answering queries from ppl who ask questions? Informing those
who do not know or wish to know something of which you know. Also a large
group of ppl on here who r industry professionals and such things allow
networking and disucssion of ideas. Paul Adam, My Key (when he posts), Mr
Gillon(same) and myself r from BAE SYSTEMS. Andrew is obviously in the
shipbuilding/design industry. Vince and Andrew Breen r at Uni and
academic professionals..I think guys, care to correct me? TMO and others
r ex navy(USN) and Mike is ex RN(again I think). So there is a lot of
info out there on many matters.

> I'm discussing a similar situation on alt.books.tom-clancy
> regarding Keegan's AHW. He's a very astute historian
> in that he has a very keen sense of the personal
> realism of history. However, how does this 1) enrich
> the reader's understanding of the conduct of war
> in general, and 2) contribute to the reader's ability
> to arrive at sensible solutions regarding problems
> thereof? It quite plainly doesn't.

? this is a newsgroup 95% dedicated to naval military matters.
Perspectivies on John Keegan (I presume u r talking about) and his
personal realism of history r important how here?

> I've seen posts that go over every minute detail of
> the Siege of Mantua and Mapolean's decision to
> fall back on two enemy columns. I do not, however,
> see discussion of July 30 event in the same manner
> as say Clausewitz's discussion on analysis (Book 2,
> Chap 5 - Vom Kriege). I've seen detailed discussions
> on specific ships within Task Force 58, intriguing
> debates on choices made by on-scene commanders in
> a very tight, expert context. However, when the
> scope is broadened to issues that move beyond the
> relatively continguous and therefore inconspicuous
> specifics of the engagement (for example, explaining
> World War I's origins), the argumentation somehow
> falters.

Yes, Im rather afraid Clausewitz doesnt do much on military naval
tactics. I cant remember what he has to say on military naval strategies,
but Im fairly sure he doesnt devote whole chapters to it. Now give us
Mahon...
One again this would explain why we do not debate the origins of WW1 that
often..about the only thing that might interest us is in the sending of
the gunboats and technical descriptions thereof...oh and tactics
employed.

> I think that's where a great deal of the friction
> in discussions over general political discussions
> comes in. Like historical discussions, drawing
> lessons to formulate a "right" world view requires
> an analytical mind--however, since it falls out
> of the realm of historical study methodical
> approaches in political discussions are sorely
> overlooked.

WE discuss naval military matters. We dont really want to be a general
historical discussion group.

ok ta
DAvid


Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

Just who the hell are you, Prez, to waft in here and be so damned
critical, censorious and self-righteous?

Glenn Dowdy

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
Eugene Griessel wrote in message <3918134e...@news1.mweb.co.za>...

>rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:
>
>>lo...@inlink.com (loki) wrote in <zyLR4.3366$Xc.1...@news1.primary.net>:
>>
>>>This child (and I'm a grandmother so to me this *is* a child)
>>
>>I'm sorry, but you're going to have to do better than
>>that to impress me. I've never met you. Having
>>grown up in projects where grandmothers were as young as
>>thirty years old and still lacking common sense.
>>
>>>has too much time on his hands.
>>>
>>>*plonk*
>>>
>>>Loki
>>
>>You seem to be easily upset there for a
>>grandmother, Loki.
>>
>>Prez
>
>Just who the hell are you, Prez, to waft in here and be so damned
>critical, censorious and self-righteous?
>

He's a college boy Navy ROTC midshipman at MIT, evidently greatly impressed
by his own ability to write long, rambling and sesquipedalian posts.
Sophomore, I'd guess. Prez, you smoke a pipe now?

BlackBeard

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
In article <39174e16...@news.dal.ca>, Arve...@chebucto.ns.ca (Arved
Sandstrom) wrote:

>Hey, I was in my early 20's and _still_ an exponent of strategic
>nuclear warfare, not to mention bio and chemical. :-)
>
>As is often the case, a spell of active duty in the military actually
>grew me up. :-)
>

>Arved Sandstrom
>


Hasn't done much for your attendance record here of late...

;)

Hey Arved... You got the below decks watch, here's the belt, the
clipboard and the nightstick. Air in the banks, sh*t in the tanks and the
boats afloat. Don't worry about the fire, the flooding will put it out.
I had it, you got it... anyone needs me I'll be in the CO's rack, just
walk in and kiss me in the dark.

BlackBeard
Submarines once, Submarines twice...

""Bless those who serve beneath the deep, Through lonely hours their vigil keep, May peace their mission ever be, Protect each one we ask of thee.
Bless those at home who wait and pray, For their return by night or day."
-Rev. Gale Williamson

Interim Books

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
On 09 May 2000 00:45:13 GMT, rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:
>It's not a condemnation, but an assessment of the
>intellectual limits that this form of communication imposes
>on us (as opposed, say, to a forum employed by professional
>students and practitioners of security and military studies).
>The quality of discussion falls as a result of both
>our time constraints and the hobbyish prioritization of
>our interests.
>
>Prez

Sorry... Just because something is a hobby does not mean you cannot
do it well. Quality or lack thereof is an intrinsic function of the
poster, not the medium.

<*PLONK*>

D.

Interim Books | 322 Pacific Ave | Bremerton, WA | 98377
fair...@hurricane.net | (360) 377-4343 | http://www.interimbooks.com


Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
"Glenn Dowdy" <glenn...@agilent.com> wrote:

>He's a college boy Navy ROTC midshipman at MIT, evidently greatly impressed
>by his own ability to write long, rambling and sesquipedalian posts.
>Sophomore, I'd guess. Prez, you smoke a pipe now?

Should I make allowances for his youth and inexperience or continue to
lambaste him? Always had a LOT of respect for MIT - especially the
Engineering side.

Andrew McCruden

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to

Brian Allardice wrote:
>
> In article <39175579...@news.mindspring.com>, fitter1st says...
> >
> >On Mon, 8 May 2000 12:00:07 -0500, "loki" <lo...@inlink.com> wrote:
>
> >>This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
> >>listening to.
> >>
> >>Loki
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >Scary shit, ain't it....
>

> Well, he caught a lot of guys with his history of HMS Vanguard......
>

Did he? IIRC most people very quickly realised it was a joke and given
the preponderance of Battleship-loving threads at the time, a very
nicely aimed one.....

Glenn Dowdy

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
Eugene Griessel wrote in message <39184627...@news1.mweb.co.za>...

>"Glenn Dowdy" <glenn...@agilent.com> wrote:
>
>>He's a college boy Navy ROTC midshipman at MIT, evidently greatly
impressed
>>by his own ability to write long, rambling and sesquipedalian posts.
>>Sophomore, I'd guess. Prez, you smoke a pipe now?
>
>Should I make allowances for his youth and inexperience or continue to
>lambaste him?

Yes.

>Always had a LOT of respect for MIT - especially the
>Engineering side.
>

Presley seems to be a very intelligent young man. I just hope he comes to
realize that school smarts ain't all it take to be a good leader.

loki

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
"BlackBeard" <Black...@call.for.prices.com> wrote

>. anyone needs me I'll be in the CO's rack, just
> walk in and kiss me in the dark.

<chuckle> You say a thing like that knowing I'm around...

Loki


Erik_Bloodaxe

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to

BlackBeard wrote:
>
> In article <39174e16...@news.dal.ca>, Arve...@chebucto.ns.ca (Arved
> Sandstrom) wrote:
>
> >Hey, I was in my early 20's and _still_ an exponent of strategic
> >nuclear warfare, not to mention bio and chemical. :-)
> >
> >As is often the case, a spell of active duty in the military actually
> >grew me up. :-)
> >
> >Arved Sandstrom
> >
>
> Hasn't done much for your attendance record here of late...
>
> ;)
>
> Hey Arved... You got the below decks watch, here's the belt, the
> clipboard and the nightstick. Air in the banks, sh*t in the tanks and the
> boats afloat. Don't worry about the fire, the flooding will put it out.

> I had it, you got it... anyone needs me I'll be in the CO's rack, just


> walk in and kiss me in the dark.
>

Man, you give a wordy turn over. What ever happened to just thowing
the logs at him and walking away.

