1) Gogi Grant with Henri Rene's Orchestra - Sheer beauty from start to
finish. Absolute perfection. This is a very respectful version, that
successfully attempts to create the Ideal version of this classic.
1) Leslie Uggams with Mitch Miller and the Gang - It's hard to pick a
favorite version of this song, but this is a strong contender.
Leslie's delivery is gorgeous with just a touch of the blues; and the
Gang's background vocals and the overriding echoes infuse the piece
with a vague sense of impending doom (which would be in keeping with
the musical). The stereo mix with Leslie on the right speaker and the
Gang on the left is an added treat.
1) Ella Fitzgerald & Louis Armstrong - Arguably the definitive version
of the song (if only because of the stature of the artists involved).
In this instance, the plaudits are warranted. The individual vocals
and the orchestration are flawless -- although the initial shift from
Ella to Louis is jarring, they work together beautifully in the final
chorus.
1) Renee Olstead - Renee starts out taking it as a haunting lullaby,
and gets progressively more bluesy and improvisational throughout,
before winding it down (slightly) for the ending. Words cannot
adequately describe the many subtle alterations in tempo and style
that make this version so captivating.
*I know, I know, the next three versions should be tied for the #5
spot -- but I prefer it like this:
2) Mary Carewe with Philip Mayers & Blue Noise - An unconventional
arrangement that's absolutely haunting. I only wish it were longer.
2) Julie London - Julie sings it as a jazz number -- and pulls it off
brilliantly. The inherent conflict between jazz approaches to this
song have hurt some of the versions below, but somehow this one is
almost better for it. Julie's vocal has the perfect mix of sultry
laziness and decadence. A real treat.
2) The Hi-Lo's - Another knockout version. The group gets a little
too showy for their own good at one or two points, but not enough to
significantly detract from the quality of the song.
3) Sam Cooke - Well done, with a great arrangement that gives the
appearance of being more sparsely orchestrated than it is. Cooke's
performance is pleasant, but falls short of the masterful
interpretations, above. It's 2:21 running time also leaves me wanting
more.
4) The Glenn Miller Orchestra - I had thought that I'd be ranking this
one last, as it lacks a vocal, but the arrangement actually transcends
the need for words. Another one where my only complaint is that it
isn't long enough.
5) Lena Horne - Much like the Billie Holiday version, below, the jazzy
arrangement is at odds with the spirit of the song (essentially a
lullaby). Lena's approach, however, fits seamlessly with the
arrangement.
6) Billie Holiday - This version is pretty good, but the orchestra's
slightly uptempo jazzy approach is at odd with the spirit of the
song.). Billie's vocal strives, with some success, to find an uneasy
medium between the two forms.
Summertime has long been one of my all-time favorite songs. An ex-
girlfriend of mine also sang it beautifully, but as far as I know, she
never recorded it.
We've got a 4-way tie with this one. The
1) Gogi Grant with Henri Rene's Orchestra - Sheer beauty from start to
finish. Absolute perfection. This is a very respectful version, that
successfully attempts to create the Ideal version of this classic.
1) Leslie Uggams with Mitch Miller and the Gang - It's hard to pick a
favorite version of this song, but this is a strong contender.
Leslie's delivery is gorgeous with just a touch of the blues; and the
Gang's background vocals and the overriding echoes infuse the piece
with a vague sense of impending doom (which would be in keeping with
the musical). The stereo mix with Leslie on the right speaker and the
Gang on the left is an added treat.
----------------------------------
These two have that dragginess that I've heard so much about but couldn't
identify until now. Billy Stewart doesn't suffer from that problem & he
doesn't even appear on your list!
> Billy Stewart. End of story.
The jackass who started this thread never heard of Billy Stewart.
Gotta admit -- the man knows me like a book!
I wouldn't have thought it was possible ...
I still can't believe my ears ...
But Billy Stewart somehow managed to turn this great standard into a
steaming heap of ... dog shit.
Pardon me, Brucie -- dogshit.
It was BY FAR the biggest selling version of the song, peaking at # 10
on the Billboard pop charts. The only version that mainstream
Americans know. The only other version that made the top 75 on the pop
charts is the Billie Holiday that you had at the bottom of your list.
I'll bet most Americans know the Ella-Louis version.
You're a fucking jackass. It's two thousand and fucking ten, moron.
Most Americans are well under 50 years old and have never heard of
Louis Armstrong, Ella Fitzgerald, or the song "Summertime."
I've never even heard the Armstrong/Ella version, how the fuck are
most Americans gonna know it?
