Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

propane OK for use in Bunsen burners?

1,830 views
Skip to first unread message

Reed Hall

unread,
Jun 22, 2001, 1:30:30 PM6/22/01
to
Just wondering whether it'd be okay to hook up a Bunsen burner to a
propane tank (the kind which fuels backyard BBQ grills) for use in
amateur experiments in a home lab? Any reasons why this might be a bad
idea? No convenient natural gas outlets in my basement....

If there are Bunsen burner models made specifically for propane use,
what might the differences be between it and the regular kind... and how
important would it really be to use one?

Dr. Artem Evdokimov

unread,
Jun 22, 2001, 2:40:16 PM6/22/01
to
As long as you know what you're doing i.e. as long as you

a) have a good reduction valve (two step)
b) use proper tubing
c) use backfire trap
d) place the tank far, far away from whereever you are planning to use
the gas.

It may end up being easier to hook up your bunsen to a normal gas line
(unless you live in an all-electrical house that is).

Since you are doing your stuff in the basement, you would be well
advised to actively ventilate your work area because in a small,
confined room whatever fumes/gaseous substances etc. you will be
generating can quickly become very concentrated. A make-it-yourself
ventilated hood is even better as long as you pipe the exhaust out on
the roof.

A.

--
|Dr. Artem Evdokimov Protein Engineering |
| NCI-Frederick Tel. (301)846-5401 |
| FAX (301)846-7148 |
| eudo...@mail.ncifcrf.gov |
| http://www.ncifcrf.gov/plague |

Reed Hall

unread,
Jun 22, 2001, 3:18:17 PM6/22/01
to

"Dr. Artem Evdokimov" wrote:

> As long as you know what you're doing i.e. as long as you
>
> a) have a good reduction valve (two step)
> b) use proper tubing
> c) use backfire trap
> d) place the tank far, far away from whereever you are planning to use
> the gas.

Uh-oh. I have no idea what a reduction valve (two-step or otherwise) or a
backfire trap is. Are they present in high school chem labs? I don't want to
blow myself or my basement up... if I find a Bunsen burner that says it is
specifically made for LP, should I be okay, or do I need to look for these
extra gadgets too? Thanks!

Tore T Stubhaug

unread,
Jun 22, 2001, 4:16:53 PM6/22/01
to
Reed Hall wrote:
>
> Uh-oh. I have no idea what a reduction valve (two-step or otherwise) or a
> backfire trap is.

In that case, why don't you just buy a camping gas stove? They're small
and safe, and they wour just as fine as Bunsen burners.

BjornP

unread,
Jun 22, 2001, 5:53:12 PM6/22/01
to
I sell electronic bunsenburners in Europe. They come with 3 different
nozzles, for the different gas types.
If you are using propane for your BB you already have the reduction valve on
your bottle/gashose.

You might get problems adjusting the flame properly if your nozzle is not
the correct one.

--
Visit
http://www.search4science.as/scholarship/scholarship.html

and find out how to participate in a USD 10.000 scholarship.
Test our pat.pend Dynamic Search

BjornP

Dr. Artem Evdokimov

unread,
Jun 22, 2001, 9:30:14 PM6/22/01
to
Reduction valve is the device that lowers the pressure of the gas from
whatever it is in the tank to whatever you need to safely feed your
burner. As one of the previous posters mentioned, it is very likely that
you already have one, if you are using your tank with a grill etc. Same
goes for the hose - you probably already have the hose that is good to
use with propane.

Back-flame suppressor is an inline gizmo that prevents the flame from
traveling backwards through the tubes. While the possibility of this is
remote, it is a good idea to have it because having one's body parts
horribly burnt is a jolly bad thing indeed. Most grills and barbeques
have these (or at least, they should!). You might be able to get away
without one as long as you a) make sure that your hose does not let
oxygen in and b) always purge your line with pure gas before lighting
the fire.

In general, I heartily agree with the other poster who advised you to
just use a portable gas burner - I think I saw one sold for under $20.

Artem

V-man

unread,
Jun 25, 2001, 9:14:51 AM6/25/01
to

lol, he said LP in his post. You should go to a hardware store. They sell
hoses for the BBQ so you can hook it up with the large tank. Costs from 10
to 20$. Don't buy small propane tanks, they are a waste of money.