BlackBeard

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
In article <39185684...@yahoodle.com>, Erik_Bloodaxe
<Erik_B...@yahoodle.com> wrote:

>>>
>> Hey Arved... You got the below decks watch, here's the belt, the
>> clipboard and the nightstick. Air in the banks, sh*t in the tanks and the
>> boats afloat. Don't worry about the fire, the flooding will put it out.
>> I had it, you got it... anyone needs me I'll be in the CO's rack, just
>> walk in and kiss me in the dark.
>>
> Man, you give a wordy turn over. What ever happened to just thowing
>the logs at him and walking away.
>
>


That's a compilation of my favorites. The standard room watch [1]
turnover being "Take the club and don't wake me".

Back when we had to have a room watch...

BlackBeard

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
In article <WRXR4.3409$Xc.1...@news1.primary.net>, "loki"
<lo...@inlink.com> wrote:

>"BlackBeard" <Black...@call.for.prices.com> wrote


>
>>. anyone needs me I'll be in the CO's rack, just
>> walk in and kiss me in the dark.
>

><chuckle> You say a thing like that knowing I'm around...
>
>Loki

Hehehe...


We had a VERY new striker onboard who overheard and A-ganger use that
line. He waited till he could stand it no longer and asked "How does he
get to use the CO's cabin"? If I only could have kept a straight face...
I had visions of him doing wake-ups and actually going into the CO's
cabin looking for the A-ganger...

ANDREW BREEN

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
In article <391811DD...@gecm.com>,

David Crompton <David.c...@gecm.com> wrote:
>shipbuilding/design industry. Vince and Andrew Breen r at Uni and
>academic professionals..I think guys, care to correct me?

It's a fair description: I'm a solar-terrestrial physicist by profession
(basically, if it happens between the 'surface' of the Sun and the bottom
of the ionised part of the Earth's atmosphere, it's part of my parish)
and a naval history geek - particularly the sail/steam transition period.
My father did the Atlantic, the channel and the biscay convoys in the last
big struggle, so I can always ask for an eye-witness opinion.
There is a _lot_ of expertise in this group, both on the historical and the
'been there, done that' sides. And the group generally works pretty well.
If people percived as trolling (or using the 'B' word, let alone the 'F'
word) get stepped on hard, then that's one of the things that keeps the
signal-to-noise ratio in this group higher than many.

--
Andy Breen ~ PPARC Advanced Research Fellow, Interplanetary Scintillation
Solar Physics Group, UW Aberystwyth
"When I was young I used to scintillate
now I only sin 'til ten past three" (Ogden Nash)

Paul J. Adam

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
In article <39175579...@news.mindspring.com>, fitter1st <?@?.?>
writes

>On Mon, 8 May 2000 12:00:07 -0500, "loki" <lo...@inlink.com> wrote:
>>"Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote
>>> Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to anyone
>>> listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.
>>
>>Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over. First a
>>development in my own life last night and now this.
>>
>>This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
>>listening to.
>>
>Scary shit, ain't it....

I'm not sure whether to be flattered or outraged :)


--
There are four kinds of homicide: praiseworthy, justifiable, excusable and
felonious...
Paul J. Adam ne...@jrwlynch.demon.co.uk

B F Lake

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
ANDREW BREEN <a...@aber.ac.uk> wrote in article <

> It's a fair description: I'm a solar-terrestrial physicist by profession
Is that the same as extra-terrestrial? :)
Regards,
Barry

Paul H. Lemmen

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
Like historical discussions, drawing
> lessons to formulate a "right" world view requires
> an analytical mind--however, since it falls out
> of the realm of historical study methodical
> approaches in political discussions are sorely
> overlooked.
>
> Prez
>
Had a bright fella in me command like ye. Too bad we buried him on his
first op. Having a good analytical mind and implementing methodical
approaches in political discussions doesn't save yer life on an op.
Following yer commanders instructions no matter how un politically
correct they may seem and following them to the letter even if ye
believe yer intellect is far superior is the only thing that will keep
ye alive. Many of us here know only too well the sound of a bullet
fired in anger (at us!) to be overweened by some snot nosed bogswaddy
at university.
--
Paul H. Lemmen
"Bloc Sprao Agath No Go Maci"
(to the non-Gaelic enabled:"Have fun or get out!")


Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.

Jim Nowotarski

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
Paul J. Adam <ne...@jrwlynch.demon.co.uk> wrote in message
news:yRn2XSAa...@jrwlynch.demon.co.uk...

> In article <39175579...@news.mindspring.com>, fitter1st
<?@?.?>
> writes
> >On Mon, 8 May 2000 12:00:07 -0500, "loki" <lo...@inlink.com> wrote:
> >>"Adam Yoshida" <adamy...@home.com> wrote
> >>> Welcome to the group, if you're going to seriously listen to
anyone
> >>> listen to Paul J. Adam and TMoliver.
> >>
> >>Ok, I can't take it. The proverbial Hell *has* frozen over.
First a
> >>development in my own life last night and now this.
> >>
> >>This may well be the only thing Adam has ever written here worth
> >>listening to.
> >>
> >Scary shit, ain't it....
>
> I'm not sure whether to be flattered or outraged :)
>
Try going for outrageously flattered.

Ob. SMN: Has anyone heard anything about the next series of
Hornblower TV movies?


>
> --
> There are four kinds of homicide: praiseworthy, justifiable,
excusable and
> felonious...
> Paul J. Adam ne...@jrwlynch.demon.co.uk


--
Jim Nowotarski

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
<3918134e...@news1.mweb.co.za>:

>
>Just who the hell are you, Prez, to waft in here and be so damned
>critical, censorious and self-righteous?

To my knowledge no one, although some have made more
of it than anything. I asked a question about
Adam Yoshida, I got back several snide answers, I
did some investigation as recommended, I heard from
Adam, and decided that the situation resulted not
simply from Adam's inflammatory remarks but the
equally undesirable baiting by other participants.
I'm not being critical at all, and I specifically
stated that no one should expect the level of
discussion to reach some sort of high academic or
professional pedestal on a newsgroup. However,
it seems that when a particularly undeveloped
perspective is voiced by someone as young as
Adam (in his tone, might I add) that folks tend to
apply a rigorous standard.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
glenn...@agilent.com (Glenn Dowdy) wrote in
<8f99p7$md9$1...@fcnews.fc.hp.com>:

>
>He's a college boy Navy ROTC midshipman at MIT, evidently
>greatly impressed by his own ability to write long, rambling
>and sesquipedalian posts. Sophomore, I'd guess. Prez, you smoke
>a pipe now?

Actually, I'm always open for suggestions on how
to improve my writing. I neither claim to be
particularly good or impressed by my writing.

I smoke cigarettes, but I fail to see what you're
getting at. If you're suggesting some sort of
academician stereotype, I'd suggest stop, think
about how you'd feel if I critiqued your experiences
and judgement, and then move on. I make no
claim to know you, and you have no relationship
with me.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
<39184627...@news1.mweb.co.za>:

>
>Should I make allowances for his youth and inexperience or continue to
>lambaste him?

I'd suggest you come up with good arguments.
I don't respond to patronizing and I don't
see any teaching merit in ad hominems.

>Always had a LOT of respect for MIT - especially the
>Engineering side.

It's a good school. I'm enjoying it.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
glenn...@agilent.com (Glenn Dowdy) wrote in
<8f9l1h$pqi$1...@fcnews.fc.hp.com>:

>
>Presley seems to be a very intelligent young man. I just hope he comes to
>realize that school smarts ain't all it take to be a good leader.

If there's one lesson that you learn in school, it's
that there's a life of experience ahead that will
help shape your perspective. Don't you think, however,
its foolish and highly uneducational to test and
modify your views if you fail to let anyone in on
them?

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
David.c...@gecm.com (David Crompton) wrote in
<391811DD...@gecm.com>:

>
>Erm...by answering queries from ppl who ask questions? Informing those
>who do not know or wish to know something of which you know. Also a large
>group of ppl on here who r industry professionals and such things allow
>networking and disucssion of ideas. Paul Adam, My Key (when he posts), Mr
>Gillon(same) and myself r from BAE SYSTEMS. Andrew is obviously in the
>shipbuilding/design industry. Vince and Andrew Breen r at Uni and
>academic professionals..I think guys, care to correct me? TMO and others
>r ex navy(USN) and Mike is ex RN(again I think). So there is a lot of
>info out there on many matters.

I'm speaking of broad discussions on political theory
where historical examples are used without really
engaging your audience.

>? this is a newsgroup 95% dedicated to naval military matters.
>Perspectivies on John Keegan (I presume u r talking about) and his
>personal realism of history r important how here?

They're important to the line of discussion at
this point, which involves specifically Adam
Yoshida's debating style and generally the
styles of all newsgroup participants.

>Yes, Im rather afraid Clausewitz doesnt do much on military naval
>tactics. I cant remember what he has to say on military naval strategies,
>but Im fairly sure he doesnt devote whole chapters to it. Now give us
>Mahon...

Who, unlike his father, was a Clausewitzian (although the
strength of his understanding might be debated in another
setting). Are you suggesting that On War has little
relevence to naval matters? I find the value of On
War to lie primarily in Clausewitz's analytical method,
which is extremely important--in my opinion--to
all aspects of war's examination--naval or not.

>One again this would explain why we do not debate the origins of WW1 that
>often..about the only thing that might interest us is in the sending of
>the gunboats and technical descriptions thereof...oh and tactics
>employed.

However, discussions on seapower once again involve
discussions on grand strategy; it is not illegitimate
to consider Clausewitz when discussing these issues,
and in some discussions he will come up as we
examine Corbets' and Mahan's influences.

>WE discuss naval military matters. We dont really want to be a general
>historical discussion group.

Apparantly, issues regarding seapower are also
brought up here. You pointed this out yourself.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
fair...@hurricane.net (Interim Books) wrote in
<1ggghsgf1thururvm...@4ax.com>:

>
>Sorry... Just because something is a hobby does not mean you cannot
>do it well. Quality or lack thereof is an intrinsic function of the
>poster, not the medium.

Doing something well and doing something professionally
are two different things. My aim is limited
to the newsgroup discourse.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
PLe...@yahoo.com (Paul H. Lemmen) wrote in <8fa4cn$86n$1...@nnrp1.deja.com>:

>
>Had a bright fella in me command like ye. Too bad we buried him on his
>first op. Having a good analytical mind and implementing methodical
>approaches in political discussions doesn't save yer life on an op.

I take issue.

You speak of methodology as if it provides some sort of
instruction book to tell you to do this or that at
such and such time. Naturally, that goes against
the grain of your experience (and it does mine; I
didn't have to join the military to learn about
hazardous lifestyles. I spent a good portion of
my life in Queensbridge Projects, and at one point
I was a gang member).

If you want to lecture me on your distaste for
college-style rosery, then fine another audience.
I didn't take an easy road to get here and I
don't expect to find an easy road out. Otherwise,
I'll look forward to discussing other things
with you. I am not, however, your sounding board
for overused cliches about "by-the-book"
junior officers.

Prez

loki

unread,
May 9, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/9/00
to
"BlackBeard" <Black...@call.for.prices.com> wrote

>
> Hehehe...
>
>
> We had a VERY new striker onboard who overheard and A-ganger use that
> line. He waited till he could stand it no longer and asked "How does he
> get to use the CO's cabin"? If I only could have kept a straight face...
> I had visions of him doing wake-ups and actually going into the CO's
> cabin looking for the A-ganger...

Oh geez...

Well, looking at it that way, I guess there are the following possibilities:

1. I go to the CO's cabin, you're not there, I kiss said CO in the dark
and hopefully he likes it...

2. I go to the CO's cabin, you're there and the CO is not. I kiss you
in the dark and you like it...

3. I go to the CO's cabin, you're there and so is the CO. I get to
watch. <grin>

4. I go to the CO's cabin, you're there and so is the CO. I get a
threesome...

Works anyway I look at it...

Loki - who couldn't resist...

B F Lake

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
Olivers <ol...@calpha.com> wrote ..
>
> He is a Canadian, a nationality troubled by shoulder chips ..... useless
> inventions,
(snip observant remarks EXCEPT>>>)
What's wrong with the paint roller? It is a source of arousing patriotism
that we are told this is "our" gift to the world. Could the USN survive
without paint rollers?

Agree with TMO designation of the game of basketball as "useless".
However, IMO , just because it was an American who thought of removing the
bottom from the peach basket to save work retrieving balls, does not
detract from our glory in this invention.
>assorted Duboukirs/Dubuggers?
Tolstoy's gift to British Columbia?
Regards,
Barry

Brian Allardice

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
In article <39185119...@beyond-comprehension.fsnet.co.uk>,
Use...@beyond-comprehension.fsnet.co.uk says...

>> Well, he caught a lot of guys with his history of HMS Vanguard......
>>
>
>Did he? IIRC most people very quickly realised it was a joke and given
>the preponderance of Battleship-loving threads at the time, a very
>nicely aimed one.....

Well, one or two, but around here I count that as a lot........

Cheers,
dba


Paul H. Lemmen

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to

I am not, however, your sounding board
> for overused cliches about "by-the-book"
> junior officers.
>
> Prez
>

LOL...ye dinna know who yer talking to boyo! I am the least "by-the-
book" bastard ye shall ever come across. As a junior intelligence
office in the Provisional IRA I did quite a few "wet" jobs...what ye
call assassinations. As Officer Commanding, 3rd Donegal Brigade, I was
the meanest and most unconventinal commander ye would ever come across.
Ye have grit boyo, stand on yer hind legs and roar....but also know
when tae keep silent and slink into the shadows. Keep struggling....it
NEVER ends, do not pause tae rest on yer laurels for ye will become
vine bound.
Cheers,

Arved Sandstrom

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
On Tue, 9 May 2000 18:18:44 GMT, Erik_Bloodaxe
<Erik_B...@yahoodle.com> wrote:

>BlackBeard wrote:
>>
>> Hey Arved... You got the below decks watch, here's the belt, the
>> clipboard and the nightstick. Air in the banks, sh*t in the tanks and the
>> boats afloat. Don't worry about the fire, the flooding will put it out.

>> I had it, you got it... anyone needs me I'll be in the CO's rack, just


>> walk in and kiss me in the dark.
>>

> Man, you give a wordy turn over. What ever happened to just thowing
>the logs at him and walking away.
>

Anyway, if I heard a litany like that, I'd wait until the squidley got
out of sight, go down to the well-deck, and drive an LVTP out the
back. :-)

Arved


Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
PLe...@yahoo.com (Paul H. Lemmen) wrote in <8fack8$h95$1...@nnrp1.deja.com>:

>
>LOL...ye dinna know who yer talking to boyo! I am the least "by-the-
>book" bastard ye shall ever come across.

Depends on the book. This reads like a really bad techno-
thriller.

>As a junior intelligence
>office in the Provisional IRA I did quite a few "wet" jobs...what ye
>call assassinations.

I'm proud of you.

Prez

Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

>eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in

><3918134e...@news1.mweb.co.za>:
>>
>>Just who the hell are you, Prez, to waft in here and be so damned
>>critical, censorious and self-righteous?
>
>To my knowledge no one, although some have made more
>of it than anything. I asked a question about
>Adam Yoshida, I got back several snide answers, I
>did some investigation as recommended, I heard from
>Adam, and decided that the situation resulted not
>simply from Adam's inflammatory remarks but the
>equally undesirable baiting by other participants.

If this is the level of scientific investigation you usually do I
strongly suggest you seek another career. We have had, on this
newsgroup, over the years, certain characters, mostly of the "what if"
persuasion who blow in here with plumb crazy notions. The grizzled
veterans of this ng usually react to this type of person quite
politely, initially, pointing out the glaring errors and gaping
loopholes in their arguments. We have had mach1 missile carrying
speedboats, million ton 32 -inch gunned 70 knot b*ttl*sh*ps, c*ncr*t*
f**sts and other wildy improbable proposals. This is to some extent
legitimate - especially as a core around which a debate can evolve.

However many of these posters are young and arrogant, untainted with
the true realities of life and untroubled by physical laws. And
instead of either defending their points with science or facts they
bluster. This *is* sci.military.naval and not one of the fantasy
newsgroups and we expect a certain level of objectivity to be
maintained. Soon the older and experienced denizens of the group lose
patience and politely or impolitely invite the young poster to
investigate procreation and travel. You have read a few of Adam's
posts and come to a firm conclusion. You have not read them in
context with the replies he received and to which he replied. Yet you
see fit to pass judgement and plead his case. I have nothing against
the lad per se - I suppose even Hitler could be quite pleasant as a
lad - but Mr Yoshida show dangerous mental instability. His rants
may be palatable to you because you may perceive those he regards as
enemies who are to be expunged from the face of the planet as your
enemies too. However imagine if he suddenly transferred the hatred he
feels towards sundry unspeakable political systems, regimes and
nationalities wordlwide to the United States? Would you feel as
complacent then? Would you make the sort of specious analysis about
him that you already have? Or did you miss that particular series of
posts in your research? Or do you enjoy consorting with bigots?

>I'm not being critical at all, and I specifically
>stated that no one should expect the level of
>discussion to reach some sort of high academic or
>professional pedestal on a newsgroup. However,
>it seems that when a particularly undeveloped
>perspective is voiced by someone as young as
>Adam (in his tone, might I add) that folks tend to
>apply a rigorous standard.

If you wish to compete in same arena you must accept the same
standards. We have a number of very young posters here who are
treated with utmost respect - because they realise the limitations of
their knowledge and experience and do not attempt to present wild
flights of fantasy, personal hatreds or megalomaniac behaviour to a
group of people who have the education AND experience to know that
they are offering utter drivel. For what its worth, Andrew Toppan,
who was largely instumental in founding this group, was either in his
teens or barely out of them at the time.

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
<3918ef4...@news1.mweb.co.za>:

>
>If this is the level of scientific investigation you usually do I
>strongly suggest you seek another career.

I think I'll be the judge of that. The
fact I'm here speaks sufficiently of
my ability; I don't have to prove it
to you.

>We have had, on this
>newsgroup, over the years, certain characters, mostly of the "what if"
>persuasion who blow in here with plumb crazy notions. The grizzled
>veterans of this ng usually react to this type of person quite
>politely, initially, pointing out the glaring errors and gaping
>loopholes in their arguments. We have had mach1 missile carrying
>speedboats, million ton 32 -inch gunned 70 knot b*ttl*sh*ps, c*ncr*t*
>f**sts and other wildy improbable proposals. This is to some extent
>legitimate - especially as a core around which a debate can evolve.

Forgive me, but I've had enough experience to know two
things:

1) The "grizzled veteran" act is just that, an act. Where
I come from they call it arrogance--when the old and
crazy folks hanging around the elevators feel its necessary
to interject their personal experiences into the lives of
every individual who comes their way. In short, I've seen
more of this grizzled veteran idea in movies than in real
life.

2) The truly experienced, the one I've come to know in real life,
have patience. They've cultivated it over the years, they don't
patronize, and they patiently educate. When they run into
arrogance--youthful or not--that they cannot penetrate, they
move on quietly. They don't need to prove anything to me,
just as I don't need to prove anything to you.

>However many of these posters are young and arrogant, untainted with
>the true realities of life and untroubled by physical laws. And
>instead of either defending their points with science or facts they
>bluster. This *is* sci.military.naval and not one of the fantasy
>newsgroups and we expect a certain level of objectivity to be
>maintained. Soon the older and experienced denizens of the group lose
>patience and politely or impolitely invite the young poster to
>investigate procreation and travel. You have read a few of Adam's
>posts and come to a firm conclusion. You have not read them in
>context with the replies he received and to which he replied. Yet you
>see fit to pass judgement and plead his case.

The truly experienced, additionally, are careful not to make
too many assumptions--particularly character assumptions. I've
explicitly stated I've read Adam's posts in the context of the
discussions. I've specifically stated I was addressing his
broad political views, then ones that appear to attract the most
vehement attacks. The discussion degenerates into political
rhetoric a good portion of the time, so I concluded that Adam's
views may be inflammatory but the replies were hardly educational
or useful in resolving the situation. That's not the simple
result of a loss of patience, but an intellectual failure at
the point of question.

At this point, I'm waiting for the "well, why the hell are you
talking about this instead of actually contributing" reply.

>I have nothing against
>the lad per se - I suppose even Hitler could be quite pleasant as a
>lad - but Mr Yoshida show dangerous mental instability. His rants
>may be palatable to you because you may perceive those he regards as
>enemies who are to be expunged from the face of the planet as your
>enemies too.

Once again, the truly experienced avoid making character
assassinations. You've already decided that Yoshida's
mentally unstable, and now you're implying the same
to me. We have not discussed the intersections of
disagreement between Adam and myself.

>However imagine if he suddenly transferred the hatred he
>feels towards sundry unspeakable political systems, regimes and
>nationalities wordlwide to the United States? Would you feel as
>complacent then?

This is a loaded question, and your choice of the word
"complacent" demonstrates the complete dishonesty behind
it. The proper question is "would I lose my temper."

1) It's a newsgroup, I don't know Adam, and I tend not
to lose my temper at people I don't know.

2) I can argue against, that's always an option.

3) I can move on from the discussion if it seems to yield
nothing in the way of correcting Adam, enriching myself,
or opening up a new road of information for the rest of
the group.


>Would you make the sort of specious analysis about
>him that you already have?

A strawman.

>Or did you miss that particular series of
>posts in your research? Or do you enjoy consorting with bigots?

This question I'll leave to you. As I said, I
have nothing to prove to you.

>If you wish to compete in same arena you must accept the same
>standards.

No, there are no standards. I've seen the political
discourse on this year, and it is NOT up to the
level you demand of Adam. Hypothetical example:

* * *

1) Statement: The American intervention in the Vietnam War
as misguided, poorly conducted and devastating.

Reply: Tru, tru...

2) Statement: The American intervention in the Vietnam
War was right, successful and stopped communism.

Reply: You simple motherfucker!

* * *

>We have a number of very young posters here who are
>treated with utmost respect - because they realise the limitations of
>their knowledge and experience and do not attempt to present wild
>flights of fantasy, personal hatreds or megalomaniac behaviour to a
>group of people who have the education AND experience to know that
>they are offering utter drivel.

Then you're making the age old mistake of replacing age for
experience. Perhaps because I'm in that midterm where I can
see both education and experience as well as youth from a
startling clear vantage point, I can comfortably assert that
it's a mistake to assume because someone is young they are
necessarily restrained by some sort of intellectual limitation.
I don't like being patronized, and I'll avoid doing that to
those younger and older to me.

>For what its worth, Andrew Toppan,
>who was largely instumental in founding this group, was either in his
>teens or barely out of them at the time.

The relevence escapes me.

Prez

Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

<snip>

>>For what its worth, Andrew Toppan,
>>who was largely instumental in founding this group, was either in his
>>teens or barely out of them at the time.
>
>The relevence escapes me.

It seems to be the story of your life.....

BTW Good luck when you get to sea for any extended period.

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
<39195a79...@news1.mweb.co.za>:

>
>It seems to be the story of your life.....

Very well, you've gone to extra lengths to demonstrate
my point.

Prez

Andrew Mccruden

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to

Presley Cannady <rev...@mit.edu> wrote in message
news:8F3055543re...@18.247.2.125...

> eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
> <3918ef4...@news1.mweb.co.za>:

>


> >We have had, on this
> >newsgroup, over the years, certain characters, mostly of the "what if"
> >persuasion who blow in here with plumb crazy notions. The grizzled
> >veterans of this ng usually react to this type of person quite
> >politely, initially, pointing out the glaring errors and gaping
> >loopholes in their arguments. We have had mach1 missile carrying
> >speedboats, million ton 32 -inch gunned 70 knot b*ttl*sh*ps, c*ncr*t*
> >f**sts and other wildy improbable proposals. This is to some extent
> >legitimate - especially as a core around which a debate can evolve.
>
> Forgive me, but I've had enough experience to know two
> things:
>
> 1) The "grizzled veteran" act is just that, an act. Where
> I come from they call it arrogance--when the old and
> crazy folks hanging around the elevators feel its necessary
> to interject their personal experiences into the lives of
> every individual who comes their way. In short, I've seen
> more of this grizzled veteran idea in movies than in real
> life.

Well while I try to aviod biting poeples heads off myself, I've seen the
cause of new construction composite-armoured battleships and deep water
Anti-ship attacks with existing ballistic missiles raised countless times,
at the very least every two or three months since the founding of
sci.military.naval, it does tend to wear the patence thin to have to go over
the same ground so often

> >For what its worth, Andrew Toppan,
> >who was largely instumental in founding this group, was either in his
> >teens or barely out of them at the time.
>
> The relevence escapes me.

The point is that not all the Younger posters on the group are the ones that
come out with improbably stupid "design" ideas or ridiculous plots (of
course i will support this line, some of Eugene's statement could also be
applied to me*.;-)
)


* In fact quite a few of the original more prominent posters to this group
were at the time of ages that were not far off what i remeber Adam's
Approximate age to be now, but many of them have now moved on to other
things.


Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

>eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in

><39195a79...@news1.mweb.co.za>:
>>
>>It seems to be the story of your life.....
>
>Very well, you've gone to extra lengths to demonstrate
>my point.

If you had a point, maybe. I looked at your earlier post long and
well and it appears we do not speak the same language. So rather than
argue the toss I decided not to attempt a point by point debate.

Anyway I'm glad Adam seems to have found a friend - which must be a
new experience in his life.

Yama

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
Presley Cannady wrote:
>
> eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
> <3918134e...@news1.mweb.co.za>:
> >
> >Just who the hell are you, Prez, to waft in here and be so damned
> >critical, censorious and self-righteous?
>
> To my knowledge no one, although some have made more
> of it than anything. I asked a question about
> Adam Yoshida, I got back several snide answers, I
> did some investigation as recommended, I heard from
> Adam, and decided that the situation resulted not
> simply from Adam's inflammatory remarks but the
> equally undesirable baiting by other participants.

Ladies and Gentlemen, lets not grab our flamethrowers...yet.
Problem with A. Yoshida is that regulars of this NG get kinda fed up
after seeing long posts which are then followed by even longer
threads (not to forget x^2 subthreads) which he posted about every
two weeks, and which were either variations of theme "USA should
rearm and kick butt <insert your favourite country" or propals how
to solve various world problems with PGM's or nukes.

And it's not like he is first of his kind, s.m.n has always had it's
'court troll'. Before AY it was MKShephard (sp?), before him it was
H. Hutchinson and so on...

The good thing in these three trolls was that after getting whacked
(metaphorically) few times, they developed certain amount of
self-irony, something you can't say about trolls of s.h.w.w-w-ii or
r.a.m (who are way too many to mention :( I take AY over, say Eni23
any day...

It's a same thing than while a some new face in this NG might find
the question of reactivating b****ships interesting and worth
debating, old salts are absolutely and utterly fed up with that,
after reading 10k+ posts about that subject during last five
years...

Olivers

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
Presley Cannady wrote:
>
> eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
> <3918ef4...@news1.mweb.co.za>:
> >
> >If this is the level of scientific investigation you usually do I
> >strongly suggest you seek another career.
>
> I think I'll be the judge of that. The
> fact I'm here speaks sufficiently of
> my ability; I don't have to prove it
> to you.
>

This latest dialogue extension raises (at least in my cluttered and fast
decaying mind) the awful prospect that in a short period of time, our
dauntless Mid, the cigarette-smoking tendentious Mr. Cannady will have
put up a single broad stripe of an N'swine and have been dispatched to
some rusting relic patrolling distant waters (or more likely lashed
tightly to some decaying pier at NOB Nofuck.

"O tempora, O mores!"

Quid consilium cepit, Cannady, for adjusting the the fact that your
prospective ship's XO, a NAVOCS product with a BA in Agricultural
Marketing from the University of Mississippi, the Bull Ensign, a former
Machinist Mate LDO with a BA, Correspondence from Maryland U, and your
department head, a newly married Kansan who studied English at Oral
Roberts, may react substantially negatively to the smashingly boring
image which you present.

Nor is it likely that those whitehats subjected to your tender mercies
will race to chip and paint in frenzied response to your pious
entreaties, more likely responding by overstaying liberty, increasing
the VD rate or if truly exasperated, missing ship's movement.

The only thing more despicable than an overweeningly arrogant ensign is
the mistreatment he/she receives from the wardroom of which he/she
becomes a member.


--
TMOliver - el pelon sinverguenza

"Alle kunst ist unsonst,
wenn ein Engel in das Kundloch prunst."

Olivers

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
Presley Cannady wrote:
>
> eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
> <3918ef4...@news1.mweb.co.za>:
> >
> >If this is the level of scientific investigation you usually do I
> >strongly suggest you seek another career.
>
> I think I'll be the judge of that. The
> fact I'm here speaks sufficiently of
> my ability; I don't have to prove it
> to you.
>

Oh, you've offered all the proof required.....

This latest dialogue extension raises (at least in my cluttered and fast
decaying mind) the awful prospect that in a short period of time, our

dauntless Mid, the cigarette-smoking tendentious Mr. Cannady, will have
put up a single broad stripe of an N'swine and been dispatched to some


rusting relic patrolling distant waters (or more likely lashed tightly

to some decaying pier at NOB Nofuck).

"O tempora, O mores!"

Quid consilium cepit, Cannady, for adjusting to the the shock that your


prospective ship's XO, a NAVOCS product with a BA in Agricultural
Marketing from the University of Mississippi, the Bull Ensign, a former
Machinist Mate LDO with a BA, Correspondence from Maryland U, and your
department head, a newly married Kansan who studied English at Oral
Roberts, may react substantially negatively to the smashingly boring

image which you present?

Are you ready to stimulate the whitehats subjected to your tender
mercies to race to chip and paint in frenzied response to your pious
entreaties? Unfortunately, they are more likely responding by
overstaying liberty, increasing the VD rate or, if truly exasperated,

Jeff Crowell

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
Presley Cannady wrote:
> The truly experienced, additionally, are careful not to make
> too many assumptions--particularly character assumptions. I've
> explicitly stated I've read Adam's posts in the context of the
> discussions. I've specifically stated I was addressing his
> broad political views, then ones that appear to attract the most
> vehement attacks. The discussion degenerates into political
> rhetoric a good portion of the time, so I concluded that Adam's
> views may be inflammatory but the replies were hardly educational
> or useful in resolving the situation. That's not the simple
> result of a loss of patience, but an intellectual failure at
> the point of question.


Heh.

The reason ol' Yosh gets people fired up is that he don't listen.
It's not the opinions that get people riled so much, it's when
Adam pontificates on a subject he knows not, then stoutly
defends his position without facts and relying only on decibel
level instead.


Jeff


Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
jeff_crow...@hp.com (Jeff Crowell) wrote in
<8fc1ab$bgn$1...@hpbs1500.boi.hp.com>:

>
>
>Heh.
>
>The reason ol' Yosh gets people fired up is that he don't listen.

I've heard, and I've seen it myself. I'm not so sure
what it means in the long run, especially if he is
young and learning. What I do wonder, however, is how
easy is it to learn in an informal setting such as
this when you get your head bitten off at every
possible turn. As this thread shows, folks tend to
go on the defensive and refuse to budge when hostility
rises.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
ol...@calpha.com (Olivers) wrote in <39199733...@calpha.com>:

>
>Oh, you've offered all the proof required.....

I'm sure in your mind I have.

<latest attempt at pinning down a misguided characterization,
laced with sea dog rhetoric, snipped>

>The only thing more despicable than an overweeningly arrogant ensign is
>the mistreatment he/she receives from the wardroom of which he/she
>becomes a member.

Accompanying someone on their ego-trip in any
setting is annoying enough. It's not unique
to the wardroom or anywhere else. Equally
annoying is the arrogance expressed by those
who purport to have some monopoly on experience
and feel it's their duty to bitterly point out
the flaws in others. It goes beyond criticism
to petty jabbing, and I have no intentions of
backing down when you or anyone else in
this newsgroup presents themselves to me in
such a manner.

Prez

Peter Skelton

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

More appropraite responses would be:

a) respectful silence with resolve to ponder

or

b) thank you, sir

(a) is to be preferred.
--
Peter Skelton

Steve Bartman

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
On Wed, 10 May 2000 17:42:22 GMT, skel...@home.com (Peter Skelton)
wrote:


>More appropraite responses would be:
>
>a) respectful silence with resolve to ponder
>
>or
>
>b) thank you, sir
>
>(a) is to be preferred.

