The Ethiopia Campaign

[rc...@mailinator.com]

The Ethiopia Campaign
After fighting neglected diseases in Africa for a quarter century,
former president Jimmy Carter takes on one of the continent's biggest
killers-malaria

By Robert M. Poole

Join a live chat with President Carter to discuss this article on June
28 at 11:15 a.m., E.S.T. Click here to submit a question.

His once-sandy hair had gone all white; his shoulders were a bit more
stooped; his freckled face was lined with new creases. But Jimmy
Carter's 82 years had diminished neither his trademark smile, which
could still disarm skeptics at 20 paces, nor his enthusiasm for the
long chance, which had propelled this obscure peanut farmer to
national prominence in the first place. That quixotic spirit took him
this past February to an impoverished corner of Ethiopia, where he
would announce his most audacious crusade yet: to eliminate malaria,
an elusive and ever-changing killer, from this ancient African nation
of 75 million people.

Now rare in developed countries, the disease kills more than a million
victims each year in the world's poorest regions. At least 300 million
people worldwide are incapacitated by malaria infections. The
disease's aches, fever, chills and other flu-like symptoms not only
inhibit economic productivity but also suppress immune systems in its
victims, making them more susceptible to tuberculosis and AIDS-both of
which kill even more people than malaria does-and other life-
threatening ailments.

"We can control malaria-absolutely," Carter was saying, standing in
the dusty courtyard of a clinic in the village of Afeta. Vultures
wheeled overhead, and farmers in faded clothes lined up to receive new
mosquito nets from the hands of the former president. Dressed in a
blue plaid shirt and blue jeans festooned with a silver "J.C." belt
buckle, Carter noticed an old woman struggling to unpack her net. He
pulled out a pocketknife, sliced open the heavy plastic packaging and
presented the net to her. "There you are," he said, flashing the
smile.

The nets, treated with long-lasting insecticide, cost $5 each, but the
villagers got them free, courtesy of the Atlanta-based Carter Center,
the Ethiopian government and a host of other donors. While the
villagers collected their nets, an entourage of reporters, documentary
filmmakers, Secret Service agents and Ethiopian health workers got a
malaria lecture from the one-term president and Nobel Peace Prize
winner, who had been making foreign forays like this one-to fight
disease, monitor elections and defuse international conflict-since
founding the Carter Center with his wife, Rosalynn, in 1982.

"Most of those who die from malaria are little children, 1 to 5 years
old," Carter said as villagers huddled nearby, deploying their
umbrellas against the rising heat. "It's been around so long that
people have become inured to it. We hope to demonstrate that we can do
away with malaria in a major country. It will be an example to other
countries of what can be done."

Carter and his colleagues have already demonstrated what can be done
in 17 African countries to prevent or treat debilitating diseases such
as Guinea worm, trachoma, lymphatic filariasis, schistosomiasis and
river blindness. All are classified by the World Health Organization
as "neglected tropical illnesses." "What that means is that they can
be prevented or eliminated with proper treatment," Carter told me.
"These neglected diseases have disappeared in most of the developed
world. In just a few years we've almost eliminated Guinea worm, which
has gone from three and a half million cases down to about 25,000-a
99.3 percent decrease. We treat about ten million people a year to
prevent onchocerciasis, or river blindness. We're making progress with
trachoma, which is the leading cause of preventable blindness in the
world. We're helping to train a corps of healthcare workers through
seven universities here in Ethiopia, so that even people in the most
remote areas will have access to treatment. The success with these
programs gives me confidence that we can have some impact on malaria."

Carter had come too late to help little Amzia Abdela, a 2-year-old who
died in 2006. She had lived deep in southwest Ethiopia, where farmers
still turn the earth with wooden plows and plodding oxen, where goats
sleep in red dirt roads and hornbills flap languidly from banana
trees.

"She was shivering," recalled the girl's father, Abdela Abawori, a
farmer in the village of Keta Chole. "She had a hot fever and a
headache. Her joints were aching. My daughter was sick for almost two
months. By the time we called the malaria worker, it was too late." We
conversed through Abate Tilahun, a program officer in the Carter
Center's Addis Ababa headquarters. Abate, soft-spoken and courtly,
translated from English to Amharic, a musical tongue with Semitic
roots that is the official language of Ethiopia.

In short order, Abate had established that Abdela and his wife,
Nefisa, 35, have six other children, including a boy born the month
before. In a few weeks, the rains would come again, and Abdela would
plant his maize. I asked about last year's harvest.

"Abdela says he grows 1,300 pounds of maize a year," Abate said.

"That sounds pretty good."

"Oh, no, it's not nearly enough," said Abate. "He says the family will
suffer. They need at least 2,600 pounds to get by. He says they have
to fill up on bananas and stuff."

Abdela was painfully thin, his face lined with wrinkles, making him
appear much older than his 40 years. He had straw in his hair, and he
wore ragged pants held together by patches. Rubber boots flapped
around his skinny legs, and his double-breasted coat was ripped at the
shoulder. Yet he was uncomplaining and dignified, an upright man who
had already lived through a vicious Marxist regime, followed by years
of turmoil, drought, war and now a young death in the family. He had
learned to take the blows and carry on, as resilient as Ethiopia
itself.

Like many in this proud country, Abdela knew that Ethiopia has never
been colonized by foreign powers. It also has its own ancient script,
its own branch of the Orthodox Church, even its own way of keeping time
-by the Ethiopian calendar it is 1999 and its millennium is still
in the future. "These things make us unique," said Teshome Gebre, a
resolutely buoyant man who heads up the Carter Center's health
operations in Ethiopia. "We also claim to be the source of humanity-
not only for Africa but for the entire world because of Lucy," he
said, referring to the 3.2-million-year-old hominid fossil,
Australopithecus afarensis, discovered in northeast Ethiopia in 1974.

Abdela led me uphill, past fenced gardens and scraggly coffee trees,
arriving at a truncated summit where he pointed to a pebbly mound of
earth sprouting weeds. "She's just here," he said. He took a step
around the little grave, not a yard long. "My mother is here with
her," he added, indicating an older burial at right angles to the
first. Neither was marked.

The sounds of morning wafted up the hillside-children laughing,
plowmen whistling to their oxen, roosters crowing in the sun. Abdela
uprooted the weeds obscuring his daughter's grave and threw them
aside. "I miss her," he said softly. "Of course I have a strong
feeling of losing my daughter. I think about her and I fear for my
family."

"Why is that?"

Abate translated: "He says almost all of his children have been
attacked by the malaria. Others could die."

Elsewhere in Ethiopia, I would meet parents who had great expectations
for their children, as prospective doctors, teachers, lawyers.
Abdela's ambition was more basic-he simply wanted his children to
live. That was enough for now.

Abdela led me to his little house, where two goats were tethered by
the entrance and smoke from a cooking fire coiled toward the sky. His
4-year-old daughter, Adia, rushed out to greet us. He scooped her up
in one arm, and with the other threw back the frayed cloth flap that
served as his front door. He ushered me into his darkened house, where
I could make out two new mosquito nets hanging in the gloom. The whole
family had been sleeping under them for a week. During that time,
Abdela had made an important discovery.

"When I woke up after the first night," he said, eyes widening with
wonder, "there were dead mosquitoes all around! Dead flies too!"

By the time Carter arrived in Ethiopia in February, the first of 20
million bed nets were in country-roughly two for each household in
malarial areas-dispatched by airplane, truck, bus and even donkey
cart. Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, a longtime supporter of Carter's
Ethiopian initiatives, had agreed that his government would distribute
17 million nets; the Carter Center would hand out the remaining 3
million in areas where it operated other health programs. Under an
agreement with the Ethiopian government, the Carter Center will
monitor the nation's malaria program until 2015, by which time it is
hoped that epidemics of the disease will be relegated to a chapter of
Ethiopian history. The Carter Center's cost would be $47 million, one
of the organization's biggest investments ever.

