Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Repairing a Celestion 15 inch speaker?

2 views
Skip to first unread message

N Cook

unread,
Dec 5, 2006, 5:28:09 AM12/5/06
to
Someone threw something at this speaker in a Carlsbro Cobra combo.
It works with distortion.
By digital probing (using my fingers) at about 4 o'clock position ,
unpowered, the rubbing resistance feel to movement of the cone disappears.
Same if powered up, no distortion, to a power level where the effect of my
fingers damping comes into play.
Is there a liquid that will contract on drying to paint radial stripe on
cone and dry and test, repeated until problem goes plus one or two more
stripes.?
Or would freeing the rim or part of the rim of the cone by hot-air heationg
and reseating all or part be better.
If part then release 2 to 6 o'clock say and pull or 8 to 12 o'clock and
push, my guess is pull would be better.
Any other ideas? rather than throwing out at this stage, if it doesn't work
then just lost a bit of time and learnt a bit maybe.

--
Diverse Devices, Southampton, England
electronic hints and repair briefs , schematics/manuals list on
http://home.graffiti.net/diverse:graffiti.net/

mike.j...@gmail.com

unread,
Dec 5, 2006, 7:02:05 AM12/5/06
to

N Cook wrote:

> Is there a liquid that will contract on drying to paint radial stripe on
> cone and dry and test, repeated until problem goes plus one or two more
> stripes.?

I have heard of minor cone tears being treated with ladies nail
varnish. Professional reconing is an option. Celestion still exist as a
company and may be able to advise

Arfa Daily

unread,
Dec 5, 2006, 8:37:20 AM12/5/06
to

<mike.j...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1165320125.2...@73g2000cwn.googlegroups.com...

If it's a pressed steel frame, you can sometimes recover such
location-specific voice coil drags, by deliberately distorting the frame in
the opposite way, so that the cone is recentralised. Crude, but often
effective.

Arfa


meow...@care2.com

unread,
Dec 5, 2006, 9:20:26 AM12/5/06
to
N Cook wrote:

> Someone threw something at this speaker in a Carlsbro Cobra combo.
> It works with distortion.
> By digital probing (using my fingers) at about 4 o'clock position ,
> unpowered, the rubbing resistance feel to movement of the cone disappears.
> Same if powered up, no distortion, to a power level where the effect of my
> fingers damping comes into play.
> Is there a liquid that will contract on drying to paint radial stripe on
> cone and dry and test, repeated until problem goes plus one or two more
> stripes.?
> Or would freeing the rim or part of the rim of the cone by hot-air heationg
> and reseating all or part be better.
> If part then release 2 to 6 o'clock say and pull or 8 to 12 o'clock and
> push, my guess is pull would be better.
> Any other ideas? rather than throwing out at this stage, if it doesn't work
> then just lost a bit of time and learnt a bit maybe.

the solution is to move the cone assembly sideways a tiny bit, not at
the rim but near the centre. If you can unfix thespider and then centre
it, problem solved. If not, other than reconing, putting sideways force
onto the cone assembly can bodge it and make it work ok. This is done
by makeing a hook shape and sinking the short sharp end of it into the
spider, and pulling and fixing to the frame. Its a bodge, but you might
want to do it to try to avoid a recone.

Dont repair cone damage with rigid materials like nail varnish, the
varnish etc will break after a bit and then the whole thing sounds
terrible. Always use a flexible glue. It does need to be a strong glue.


NT

N Cook

unread,
Dec 5, 2006, 9:40:53 AM12/5/06
to
Arfa Daily <arfa....@ntlworld.com> wrote in message
news:kCedh.2$Ng...@newsfe1-win.ntli.net...

Didn't expect it to be so easy.
The central dome was buckled in. Drilling a few 1mm holes
and using a dental sickle brobe managed to pull it back into reasonable
shape.
Somehow that corrected things, just a small puncture in the cone periphery
to patch over now.

meow...@care2.com

unread,
Dec 5, 2006, 12:08:23 PM12/5/06
to
N Cook wrote:

> Didn't expect it to be so easy.
> The central dome was buckled in. Drilling a few 1mm holes
> and using a dental sickle brobe managed to pull it back into reasonable
> shape.
> Somehow that corrected things, just a small puncture in the cone periphery
> to patch over now.

I trust youve sealed up the little holes, that needs doing else muck
gets in the very tight spaces between cone and pole magnet and the
speaker's then stuffed.


NT

Dave Curtis

unread,
Dec 5, 2006, 5:30:44 PM12/5/06
to
On Tue, 5 Dec 2006 14:40:53 -0000, "N Cook" <dive...@gazeta.pl>
wrote:

>Arfa Daily <arfa....@ntlworld.com> wrote in message
>news:kCedh.2$Ng...@newsfe1-win.ntli.net...
>>
>> <mike.j...@gmail.com> wrote in message
>> news:1165320125.2...@73g2000cwn.googlegroups.com...
>> >
>> > N Cook wrote:
>> >
>> >> Is there a liquid that will contract on drying to paint radial stripe
>on
>> >> cone and dry and test, repeated until problem goes plus one or two more
>> >> stripes.?
>> >
>> > I have heard of minor cone tears being treated with ladies nail
>> > varnish. Professional reconing is an option. Celestion still exist as a
>> > company and may be able to advise
>> >
>>
>> If it's a pressed steel frame, you can sometimes recover such
>> location-specific voice coil drags, by deliberately distorting the frame
>in
>> the opposite way, so that the cone is recentralised. Crude, but often
>> effective.
>>
>> Arfa
>>
>>
>
>Didn't expect it to be so easy.
>The central dome was buckled in. Drilling a few 1mm holes
>and using a dental sickle brobe managed to pull it back into reasonable
>shape.
>Somehow that corrected things, just a small puncture in the cone periphery
>to patch over now.


Try to find some Plio-bond. Apply it to the edges of the tear with a
toothpick and carefully fit the tear back together. If you have a
small piece missing, make up a patch to fit using construction paper
and glue it in place. You said puncture, so I'm thinking all the paper
is still there.

Don't use Elmer's glue or nail polish; they're not very flexible when
they dry.
-Dave

hrho...@att.net

unread,
Dec 6, 2006, 12:45:34 AM12/6/06
to
Stiff glue is fine if the part of the speaker where it is used is
stiff, it is only around the flexible periphery that the stiff glue
should not be used.

H. R. Hofmann

Dave Curtis

unread,
Dec 6, 2006, 7:27:39 AM12/6/06
to
On 5 Dec 2006 21:45:34 -0800, "hrho...@att.net" <hrho...@att.net>
wrote:

>Stiff glue is fine if the part of the speaker where it is used is
>stiff, it is only around the flexible periphery that the stiff glue
>should not be used.
>
>H. R. Hofmann

Actually, many parts of the cone that seem stiff will flex quite a bit
when the speaker is driven hard, not just the surround.

-Dave

OLDFART

unread,
Dec 6, 2006, 12:09:51 PM12/6/06
to

>>> Don't use Elmer's glue or nail polish; they're not very flexible when
>>> they dry.


At EAW before they got, um, 'LOUD', we used to treat 5" mid
speakers with a 95%/5% mix of Elmer's and water. The water
would break up the Elmer's enough to flex. Later, we found
another 'wood based' glue (forget the name) and did the same
mix ratio, with alot better results. I used an old 78 turntable
I'd place the speaker on, and set it at 16...and paint..faintly.

The folks at RCF speakers came over, saw the setup and told
me they did the SAME turntable trick in Italy. AWESOME folks..

This 5" speaker would then drive the wood formed mid 'horn'
of the cab, and increased mid range response big time.

KF at EAW is on the level of Leo N Jim, HP and D Reeves,
or any other ICON in this business. Great guy, taught me alot.

Taught me how to re-cone speakers in mass qualities..the right way..


JJTj

www.oldfartdays.com

I am frolicsome, I am easy,
Good tempered and free,
And I don't give a single pin' me boys
What the world thinks of me.

meow...@care2.com

unread,
Dec 6, 2006, 6:24:03 PM12/6/06
to
OLDFART wrote:

> At EAW before they got, um, 'LOUD', we used to treat 5" mid
> speakers with a 95%/5% mix of Elmer's and water. The water
> would break up the Elmer's enough to flex. Later, we found
> another 'wood based' glue (forget the name) and did the same
> mix ratio, with alot better results. I used an old 78 turntable
> I'd place the speaker on, and set it at 16...and paint..faintly.
>
> The folks at RCF speakers came over, saw the setup and told
> me they did the SAME turntable trick in Italy. AWESOME folks..
>
> This 5" speaker would then drive the wood formed mid 'horn'
> of the cab, and increased mid range response big time.
>
> KF at EAW is on the level of Leo N Jim, HP and D Reeves,
> or any other ICON in this business. Great guy, taught me alot.
>
> Taught me how to re-cone speakers in mass qualities..the right way..
>
>
> JJTj

Why not just brush paint it in situ? Thats what I did, cba these days
though.

Re somene elses comments earlier, all parts of the cone assembly flex
in use, just some more than others.


NT

meow...@care2.com

unread,
Dec 6, 2006, 6:24:13 PM12/6/06
to
OLDFART wrote:

> At EAW before they got, um, 'LOUD', we used to treat 5" mid
> speakers with a 95%/5% mix of Elmer's and water. The water
> would break up the Elmer's enough to flex. Later, we found
> another 'wood based' glue (forget the name) and did the same
> mix ratio, with alot better results. I used an old 78 turntable
> I'd place the speaker on, and set it at 16...and paint..faintly.
>
> The folks at RCF speakers came over, saw the setup and told
> me they did the SAME turntable trick in Italy. AWESOME folks..
>
> This 5" speaker would then drive the wood formed mid 'horn'
> of the cab, and increased mid range response big time.
>
> KF at EAW is on the level of Leo N Jim, HP and D Reeves,
> or any other ICON in this business. Great guy, taught me alot.
>
> Taught me how to re-cone speakers in mass qualities..the right way..
>
>
> JJTj

Why not just brush paint it in situ? Thats what I did, cba these days

0 new messages