This is one of the more profound responses I've seen in these parts
lately. I somehow doubt the target will internalize it. At his age
plus a few I also was a jackass ensign, and yes, Peter, and yes, TMO,
I learned quite well the torments possible of infliction when one is
close confined for many months with jackass hunters.

He'll learn, or he'll die. At least wish he could. The universe will
move on.

Steve

Keith Willshaw

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to

Presley Cannady <rev...@mit.edu> wrote in message
news:8F3080D8Are...@18.247.2.125...

The problem is he shows little sign of learning

Something you and he seem to have in common

You at least have not advocated Genocide or been overtly racist ,
Yoshida has. Ask him about his plans to sterilise China
next time you chat.

Keith

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
skel...@home.com (Peter Skelton) wrote in <391aeff2.24079117@news>:

>
>More appropraite responses would be:
>
>a) respectful silence with resolve to ponder

I prefer a swift "fuck you."

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
keith_w...@compuserve.com (Keith Willshaw) wrote in
<8fcdee$poc$1...@sshuraab-i-1.production.compuserve.com>:

>
>
>Something you and he seem to have in common

Imagine how little weight this carries...

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
sbar...@ix.netcom.com (Steve Bartman) wrote in
<ck9jhsktrfeshqfqa...@4ax.com>:

>
>This is one of the more profound responses I've seen in these parts
>lately. I somehow doubt the target will internalize it. At his age
>plus a few I also was a jackass ensign, and yes, Peter, and yes, TMO,
>I learned quite well the torments possible of infliction when one is
>close confined for many months with jackass hunters.
>
>He'll learn, or he'll die. At least wish he could. The universe will
>move on.

I once said this to someone else on this board.

I'm not here for your experience, your advice, or
anything else that styles you an instructor unless
I indicate otherwise.

Prez

Steve Bartman

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to

And I wasn't talking to you, jackass.

Steve

Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

>ol...@calpha.com (Olivers) wrote in <39199733...@calpha.com>:
>>
>>Oh, you've offered all the proof required.....
>
>I'm sure in your mind I have.
>
><latest attempt at pinning down a misguided characterization,
>laced with sea dog rhetoric, snipped>
>
>>The only thing more despicable than an overweeningly arrogant ensign is
>>the mistreatment he/she receives from the wardroom of which he/she
>>becomes a member.
>
>Accompanying someone on their ego-trip in any
>setting is annoying enough. It's not unique
>to the wardroom or anywhere else. Equally
>annoying is the arrogance expressed by those
>who purport to have some monopoly on experience
>and feel it's their duty to bitterly point out
>the flaws in others. It goes beyond criticism
>to petty jabbing, and I have no intentions of
>backing down when you or anyone else in
>this newsgroup presents themselves to me in
>such a manner.

Well, there you have it Tom, he knows it all and nobody can teach him
anything. The fact that you and I were fighting wars when he was
still wearing three-cornered pants means jackshit to him.

He'll learn. The hard way, I fear.

Greg Yantz

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) writes:

> sbar...@ix.netcom.com (Steve Bartman) wrote in
> <ck9jhsktrfeshqfqa...@4ax.com>:

> >This is one of the more profound responses I've seen in these parts
> >lately. I somehow doubt the target will internalize it. At his age
> >plus a few I also was a jackass ensign, and yes, Peter, and yes, TMO,
> >I learned quite well the torments possible of infliction when one is
> >close confined for many months with jackass hunters.

> >He'll learn, or he'll die. At least wish he could. The universe will
> >move on.

> I once said this to someone else on this board.

> I'm not here for your experience, your advice, or
> anything else that styles you an instructor unless
> I indicate otherwise.

Why are you here?

Aside from to display the chip on your shoulder?

-Greg

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in
<3919cb3d...@news1.mweb.co.za>:

>
>Well, there you have it Tom, he knows it all and nobody can teach him
>anything. The fact that you and I were fighting wars when he was
>still wearing three-cornered pants means jackshit to him.

Exactly.

>He'll learn. The hard way, I fear.

I'm touched.

Prez

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
sbar...@ix.netcom.com (Steve Bartman) wrote in
<jghjhs4shpunhang6...@4ax.com>:

>
>And I wasn't talking to you, jackass.

I was talking to you, so?

Prez

Peter Skelton

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

>eug...@dynagen.co.za (Eugene Griessel) wrote in

><3919cb3d...@news1.mweb.co.za>:
>>
>>Well, there you have it Tom, he knows it all and nobody can teach him
>>anything. The fact that you and I were fighting wars when he was
>>still wearing three-cornered pants means jackshit to him.
>
>Exactly.
>
>>He'll learn. The hard way, I fear.
>
>I'm touched.

I think you can count on that.
--
Peter Skelton

Olivers

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
Eugene Griessel wrote:
>
> rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:
>
> >ol...@calpha.com (Olivers) wrote in <39199733...@calpha.com>:
> >>
> >>Oh, you've offered all the proof required.....
> >
> >I'm sure in your mind I have.
> >
> ><latest attempt at pinning down a misguided characterization,
> >laced with sea dog rhetoric, snipped>
> >
> >>The only thing more despicable than an overweeningly arrogant ensign is
> >>the mistreatment he/she receives from the wardroom of which he/she
> >>becomes a member.
> >
> >Accompanying someone on their ego-trip in any
> >setting is annoying enough. It's not unique
> >to the wardroom or anywhere else. Equally
> >annoying is the arrogance expressed by those
> >who purport to have some monopoly on experience
> >and feel it's their duty to bitterly point out
> >the flaws in others. It goes beyond criticism
> >to petty jabbing, and I have no intentions of
> >backing down when you or anyone else in
> >this newsgroup presents themselves to me in
> >such a manner.
>
> Well, there you have it Tom, he knows it all and nobody can teach him
> anything. The fact that you and I were fighting wars when he was
> still wearing three-cornered pants means jackshit to him.
>
> He'll learn. The hard way, I fear.
>

While I'd just as soon forget the proximity to war part, the four years
at sea and 25 in the reserve did expose me to more than a few boot
ensigns and those about to be (and then I wuz one once). In his
ignorance and the arrogance at least partly bred therefrom, he'll likely
miss the one lesson that experience almost inevitably imparts, the need
to exercise great care in putting one's mouth or fingertips in gear
before one's brain's engaged.

Come sea duty time, in a wardroom large or small, he may experience the
incipient paranoia that results from being shat upon by all those with
whom he sails, his seniors because they will reward his brashness by
filling in every nook and cranny of the watch bill and his juniors
because they will reward his effervescent personality with every
obstacle within their purview.

Steve Bartman

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
On Wed, 10 May 2000 22:45:11 GMT, Olivers <ol...@calpha.com> wrote:
and his juniors
>because they will reward his effervescent personality with every
>obstacle within their purview.

Call out The White Mutiny!!!

Steve

Prof. Vincent Brannigan

unread,
May 10, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/10/00
to
Peter Skelton wrote:
> . Every Texan knows that the more you run over a dead
> cat, the flatter it gets.

Texas tenderizer

>
> Donate the usual fine to the St. Valentine's BBQ. As I assume you'll chose
> that corn varnish remover, deliver it to ViKnce.

Horrible catastrophe, an entire aging warehouse of Wild turkeyjust
burned to the ground. Flaming bourbon went into the local water supply

I'm distraught

Viknce

Paul H. Lemmen

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
Bloody hell boyos, where's the bleedin' SecDet? The damn Ustafish has a
new candidate for MK Sheppards vacant torpedo tube. And don't pickle
him in me poteen stores!
--
Paul H. Lemmen
"Bloc Sprao Agath No Go Maci"
(to the non-Gaelic enabled:"Have fun or get out!")


Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.

DeepSea

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to

Paul H. Lemmen wrote in message <8fcunb$cse$1...@nnrp1.deja.com>...

>Bloody hell boyos, where's the bleedin' SecDet? The damn Ustafish has a
>new candidate for MK Sheppards vacant torpedo tube. And don't pickle
>him in me poteen stores!

Is this some other language for "where's the duct tape? , and don't leave
him in the dry store room"

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
ol...@calpha.com (Olivers) wrote in <391A0239...@calpha.com>:

>
>Come sea duty time, in a wardroom large or small, he may experience the
>incipient paranoia that results from being shat upon by all those with
>whom he sails, his seniors because they will reward his brashness by
>filling in every nook and cranny of the watch bill and his juniors

>because they will reward his effervescent personality with every
>obstacle within their purview.

1) You don't know me.

2) I don't know you, I have no proof you have ever been
onboard a ship, let alone served. If I were to speculate,
I'd say you're probably some kid who's watched Good
Morning Vietnam enough to develop this neat categorization
of junior officers with predictable attitudes. Of course,
I'd probably be wrong--after all, I don't know you.

3) To that end, I suggest you save your advice for someone
who cares.

Prez

Peter Skelton

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
Paul H. Lemmen <PLe...@yahoo.com> wrote:

>Bloody hell boyos, where's the bleedin' SecDet? The damn Ustafish has a
>new candidate for MK Sheppards vacant torpedo tube. And don't pickle
>him in me poteen stores!

This one goes at the bottom of the periscope well/urinal
--
Peter Skelton

Cheng Tseng

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
In article <8F30D56DEre...@18.247.2.125> rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) writes:

>1) You don't know me.

>2) I don't know you, I have no proof you have ever been
>onboard a ship, let alone served. If I were to speculate,
>I'd say you're probably some kid who's watched Good
>Morning Vietnam enough to develop this neat categorization
>of junior officers with predictable attitudes. Of course,
>I'd probably be wrong--after all, I don't know you.

>3) To that end, I suggest you save your advice for someone
>who cares.

Mr. Cannady,

I see that you are currently a second year student (Commonly referred to as a
"sophmore".) at MIT. It is a fine establishment, and you must have possessed
excellent qualifications to receive entrance. For that, and the fact you
intend to serve in the US Navy, I salute you.

Yet, as a person who has been on this newsgroup for a while, and who is about
to finish his undergraduate career, I have been rather disturbed, about your
attitude toward Adam Yoshida. The alarm has only gone-up since your defense
of him/attack on his critics begun appearing on my newsreader.

Mr. Yoshida, is a teenage bigot Canadian of unbelieveable stubborn ignorance,
who also possess a callous disregard for the niceties of human relations, and
an egomanical opinion of himself. That is evident from his postings.

That you apparently do not reach this conclusion after research, indicates you
have not bothered researching Adam Yoshida enough. How could you not say
somebody is nuts when they advocate a stop to illegal immigration by using
F/A-18s to bomb the ships carrying the said immigrants? Most of us here tend
to give poor regard for such an individual.

Furthermore, the opinions of those here regarding Adam Yoshida has come from a
great deal of experience. Yet you seem to downplay the value of such
experience and indeed the total experiences of those who were here long before
you. While you are entitled to do so, do not expect such an attitude, openly
displayed, to go unchallenged. Indeed, you seem to want to incite unpleasant
reactions with snide comments "save your advice for someone who cares." The
fact that most people here has far more knowledge then you do, especially
regarding naval history, seems valueless to you.

In short, while you are qualified enough to get into MIT, it is apparent that
you do not have enough qualifications for real life, where people disagreeing
with you is a common experience. However, since you have not quite displayed
the same level of arrogance, ignorance, and stubbornness as Adam Yoshida,
there still remains some hope for you. I sincerely wish you the best for your
remaining years at MIT, and hope that when you graduate from that
establishment and also be commissioned with as a freshly-minted new ensign in
the USN, you will not just have grown older, but also grown-up.

C.T.


ANDREW BREEN

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
In article <8fcunb$cse$1...@nnrp1.deja.com>,

Paul H. Lemmen <PLe...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>Bloody hell boyos, where's the bleedin' SecDet? The damn Ustafish has a
>new candidate for MK Sheppards vacant torpedo tube. And don't pickle
>him in me poteen stores!

_Vacant_ torpedo tube nothing. He's still in there. And as far as I'm
concerned he's only leaving it with a shot of air behind him.

Respectfully submit that we stuff this one in the same tube as ROB. That
means that we still only have two tubes loaded with munitions prohibited
under the rules laid down by the Geneva convention.

--
Andy Breen ~ PPARC Advanced Research Fellow
Solar Physics Group, U-W Aberystwyth
"Usenet should require licenses;
licenses that can be revoked." (Abigail, in the Monastery)

Presley Cannady

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
Mr. Cheng Tseng:

At no point do I "defend" Adam Yoshida. Any
criticism I would add in that direction would
obviously drown out in the already unnecessarily
large heap of flak the kid's already caught.

I originally asked the question because I was
unsure exactly why he is considered a troll.
A troll has one mission, and that is to deliberately
incite flamewars.

I've participated in other newsgroups that
suffered from greater trolling in this newsgroup
While I do disagree with Yoshida on a
number of his views, I cannot responsibly
push on him a label he really doesn't deserve.

Further research revealed that despite claims
of Yoshida's trolling, group participants
nevertheless refused to treat him as one.
In fact, you treat him just as you describe
him--ignorant, young and bigoted. Yet
at the same time you imply that he sincerely
holds on to these views, and therefore you've
just conceded that Adam Yoshida is not a troll.

That you find his views repugnant does not
puzzle or annoy me. It's perfectly fine by me.
However, what got to me was the immediate
patronizing folks here thought was necessary
in order to convince me of a condition they
demonstratably prove false. Trust me, it's quite
annoying to read through half a dozen emails
by people you've never met in real life speculating
on what direction your life will take. It's
also very annoying when these absolute strangers
assume their "experience" (of which I have no proof)
somehow validates their insulting approaches.
I'm young, but I'm not a child nor I
definitely did I come enjoy a sheltered childhood.
I don't downplay the experiences of others posting here.
At this point in the discussion, their experiences have
little value to me. If I have use of their experience
in the future, and hopefully it's still available,
then I'll happily listen. However, in a discussion
that has evolved to newsgroup participants downplaying
MY experiences without any concept of who I am or
where I'm coming from, I feel compelled to defend
myself. Since all of you are, in reality, absolute
strangers, I have nothing to prove to you. So, I
suggest you simply stop speculating about me, MIT,
my choice in career, and anything similar. For all
you know, I might be in NROTC only for the tuition.
After all, unlike Adam Yoshida, I haven't written
at length about my intentions to defend the United
States with my life...

Prez

ANDREW BREEN

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
In article <wxnS4.58767$fV.36...@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>,

DeepSea <deep...@mydeja.com> wrote:
>
>Paul H. Lemmen wrote in message <8fcunb$cse$1...@nnrp1.deja.com>...
>>Bloody hell boyos, where's the bleedin' SecDet? The damn Ustafish has a
>>new candidate for MK Sheppards vacant torpedo tube. And don't pickle
>>him in me poteen stores!
>
>Is this some other language for "where's the duct tape? , and don't leave
>him in the dry store room"

SecDet seem to be delayed, but the Duct Apes are on their way. They know
what to do in these circumstances.

--
Andy Breen ~ PPARC Advanced Research Fellow

Solar Physics Group, UW Aberystwyth
Silliness is the last refuge of the doomed: P. Opus

Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
a...@aber.ac.uk (ANDREW BREEN) wrote:

>In article <8fcunb$cse$1...@nnrp1.deja.com>,
>Paul H. Lemmen <PLe...@yahoo.com> wrote:

>>Bloody hell boyos, where's the bleedin' SecDet? The damn Ustafish has a
>>new candidate for MK Sheppards vacant torpedo tube. And don't pickle
>>him in me poteen stores!
>

>_Vacant_ torpedo tube nothing. He's still in there. And as far as I'm
>concerned he's only leaving it with a shot of air behind him.
>
>Respectfully submit that we stuff this one in the same tube as ROB. That
>means that we still only have two tubes loaded with munitions prohibited
>under the rules laid down by the Geneva convention.

I'll have is collection of Japanese porn pictures, please! Only for
the artistic value of course!