Since the late 1800s, it has been known that bed nets could prevent
malaria by shielding humans from marauding Anopheles mosquitoes. The
female mosquitoes, which make their rounds by night, inject victims
with malaria parasites. Of the four species of these parasites, the
most common and most dangerous is Plasmodium falciparum. They lodge in
the liver, where they remain dormant for a period of ten days or so
before flooding into the bloodstream. There they destroy red blood
cells by the tens of thousands, which triggers the characteristic
symptoms: "Coldness overtakes the whole body. Tremors...accompany the
cold sensations, beginning with the muscles of the lower jaw....The
expression has meanwhile changed: the face is pale or livid; there are
dark rings under the eyes; the features are pinched and sharp, and the
whole skin shrunken," according to a 1911 account, still accurate
today. Most of the 300 million to 500 million people infected
worldwide survive a malaria attack, which may arm them with a
resistance that makes future attacks less debilitating. In some cases,
the parasite remains in the body and emerges weeks or even years later
to cause a relapse; perhaps 15 percent of cases in Ethiopia are
recurring.

If you could avoid the insect's bite, however, you could avoid the
disease. The new nets blanketing Ethiopia add a high-tech twist to the
old protective strategy: they not only block the insects, but, as
Abdela Abawori had discovered, they kill any that come in contact with
the nets. They have the insecticide deltamethrin woven into the mesh,
and with no apparent risk to humans, they retain their mosquito-
killing potency for up to seven years.

Carter explained: "We first got involved with bed nets in Nigeria,
where we've used more than 100,000 to control lymphatic filariasis, or
elephantiasis. The problem with the old nets was that they had to be
reimpregnated every year. So you had to go back into every village and
every home to keep the nets working. It was an almost insurmountable
problem. This new technology makes it a one-shot deal. It doesn't just
repel mosquitoes-it kills them. It kills them! This would not have
been possible several years ago."

Carter's organization is not the only one to deploy this latest
armament in the mosquito wars. A group called Malaria No More, a
nonprofit collaboration between American business groups and
charities, is distributing more than a million new insect-killing nets
in other African countries. President Bush has launched a five-year,
$1.2 billion initiative against the disease, to help purchase and
distribute new nets, to provide malarial drugs for treatment and
prevention during pregnancy, to spray insecticide indoors and to boost
public education. Others have stepped up with financial commitments
for a worldwide campaign: the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis
and Malaria has promised $2.6 billion for nets and drugs; the World
Bank $357 million in loans for affected countries; the Bill and
Melinda Gates Foundation $303.7 million for research on vaccines.

The new attention would help the former president's fundraising
efforts. "I have absolute confidence in our Ethiopian project, as much
as I have had in anything we've done," he said. "We're not just doing
it spasmodically, just giving out nets in one village and skipping
others. We're going everywhere. We're doing it comprehensively."

A few days later, the former president returned to the United States
to solicit contributions for his Ethiopian campaign and to resume a
busy schedule, commenting on the passing political scene, teaching a
Sunday school class in his native Plains, Georgia, and writing books.
He has written more than 20 since leaving the White House, many of
them bestsellers. His latest, provocatively titled Palestine: Peace
Not Apartheid, created a storm of protest for criticizing Israel-and
expressing sympathy for the Palestinians-and led to several
resignations from the advisory board of the Carter Center.

It is too soon to tell if Carter's malaria crusade will succeed. But
the organization's track record suggests cause for hope on a continent
where that can be rare. After Carter departed Ethiopia, I remained
behind to see how his colleagues were handling established campaigns
against river blindness and trachoma, two devastating diseases that
have long plagued this country of rumpled mountains and foaming
rivers.

Those rivers were part of the problem. Day after day, I saw women
doing their wash in the swift current, where boys gathered water in
goatskins and men watched over cattle slurping from the river. The
same waters were home to a black fly of the Simulium species, a nasty
little customer that cut a wide swath in Ethiopia, infecting more than
3 million people with onchocerciasis, or river blindness, and placing
some 7.3 million at risk for the disease. The flies feed on human
blood. In the process, they infect their hosts with the parasite
Onchocerca volvulus, which gives the disease its scientific name. Once
inside a person, the worm-like parasites live for up to 15 years,
producing millions of little worms called microfilariae. These crawl
under the skin, causing inflammation, lesions, intense itching and a
mottling of the epidermis known as "leopard skin." In severe or
prolonged cases, they may migrate to the eyes, causing impaired vision
or blindness.

