On 1/6/2022 10:29 AM, bitrex wrote:
> On 1/6/22 11:50 AM, Don Y wrote:
>> Advice on good ("respectable") candidates for the above?
>> Not keen on a guitar-wannabe "instrument"...
>>
>> (Also, not keen on anything that will not be able to
>> completely restore axe to original condition when no
>> longer needed/wanted)
>
> If you want to add a thing to add to a regular electric guitar to get
> polyphonic MIDI output without modifying the guitar significantly I think it
> limits the options to something like the hex pickups you can non-destructively
> mount:
But, are they truly nondestructive? Some seem to rely on adhesives and
I'm not sure folks USING adhesives ever really think of them "long term"
(residue, staining, etc.)
I've also seen a product or two that look at the *audio* and try to reconstruct
the fingering from that. Theoretically possible but a fair bit of work to
accomplish in real-time. Not sure how that latency stacks up with the
rest of the processing chain...
> Then you'll need something to convert the hex signal to MIDI output and there
> are solutions that come with sounds and some without e.g. this package:
No need for synth; just treat the instrument as an "input device with a
familiar feel".
> Different companies have made a number of boxes like that over the years in
> pedal and rackmount form. I have a Yamaha G50 rack unit that you can plug the
> Roland hex pickup into it's just a MIDI converter, no onboard sounds. It's
> about 25 years old but still works very well with pretty low latency when you
> get it adjusted, IIRC the selling point at the time is that it uses a neural
> network to detect notes before a full cycle has elapsed; even on the low E of a
> guitar (much less a bass) if you wait a whole cycle it introduces objectionable
> latency. I expect nowadays the good systems all have their own proprietary
> algorithms for that.
I imagine some of the guitar-wannabes can play tricks that aren't
feasible with a real guitar. OTOH, it's hard not to interfere with the
"feel" -- even if only approximated.
(Driving a car and driving a car in a video game -- using a cheesy
steering wheel controller and foot pedals -- are entirely different
experiences!)
> There are probably other systems that's just the setup I'm most familiar with.
>
> GraphTech makes an all-in-one where the hex pickup is integrated into a hard
> tail or Floyd Rose bridge and you can add a piezo amplifier for pseudo-acoustic
> sounds and/or a hex driver for MIDI conversion internally to the guitar. that
> can be an expensive way to go, the bespoke Floyd Rose is almost $300 and the
> electronics is another $300, kinda absurd for what you get which is a bare PCB
> with pin-headers and about $5 worth of components:
Yeah, I suspect there is a fair bit of "overhead" in these products
as none of the companies appear to be The Next Apple (in terms of
profits).
Thanks, I'll look into the items/technologies you mentioned.