ANDREW BREEN

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
In article <cxt217.130...@psu.edu>, Cheng Tseng <cxt...@psu.edu> wrote:
>In article <8F30D56DEre...@18.247.2.125> rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) writes:

/wibble wibble wibble/


>I see that you are currently a second year student (Commonly referred to as a
>"sophmore".) at MIT. It is a fine establishment

Last time I was there I was geting hints of a possible job offer, so they
must be good ;)

They're a good place though - I only know the space physics group there,
but they are _very_ good indeed. Which reminds me that I need to send them
some data..

>Mr. Yoshida, is a teenage bigot Canadian of unbelieveable stubborn ignorance,
>who also possess a callous disregard for the niceties of human relations, and
>an egomanical opinion of himself. That is evident from his postings.
>

What I find "interesting" to the point of scary is that _Adam_ has been
conspicuously more sane, rational and polite than has Mr Cannardy.

We must be having some kind of good influence on him (though dear gods it's
taken long enough..)


--
Andy Breen ~ PPARC Advanced Research Fellow, Interplanetary Scintillation


Solar Physics Group, UW Aberystwyth

"When I was young I used to scintillate
now I only sin 'til ten past three" (Ogden Nash)

Adam Yoshida

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
On 10 May 2000 17:21:12 -0400, Greg Yantz <ran...@mit.edu> wrote:

>rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) writes:
>
>> sbar...@ix.netcom.com (Steve Bartman) wrote in

>> <ck9jhsktrfeshqfqa...@4ax.com>:
>
>> >This is one of the more profound responses I've seen in these parts
>> >lately. I somehow doubt the target will internalize it. At his age
>> >plus a few I also was a jackass ensign, and yes, Peter, and yes, TMO,
>> >I learned quite well the torments possible of infliction when one is
>> >close confined for many months with jackass hunters.
>
>> >He'll learn, or he'll die. At least wish he could. The universe will
>> >move on.
>
>> I once said this to someone else on this board.
>
>> I'm not here for your experience, your advice, or
>> anything else that styles you an instructor unless
>> I indicate otherwise.
>
>Why are you here?
>
>Aside from to display the chip on your shoulder?
>
>-Greg

This thread is insane. Let him be.

Adam Yoshida

"Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice, and moderation in the pursuit of Justice is no virtue"
-Barry Goldwater

Adam Yoshida

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
On 11 May 2000 01:02:23 GMT, rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:

>ol...@calpha.com (Olivers) wrote in <391A0239...@calpha.com>:
>>
>>Come sea duty time, in a wardroom large or small, he may experience the
>>incipient paranoia that results from being shat upon by all those with
>>whom he sails, his seniors because they will reward his brashness by
>>filling in every nook and cranny of the watch bill and his juniors
>>because they will reward his effervescent personality with every
>>obstacle within their purview.
>

>1) You don't know me.
>
>2) I don't know you, I have no proof you have ever been
>onboard a ship, let alone served. If I were to speculate,
>I'd say you're probably some kid who's watched Good
>Morning Vietnam enough to develop this neat categorization
>of junior officers with predictable attitudes. Of course,
>I'd probably be wrong--after all, I don't know you.

It's pretty clear to me that TMoliver has a long history of service.
He's spoken about serving on a CV back in '61 or so.

Eugene Griessel

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
adamy...@home.com (Adam Yoshida) wrote:
>
>It's pretty clear to me that TMoliver has a long history of service.
>He's spoken about serving on a CV back in '61 or so.

Please stop this nonsense! We are beginning to like you!

Random

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
On Tue, 9 May 2000 09:10:30 -0600, "Glenn Dowdy"
<glenn...@agilent.com> wrote:

>Eugene Griessel wrote in message <3918134e...@news1.mweb.co.za>...
>>rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) wrote:
>>
>>>lo...@inlink.com (loki) wrote in <zyLR4.3366$Xc.1...@news1.primary.net>:
>>>
>>>>This child (and I'm a grandmother so to me this *is* a child)
>>>
>>>I'm sorry, but you're going to have to do better than
>>>that to impress me. I've never met you. Having
>>>grown up in projects where grandmothers were as young as
>>>thirty years old and still lacking common sense.
>>>
>>>>has too much time on his hands.
>>>>
>>>>*plonk*
>>>>
>>>>Loki
>>>
>>>You seem to be easily upset there for a
>>>grandmother, Loki.
>>>
>>>Prez
>>
>>Just who the hell are you, Prez, to waft in here and be so damned
>>critical, censorious and self-righteous?
>>
>
>He's a college boy Navy ROTC midshipman at MIT, evidently greatly impressed
>by his own ability to write long, rambling and sesquipedalian posts.
>Sophomore, I'd guess. Prez, you smoke a pipe now?
>
Geesh! I thought he was the CNO!

random

Cheng Tseng

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to
In article <8F319C18re...@18.247.2.125> rev...@mit.edu (Presley Cannady) writes:

<snip>

>Further research revealed that despite claims
>of Yoshida's trolling, group participants
>nevertheless refused to treat him as one.
>In fact, you treat him just as you describe
>him--ignorant, young and bigoted. Yet
>at the same time you imply that he sincerely
>holds on to these views, and therefore you've
>just conceded that Adam Yoshida is not a troll.

A point need to made is that Adam Yoshida is actually WORSE then a troll. He
believes his own ideas, despite overwhelming evidence and argument to the
contrary.

He also seem not to understand that somethings that he advocates are wrong,
wrong, wrong.

>That you find his views repugnant does not
>puzzle or annoy me. It's perfectly fine by me.
>However, what got to me was the immediate
>patronizing folks here thought was necessary
>in order to convince me of a condition they
>demonstratably prove false. Trust me, it's quite
>annoying to read through half a dozen emails
>by people you've never met in real life speculating
>on what direction your life will take. It's
>also very annoying when these absolute strangers
>assume their "experience" (of which I have no proof)
>somehow validates their insulting approaches.
>I'm young, but I'm not a child nor I
>definitely did I come enjoy a sheltered childhood.

Valid, but on sci.military.naval, the posters treat people like Yoshida the
way we treat trolls, irrational battleship advocates, and nationalistic
extremists the same way.

Furthermore, we want to educate newcomers to the group on what NOT to do.
There is much that can be said about this technique, true, but there is also
something to suggest that it would have been better if you sent an email to
Adam Yoshida, to get his personal take, before a UseNet posting. Likewise, if
you had read his past, you might have gotten a very good idea of people's
reaction to him.


<snip>

>my choice in career, and anything similar. For all
>you know, I might be in NROTC only for the tuition.

Pardon me? Are you simply taking the college program, or are you actually
taking money from the government.

>After all, unlike Adam Yoshida, I haven't written
>at length about my intentions to defend the United
>States with my life...

Which is odd, because Yoshida is NOT a citizen, or a resident, of the US.

C.T.

David Crompton

unread,
May 11, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/11/00
to

Presley Cannady wrote:

> I'm not here for your experience, your advice, or
> anything else that styles you an instructor unless
> I indicate otherwise.

Why are you here then? This forum exists to share knowledge and educate to
discuss and absorb new ideas. You railed against us at our suposed
attitude to bam bam yoshida, yet u are currently displaying the very
attributes you accuse us of.

As to your whinging of our treatment of Adam and now you, it is because
you have failed the one basic requirement we ask of ppl...learn, take on
board new ideas. We dislike Adam precisely because he consistently fails
to learn or listen to better, more knowlegable ppl on specific subjects.,
i.e. his love of BB's and instant warfare on every situation tension
arises.

After a time of giving refutations to the same ppl about the same
subjects, the educating process becomes pointless because all parties know
the knowledge you are trying to impart is not going to be taken on board,
consequently such ppl get the treatment they r deemed to deserve, in
Adam's case...ridicule and contempt.

Im only a yr or 2 out of Uni with degrees and Masters and held views
somewhat closer to Adam than I do now, purely because in the intervening
yrs Ive gone to work in the defense industry and learnt the difference
between fantasy and practicality and getting to know exactly just how much
damage the weapons I help design and build can do and also the cost of
using them! Practical experience sobers you up to the realities of life.
Wars and armed forces cost money and they cost life, these things seemed
to have passed Adam by.

ok ta
DAvid
BAE SYSTEMS
Aber Uni


It is loading more messages.
0 new messages