By the time 78-year-old Mekonen Leka turned up at the Afeta health
clinic in February, he was complaining of blurred vision and intense
discomfort. His bony shins and ankles were spotted with the white
blotches characteristic of onchocerciasis, and long, livid scars ran
up and down his legs from constant scratching. "I feel like there's
something crawling around under my skin," he said, reaching for a
sharp stick to dig at his shins once more. He sat propped against a
tree, his legs splayed before him, telling his story: he was infected
six years ago, while planting coffee near the river; the itching kept
him from sleeping; that, in turn, kept him from working; one of his
children took care of him; he could still see well enough to get
around, but he worried that his eyesight would get worse.

"It makes me very weak," said Mekonen. "I have come to the clinic to
beg for medication to stop the itching," he said.

The medication was ivermectin, a drug originally developed for
deworming cattle and dogs and now produced for people as Mectizan by
Merck & Co., which donates the doses. In 2006 alone, the Carter Center
distributed more than 2.5 million treatments to Ethiopians.
Administered once a year in tablet form, the drug does not kill the
adult worms, but it controls the spread of their offspring, which
gives patients like Mekonen immediate relief from itching. More
important, it will ensure that his vision would deteriorate no
further.

He would have to wait a few weeks for the drug, when area health
clinics planned a massive treatment. I witnessed several of these drug
campaigns, which were run and attended by Africans. The events were
announced in local markets and promoted on posters, resulting in
hundreds of patients showing up for medicine on a specified day.
Nobody just pocketed his pills and went home, but swallowed them under
the watchful eye of health workers who dutifully recorded each
patient's name in a bound ledger, measured his or her height with a
wooden stick, and determined the proper dosage accordingly.

"Our number one complaint is still malaria," said Yeshimebet Moges,
the chief nurse at the Afeta health clinic, where patients were lined
up 30 deep for afternoon checkups. "But we're seeing a lot of
onchocerciasis patients too. They itch; they get the treatment; the
complaints disappear. And there's a side benefit-a lot of people have
discovered that the medicine also gets rid of intestinal worms and
other parasites, which can be a big problem for children. Our patients
are really grateful-they bring us coffee, bananas, avocados, oranges."
A few satisfied customers have even named their children Mectizan, a
tribute to the drug that healed them.

Mectizan means that millions of children will not go blind or know the
misery that onchocerciasis has visited on their elders. With luck, a
new generation might be well enough to attend school instead of
suffering at home or staying there to nurse a sick parent. "If one
family member is taken out of production because of sickness, it
affects the whole family and eventually the economic development of
Ethiopia," said Teshome Gebre. "This is one of the reasons we have a
poor country. You need healthy working people if you want to reach the
dream of economic progress."

It had been a long while since Sintayhu Tegegn, 45, felt well enough
to work. The widowed mother of three sons had contracted trachoma, a
bacterial infection occurring throughout Ethiopia, and now she
suffered from trichiasis, a late stage of the disease that affects a
million Ethiopians and requires immediate surgery to preserve sight;
another 15 million to 20 million have an early phase of the ailment,
which can usually be arrested by antibiotics.

"My eyes started hurting two years ago," she told me, as we sat
outside a village clinic in Merawi, a dot on the map in northwestern
Ethiopia. Along with several hundred patients, she was awaiting eye
surgery. "The pain has become unbearable," she said, tightening a
white cotton shawl around her head to screen out the sunlight. "I have
trouble cooking for my family because the smoke irritates my eyes.
Sometimes I can find a neighbor to help me-sometimes I just have to go
to the kitchen and endure the pain because there's nobody else to feed
my family. I can't sleep because of the pain. I can't close my eyes.
If I do, then I can't open them because of the pain." She had them
closed as we spoke.

The disease, known from ancient times, is transmitted by flies or
spread from person to person. The vector, a fly known as Musca sorbens
(cousin to our familiar housefly, good old Musca domestica), swarms
around the eyes and runny noses of children, feeding on the moisture
and leaving behind a microorganism called Chlamydia trachomatis.
Infections from the microorganism settle under the eyelids, which
become inflamed and thickened. With time the lids begin to scar from
the inside, causing them to curl in upon themselves. When this
happens, inverted eyelashes begin to scratch the cornea, which
eventually clouds over like frosted glass, causing blindness. In
Ethiopia, where the disease is known as "hair in the eye," the ailment
afflicts primarily children and the women who care for them.

"It is very much an illness of gender," said Mulat Zerihun, the eye
surgeon in charge of the Carter Center's trachoma programs for the
sprawling Amhara region. He worked his way through a sea of patients
waiting to be screened in the Merawi clinic. When he came to Sintayhu
Tegegn, he pulled his magnifying goggles into position, cupped her
chin in his hands and tilted her head up. Like many suffering from
late-stage trichiasis, Sintayhu had found respite by plucking her
eyelashes with tweezers, which more than a few patients wore like
amulets around their necks. "Pulling the lashes helps for a day or
so," Mulat said, but then they grow back, sharp and bristly, and they
scratch the eyes worse than before.

Mulat peeled back Sintayhu's eyelids, studied her for a moment and
announced a verdict: "Both eyes will be all right. There's no clouding
on the cornea. You will feel a lot better in a few days." Mulat
plunged back into the silent crowd while Sintayhu's 15-year-old son
led her into a small room where surgeons were already at work on one
patient.

Sintayhu was lucky to fall under the care of Mitikie Wondie, 34, an
ophthalmic nurse suited up in a surgeon's cap, mask and latex gloves.
She settled Sintayhu on the table, draped her face with a sterile
cloth and told her to hold steady. After injecting each eyelid with
local anesthetic, Mitikie went to work: she threaded a needle through
the upper lid of one eye, pulled it up with a loop of silk and slid in
a stainless steel retractor to hold the lid in place; with a scalpel,
she made a small incision along the margin of the lid and the tarsal
conjunctiva; this relieved tension on the damaged eyelid, which
allowed her to unfold the eyelid, freeing it from scraping against the
cornea; with the lid restored to its proper position, Mitikie closed
the incision, squeezed antibacterial ointment in the eye and patched
it down with gauze, repeating the process on Sintayhu's other eye. All
through the 12-minute operation, Sintayhu lay barefoot and unflinching
on the table, watched over by four surgical assistants who handed
equipment to Mitikie, swabbed blood from Sintayhu's eye and listened
intently as Mitikie described what she was doing. The assistants were
in training, and would soon be allowed to perform a few operations
under Mitikie's supervision.

"We'll probably perform 40 surgeries in this clinic today," Mulat
said, "and another 40 down the road in Dur Bete. We could do more, but
we're giving these young people exposure to training, so they will be
able to do what Sister Mitikie does." His honorific title for Mitikie
referred to her position as a nurse, not to holy orders. When he
praised her, she shrugged, pulled on fresh gloves and went to work on
a new patient, one of the 67,000 trachoma surgeries the Carter Center
has coordinated in Ethiopia since 2000.

Sintayhu, meanwhile, was ready for home. She stood a little
unsteadily, her eyes taped with gauze, and called for her shoes,
pointed and black with red stars on each toe. She pulled her shawl
protectively over her head, locked arms with her son and went out into
the light. With him on one side, a niece on the other and a neighbor
following, Sintayhu navigated a passageway crowded with patients,
stepped gingerly into the clinic's sunbaked courtyard and disappeared
through a gate. Now maybe she could sleep.

The eye-saving surgery at Merawi and other rural clinics was but one
component in Carter's multifaceted campaign against trachoma. The
Carter Center also works with the Ethiopian Health Ministry and
volunteer groups such as Lions Club International to distribute
antibiotics from Pfizer, Inc., which has donated 5.5 million doses of
Zithromax, its version of azithromycin. The drug not only arrests
trachoma but also knocks out a wide range of other ailments, among
them scabies, lice and the respiratory infections that haunt children.

The trachoma initiative also includes a public education campaign
emphasizing the importance of face washing and hygiene in preventing
the disease. To encourage such washing, the Carter Center and the
Lions Club have drilled more than 119 community wells in the region.
And in order to stop trachoma at its source, the former president has
inspired an unprecedented sanitation campaign.

"I used to be known as the president who negotiated peace between
Egypt and Israel," Jimmy Carter told a recent gathering of health
workers in Addis Ababa. "Now I'm known as the number one latrine
builder in the world."