And I think the bunsen can be adjusted for propane (the valve) so should
not be a problem.

V-man

Lucius Chiaraviglio

unread,
Jun 27, 2001, 3:05:04 AM6/27/01
to
"Dr. Artem Evdokimov" <eudo...@mail.ncifcrf.gov> wrote:
>> Just wondering whether it'd be okay to hook up a Bunsen burner to a
>> propane tank (the kind which fuels backyard BBQ grills) for use in
>> amateur experiments in a home lab? Any reasons why this might be a bad
>> idea? No convenient natural gas outlets in my basement....
>>[. . .]
>[. . .]

>Since you are doing your stuff in the basement, you would be well
>advised to actively ventilate your work area because in a small,
>confined room whatever fumes/gaseous substances etc. you will be
>generating can quickly become very concentrated. A make-it-yourself
>ventilated hood is even better as long as you pipe the exhaust out on
>the roof.

Not only that, but remember that propane is heavier than air, so if
your cutoff valve leaks, the propane will tend to accumulate in the basement
(and in particular, near the floor, and thus near to the air intakes for
combustion chambers of furnaces and hot water heaters) rather than leaking out
through the ceiling of the basement as natural gas would; for the same reason,
people upstairs are less likely to smell it before something bad happens. It
is better to do this kind of thing in a garage that is not below ground level,
provided that you back the car(s) out, keep the door open, and do not store
large quantities of flammable liquids in the garage.

--
Lucius Chiaraviglio
New e-mail address is approximately: lucius1@telo_large_urban_area.com
To get the exact address: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Replace indicated characters with common 4-letter word meaning the same thing
and remove underscores (Spambots of Doom, take that!).

Joe Cummings

unread,
Jun 30, 2001, 3:31:50 AM6/30/01
to

Last time I bought a cooker, I was supplied with two kinds of
injectors - these are the small nozzles at the base of the jets. One
for methane, one for a LPG.

I'm nearly certain that you can buy Bunsen burners for either
LPG or methane ("town gas" in the UK.), or equipped with two sets of
injectors .

Ask your supplier.

Have fun,

Joe Cummings
>

Lucius Chiaraviglio

unread,
Jul 1, 2001, 3:23:39 AM7/1/01
to
[I am reposting this because it did not appear on news.telocity.com even 6
days after posting. Apologies if this appears twice.]

"Dr. Artem Evdokimov" <eudo...@mail.ncifcrf.gov> wrote:

>> Just wondering whether it'd be okay to hook up a Bunsen burner to a
>> propane tank (the kind which fuels backyard BBQ grills) for use in
>> amateur experiments in a home lab? Any reasons why this might be a bad
>> idea? No convenient natural gas outlets in my basement....

>>[. . .]
>[. . .]

>Since you are doing your stuff in the basement, you would be well
>advised to actively ventilate your work area because in a small,
>confined room whatever fumes/gaseous substances etc. you will be
>generating can quickly become very concentrated. A make-it-yourself
>ventilated hood is even better as long as you pipe the exhaust out on
>the roof.

Not only that, but remember that propane is heavier than air, so if

Dopefish

unread,
Jul 3, 2001, 2:47:16 AM7/3/01
to
Lucius Chiaraviglio <lucius1@telo_large_urban_area.com> wrote in message
news:3b3ecff6...@news.telocity.com...

> [I am reposting this because it did not appear on news.telocity.com even 6
> days after posting. Apologies if this appears twice.]
>

<snip>

man, you really need a different news server (check out www.mailops.com)

fish

--
begin OE-fishsig.sig
------BEGIN SIGNATURE------
A.K.A "Dopefish" or "fish" for short on Usenet.

Microsoft? Is that some kind of toilet paper?

-----BEGIN GEEK CODE BLOCK-----
Version: 3.12
GO dpu s++:++ a---- C++++ U--->UL
P L+ E? W++ N+++ o+ K--- w+>w+++++
O--- M-- V? PS+++ PE Y-- PGP t 5--
X+ R tv b+ DI D+ G-- e- h! r z
------END GEEK CODE BLOCK------
(www.geekcode.com)

------END SIGNATURE------
`
end


0 new messages