Pandora wrote:
> >Humans didn't evolve in any specific place.
> Yes they did, they evolved on planet Earth, an insignificant pale blue
Aw, did that trigger your troll button?
You're not interested in discussion, on ever in enforcement of your
dogma.
> Within the confines of that tiny place 5 of the 7 million years of
> human evolution
Cites?
So they're claiming to find Homo here:
https://goo.gl/maps/savJk3gSZtxPTyzf6
Well that's precisely where Homo would be if it was moving to OR
FROM Asia.
You have to be trained, like on of Pavlov's dogs, to not see it. The
location fits both models.
Problem is, and you're proving this, that if you read ONE cite you
think you know, but if you read two or more suddenly you're not
sure anymore:
https://popular-archaeology.com/article/the-remarkable-skulls-of-drimolen/
: the small skull was that of a hominin, not of a baboon, as had previously
: been suggested along with buck, hyaena, and others.
And if you add reading comprehension into the mix -- read it in context --
NOBODY saw an erectus skull. Absolutely nobody. A lot of people looked
at it and didn't even see a primate!
AND EVEN IN YOUR OWN CITE, if you had bothered to read it, what it
actually says is:
: The DNH 134 cranium shares clear affinities with Homo erectus
But you think you know. Because you read a cite. Or at least read a
headline but, hey, why go further, right?
"Science!"
> as well the oldest known representatives of Homo sapiens:
Homo sapiens heidelbergensis?
Homo sapiens neanderthalensis?
>
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-04275-8
Again, exactly where they should be if they were going to OR COMING
FROM Asia...
But you're trained well. Very well.
>
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature22335
This doesn't fit any model that you think you're defending.
Neither are saying anything definitive.
You can claim they are CONSISTENT WITH a favored model... models.
That's the best science -- real science -- can usually offer for any one piece
of the evidence.
"Amongst the models this evidence is consistent with would me the one that
I avocate."
Big deal.
-- --
https://jtem.tumblr.com/post/675871863173480448