The flies transmitting trachoma breed in human feces. In the fields
where they spend all day and sanitary facilities are unknown, farmers
have traditionally squatted behind any convenient bush or maize plot.
"As you can see, we live in a big country," Mulat said as we drove
through yellow fields and lumpy mountains bordering Lake Tana, where
the Blue Nile uncoils on its long journey toward Sudan. "Our tradition
is to defecate outside in the fresh air under the sky. This is what
the farmers have always done."

Farmers were indignant a few years back when Mulat began talking about
the link between trachoma, flies and toilet habits, and suggested that
latrines could help. "Why should we change?" Mulat recalled them
asking. "Our ancestors did it this way. We do it this way! We've been
to cities. Their latrines smell terrible!"

To answer such complaints, Mulat staged latrine-building workshops in
a few communities, with raffles. "The lucky winner got a latrine,"
Mulat said. Neighbors did the construction, using simple materials
such as saplings and cornstalks. "Once people saw how the latrines
worked and they started using them, they really liked them-especially
the ladies." In this conservative region, women had been suffering for
years because it was a cultural taboo for them to defecate in
daylight, when they could be seen. "It brought shame and ridicule on
your family," Mulat said. "They basically had to go to the bathroom at
night, which could be very inconvenient."

With women leading the charge, latrine fervor soon swept the Amhara
region, where more than 300,000 new household privies have been built
since 2002, far beyond the 10,000 that health officials initially had
in mind. Neighbors competed to see who could build the best one.

Having visited a few of those reeking city latrines the farmers
complained about, it was with some trepidation that I made the half-
hour hike down a broken boulder field, across a sluggish creek and up
into the scrubby hills near Lake Tana to meet Wallegne Bizvayehu, a
farmer who proudly showed me his family privy, one of 300 new sanitary
facilities in his village of 6,000. It was a simple structure about
ten feet deep and three feet wide, with airy walls of woven maize
stalks and a slanting thatched roof lined with an orange plastic tarp.
Wallegne's outhouse was a clean, odorless, well-swept building, with
thin bars of sunlight shining through the walls, and not a fly in sight
-an island of unaccustomed privacy in a village of barking dogs, farm
chores and family obligations.

"Since we built it I believe we've been healthier," Wallegne said.
"We've decreased our visits to the nurse's station." Inspired by
Wallegne's example, three neighbors were building new latrines.
"They'll build them themselves," Wallegne said, "but of course I will
help if they need it."

This seemed to me the salient lesson of Jimmy Carter's efforts in
Ethiopia, where Africans were helping Africans. The former president
made the high-level contacts with prime ministers and health
officials, then went home to raise the contributions. He gathered a
small but talented technical staff in Atlanta to supervise and plan
projects. But they remained largely invisible on the ground in Africa,
where the recent history of charity has been written in overblown
promises, unrealized dreams and squandered billions.

"Most of the money spent on foreign aid never gets to the suffering
people," Carter told me. "It goes to the bureaucrats and to wasteful
contractors. There's data showing that for every $100 in available aid
for the control of disease and suffering in Africa, only $20 gets to
the people who need it."

Determined to improve upon that record, Carter (a notoriously frugal
child of the Great Depression) has kept his expenses low,
infrastructure small, accounting systems rigorous and expectations
reasonable. Over the past two and a half decades in Africa, he has
been happy to take small steps, to build upon them and to let local
people take credit for the programs that work. In Ethiopia, he has
drafted respected professionals such as Teshome Gebre and Mulat
Zerihun, who built their own network of indigenous helpers. These
villagers were the ones who went to the markets and made the
announcements of forthcoming clinics, kept the records, dispensed the
medicine, trained the nurses and performed the eye surgeries.

"That is the key to success," said Carter. "We don't come in to impose
something on a country. We get invited. We help. But all the work gets
done by local people."

And now local people were fanning out to make sure the nets were
properly deployed all over Ethiopia, which may yet win its long
struggle with malaria.

Robert M. Poole is a contributing editor to Smithsonian. His "Lost
Over Laos" appeared in August 2006. Trained as an artist, photographer
Antonio Fiorente lives in Addis Ababa.
http://www.smithsonianmagazine.com/issues/2007/june/malaria.htm