This one is fun because it's a great example of tone deafness. Sheriff
Paul is apparently so short of supporters that he's regularly recycling the
same people. His latest campaign ads present subordinates, including the
PCSO's community-relations Director as ordinary citizens without identifying
their relationships with Sheriff Paul.
http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/2012/04/23/20120423babeu-ads-raise-politicking-questions.html
"Pinal County Sheriff Paul Babeu's new campaign ads for Congress feature at
least six of his Sheriff's Office employees praising his conservative
values.
By using the subordinates in the two 30-second spots, Babeu may have
violated federal law that restricts elected officials from using their
official resources to help campaigns, even if the employees volunteered.
video Watch Paul Babeu's ads: Part 1 | Part 2
But Babeu's campaign consultant says he doesn't believe the campaign erred
by filming the employees, because they volunteered to appear on their
personal time. He argues that the ads, unveiled Monday, will help voters
learn about Babeu from people who know him well.
Most of the employees are top Pinal County Sheriff's Office managers and
staunch allies of Babeu's, including community-relations Director Cheryl
Chase and several deputies.
Babeu and Chase, along with other top sheriff's aides, are targets of an
investigation by the U.S. Office of Special Counsel, which is looking into
possible violations of the Hatch Act. The federal agency, which opened its
inquiry in December, subpoenaed records and laptops from Pinal County this
month, looking for records linked to Babeu's campaign for a seat in
Arizona's 4th Congressional District.
The Hatch Act makes it illegal for certain government workers to participate
in political activities.
Ann O'Hanlon, a spokeswoman for the Office of Special Counsel, said
featuring employees in campaign ads likely would violate the same law
because it could be seen as coercion.
Even if the employees volunteered, "when somebody is a subordinate, they're
a subordinate. They don't really have free will. They do something because
you're the boss."
She said if a full investigation of the ads were launched, the details would
be teased out. "(But) it's very difficult for a boss to have some sort of a
favor done by an employee without it having an element of coercion because
that boss has power over you."
Under the heading "Use of authority/coercion" on its website for state and
local employees, the Office of Special Counsel tells elected officials that
it is not acceptable to ask underlings to help on campaigns.
"Because it is inherently coercive for a supervisor to ask a subordinate
employee to contribute to a political cause, the Hatch Act would prohibit an
elected official from asking subordinate employees to help or contribute to"
his or her re-election campaign, the site says.
Chris DeRose, Babeu's campaign consultant, also pointed to the Office of
Special Counsel's website in defending Babeu's use of employees, saying,
"Nobody in the ad was a federal employee, much less a 'more restricted'
federal employee."
He initially cited a page of the website with instructions guiding federal
employees. When told there was a separate page dealing with state and local
employees, DeRose said he still did not see a problem.
Many of the employees who appeared in the ads stood beside Babeu, and in
some cases spoke in support of him, at a news conference in February. At
that time, Babeu admitted he was gay and said he had exchanged suggestive
photos with a former boyfriend but denied ever threatening the man with
deportation to keep their relationship secret.
The two ads running on television show a range of employees and other people
vouching for the sheriff's commitment to lower taxes, border security and
support of small businesses.
"Paul Babeu has served our country in uniform and as a sheriff, and I trust
him," Pinal County jail official Jayme Valenzuela says in one ad.
"I trust Paul Babeu to do the right thing," Chase says. In another ad, she
says, "Paul's always been pro-life. I like that."
Both Valenzuela and Chase were at the news conference.
None of the employees is in uniform in the ads. No names or titles are
given. And nothing distinguishes the employees from a Pinal County
businessman, a personal friend and other people who appear.
DeRose said it isn't misleading to viewers that the employees aren't
identified."
[snip]
The claim that Babeu has always been "pro-life" is a flat out lie. He's
been in politics since he was a teenager and has publically changed his
position several times.
http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com/valleyfever/2012/04/paul_babeu_falsely_claims_hes.php
Meanwhile, across the border in Maricopa county:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/24/joe-arpaio-obama-birth-certificate_n_1447801.html
Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio plans to release new findings in his
ongoing investigation of President Obama's birth certificate, which he
believes is a forgery.
In an interview with birther-friendly website World Net Daily, the
self-proclaimed "toughest sheriff" in America said he would soon hold a
press conference to reveal new evidence that he believes will prove that
Obama's birth certificate and Selective Service documenation are
fabrications.
Arpaio, who is currently the subject of a Department of Justice probe
investigating charges of racial profiling against Hispanics within his
office, told the website that he has no intention of leaving his post, even
as he faces a federal trial.
"I have no intention of resigning," Arpaio said. "They forget I have a four
decades-long career in federal law enforcement."
[snip]
http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com/valleyfever/2012/04/sheriff_joe_arpaio_should_be_c.php
Phil Gordon, Paul Charlton, Rick Romley and Terry Goddard sent a letter to
U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder today asking him to have Sheriff Joe
Arpaio charged for abusing his power.
Gordon's a former Phoenix mayor; Charlton's a former Arizona U.S. Attorney;
Romley's a former Maricopa County Attorney, and Goddard's a former Arizona
Attorney General.
The ex-mayor and ex-prosecutors point out that when a state Supreme Court's
disciplinary panel disbarred former County Attorney Andrew Thomas last week,
it linked Arpaio as his partner in crime -- literally.
[snip]
TB