In article <37f3f59b...@news.bentonrea.com>
First, you are being jerked off by the factory spokesman.... The antenna does not
know what the velocity factor of the feedline is... All, you are being told to do
is to replace a fairly low loss coax with one of higher loss, i.e. insert a
resistor in the line to make the swr look better... In fact, if you will put a 50
ohm resistor across the antenna terminals, it will look real good...
Nor, will the velocity factor of the feedline change the gain, or front to back
ratio of the antenna, etc... If it is bad now, it will be bad then...
Gary, at the factory, speaketh in tongues...
Interestingly, Force 12 also uses the same statement to justify their swr
problems...
Second, no national manufacturer will knowingly produce an antenna that does not
perform, at least reasonably, to it's claims... They have antenna ranges and they
have verified their engineers design work... So, the antenna, as designed, will
work, give or take a dB or two... If your antenna is not working within reason then
there are only two possibilities..
1. That it is improperly assembled... This has been addressed to you in prior
posts... It is extremely likely... Let me give you an example...
I assembled a brand new KT34XA with the help of a friend, N8GAN... We double
checked each others dimensions as we assembled... A few days later when we were
ready to put it up, we again measured the critical dimensions... All, were within
spec...The antenna was raised to about 30' and tested and found to have swr
indications within reason, but not great... Knowing that we had checked it several
times it was put in the air and it operated satisfactorily... Two years later a
major storm twisted the elements on the boom and bent a couple.. The antenna was
trammed back to the ground <sigh> and repaired... During the repair I chose to go
over the dimensions again... Lo and behold, after all of our double checking, I
found two dimensions on one linear trap that were reversed! Stuff happens...
2. Or, you have bad traps, improperly resonated at the factory, etc... Another high
probability...
Get the local hams to help you take it down and go over the antenna assembly with a
microscope... Then haul it into the air 30-35 feet and using a new test piece of
coax exactly a half wavelength on 40 meters use one of the antenna analyzers to run
a set of impedence/reactance curves for every band... Then talk to the factory...
If they still give you grief spend a hundred bucks on an attorney to get your money
back and buy a different beam...
Cheers ... Denny
I got a used Mosley TA-53 and had a SWR problem until I turned a couple
traps around that I installed the wrong way because the color coding was
worn off on the traps.
John Finley N4SPL
Tampa, Florida
jfin...@tampabay.rr.com
Check out Sam's Ham Radio Store
http://www.wireless-prd.com/
WA7AW <wa...@bentonrea.com> wrote in message
news:37f3bf06...@news.bentonrea.com...