R7RS Red Edition balloting is complete

20 views
Skip to first unread message

John Cowan

unread,
Jul 20, 2016, 11:27:35 AM7/20/16
to scheme-re...@googlegroups.com, scheme-re...@googlegroups.com, chez-...@groups.google.com, chibi-...@groups.google.com, chicke...@lists.nongnu.org, chicken...@lists.nongnu.org, comp.lan...@groups.google.com
The R7RS Red Edition ballot is now complete, with 28 votes counted.

* All unopposed SRFIs passed except 129 (titlecase).

* SRFI 125 (backward compatible with SRFI 69, but not with R6RS) passed.

* SRFI 135 (immutable texts) passed despite last-minute competition from
SRFI 140.

* For a (mutable) string library, there was no majority vote.
"No library" had a plurality, but SRFI 13 and SRFI 130 jointly outvoted
it, so the question will be reballoted.

* The returns are visible at http://tinyurl.com/wg2-red-results

* Corrections and changes (but not new ballots) will be accepted
by email to me or scheme-reports-wg2@ for 24 hours, so these
results are not final.

Lists: SRFI 1 passed 28-0.
Vectors: SRFI 132 passed 27-1.
Strings: No library: 12, SRFI 13: 9, SRFI 130: 5
Sorting: SRFI 132 passed with 23 votes, 2 for R6RS, 2 for No library.
Sets/bags: SRFI 113 passed 20-5.
Character sets: SRFI 14 passed 22-2.
Hash tables: SRFI 125 passed with 19, SRFI 126: 4, R6RS: 3, SRFI 69: 1
Immutable pairs: SRFI 116 passed 12-9.
Random access pairs: SRFI 101 passed 13-9.
Immutable deques: SRFI 134 passed 20-3.
Immutable texts: SRFI 135 passed with 14, SRFI 140: 6, No library: 4.
Generators: SRFI 121 passed 17-5.
Lazy sequences: SRFI 127 passed 15-7.
Streams: SRFI 41 passed 22-2.
Boxes: SRFI 111 passed 19-4.
List queues: SRFI 117 passed 16-5.
Ephemerons: SRFI 124 passed 17-5
Titlecase: SRFI 129 failed 11-13.
Comparators: SRFI 128 passed 21-6 by imputed votes.

--
weirdo: When is R7RS coming out?
Riastradh: As soon as the top is a beautiful golden brown and if you
stick a toothpick in it, the toothpick comes out dry.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages