In article <
v7c36b1t2gu80k97d...@4ax.com>, Andreas Skitsnack
wrote:
> > > > > Andreas Skitsnack:
> > > > > In my view, it's not a question of
> > > > > whether the card *must* be formatted in the camera or in the
> > > > > computer. It's a question of when to format the card.
> > > >
> > > > > I would never allow my photo management software (Lightroom
> > > > > or Photoshop) to format the card automatically after upload.
> > > >
> > > > Sandman:
> > > > Lightroom has no option to erase your card after
> > > > import, unless they changed something recently. It's
> > > > something that has bugged me for a long time.
> > >
> > > Andreas Skitsnack:
> > > Why have you snipped what I replied to? I replied to nospam's
> > > comment:
> >
> > > "you can delete images from the computer or the camera. it makes
> > > absolutely no difference. in fact, photo management software can
> > > do that *for* you automatically after copying them."
> >
> > > Normally, you go for these long, interleaved, replies where you
> > > quote everything and stick in those inane comments like "hahaha"
> > > or "incorrect" a few times. Here, though, you snip to deceive.
> >
> > Sandman:
> > Who did I deceive and in what way?
>
> > You said you wouldn't allow Lightroom to erase your memory card,
>
> No, I said that I would not allow my photo management software to
> format automatically.
Yes, that's what I was in reference to, as the text you snipped made clear.
> I currently import using LR, but if LR adds that undesirable feature
> I wouldn't use it.
Indeed, and I never said you should. I just correctly pointed out that it
doesn't have that, to you, undesirable feature.
> Since I don't currently use Photoshop (CS 2015) to upload, I don't
> remember if it has that "feature", but I wouldn't allow that either.
I was not even aware that Photoshop could import photos from a card, so I
didn't comment on that.
> I think it does because I remember declining that option at some
> time.
Seeing how Photoshop isn't even a photo management application, I didn't
comment on it. And I'm not aware of Photoshop even having an import function
akin to that in Lightroom, much less a function to erase the memory card. Of
course, I could be mistaken, having never used Photoshop for this purpose.
> My "wouldn't" applies to any and all photo management software
> programs.
And my comment applied only to the one you explicitly mentioned. Not sure why
you're getting so riled up. You snipped away the part of my message where I
explicitly stated that I didn't post to point out something you did wrong, or
to correct some misinformation
--
Sandman