Is this the uptempo version or the slow version? Cooke
recorded two completely different versions of the song,
and for some reason many later reissues include the
wrong version.
I first became familiar with the slow version when I
bought a re-pressing of the sixties "The Best of Sam
Cooke" album nearly thirty years ago. It was only much
later that I found out that this was not the charted
version that issued on the flip side of "You Send
Me" (Keen 4013).
The original single has a much more lively uptempo version
which includes a prominent guitar part in the foreground.
You can listen to it here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cetclnMH9S4
Keen later issued another single (Keen 2101) which has
two versions of "Summertime" listed as "Part 1" and
"Part 2". I've never had the 45, but I would guess that
it contains both of these two versions.
The wrong version is included even on the 4-CD boxed set
"The Man Who Invented Soul" that BMG put out in 2000.
The liner notes include a paragraph about the song,
and the writer seems to have no idea that the version
he is analyzing is not the one that was on the original 45!
BTW, in addition to the classic Billy Stewart hit,
there are also very nice uptempo versions of the song
by the Marcels and Ronnie Hawkins.
--
Jyrki Ilva --- Helsinki, Finland, Europe *
--- il...@cc.helsinki.fi *
--- http://www.helsinki.fi/~ilva/ *
> The wrong version is included even on the 4-CD boxed set
> "The Man Who Invented Soul" that BMG put out in 2000.
> The liner notes include a paragraph about the song,
> and the writer seems to have no idea that the version
> he is analyzing is not the one that was on the original 45!
He sounds a lot like the complete and utter jackass who started this
thread.
It's in the same class as Vito and the Salutations' "interpretation" of
"Unchained Melody"
Porgy & Bess was written as an opera, and "Summertime", as sung by
Leontyne Price is how it should be sung.
The general public says differently. Stewart's was by far the biggest
hit version of the song.
If that was the case, would the cover versions in which Pat Boone or
Georgia Gibbs outsold the originators... make it "better"? Of course
not.
Otherwise Scarlotti could say "the general public says differently" if
you were debating the merits of those covers with him.
We're not just ta;lking about it being the biggest hit. We're talking
that it was BY FAR the biggest hit version of the song and the only
version of the song that was a top 40 hit in the last 70 years. The
ONLY other version that was a big hit was Billie Holliday in 1936.
> If that was the case, would the cover versions in which Pat Boone or
> Georgia Gibbs outsold the originators... make it "better"? Of course
> not.
Boone and Gibbs versions were not all that much bigger than the
versions they copied, and there were obvious reasons why they were big
at all. There are no such factors with "Summertime." The author may
have intended it to be an opera but the public disagreed with him.
This happens often in music.
> Otherwise Scarlotti could say "the general public says differently" if
> you were debating the merits of those covers with him.
You're not paying ,much atte ntion, he says that all the time.
-------------------------
I'll bet most Americans aren't familiar with it (you & Sharx aren't most
people). A lot more people living today are more familiar with the Big
Brother & the Holding Company version and even more are familiar with the
Billy Stewart version.
Here's a more extreme example, not where one version barely outsold the
other.
How about Darin's "Mack the Knife", a monster hit by any standards. one
of the biggest songs in '59, if not THE biggest...and one of the biggest
hits of the entire decade as well.
I don't like his version..too "Vegas hip" for my tastes.
Louis Armstrong charted with it at #20 in 1956, so Darin's version
outsold it probably 10-1 if not more.
Yet I like Satchmo's version much better, and Ella's too.
Do you like Darin's better than Louis and Ella?
If you were being consistent, you'd be pushing the original version
from the soundtrack of "The Threepenny Opera."
--
--md
_________
Remove xx's from address to reply
Yes
I'll admit I never heard of Sidney Bechet but for a few years ago
(maybe it was 1999 or 2000 or some time like that) when I watched and
took in the whole Ken Burns Jazz serialized presentation over 3 weeks
back at that time.
Listen to the whole Bechet version song for free, at this discussion
point on an NPR (National Public Radio in the USA) show:
http://www.npr.org/blogs/ablogsupreme/2009/06/listening_party_for_two_sidney.html
Bechet comes MUCH, much closer I think to original intent of Gershwin;
namely, the somewhat or mournful or wistful feeling, even a little bit
of lonesome poured in there of Gershwin's musical intent and idea.
Holiday's version, I have no problem with her phrasing. It's just
that it is not so loyal to Gershwin's intent...it is a little TOO
joyful, ...even playful in tone. Nothing if not a celebration, in
fact. Plus, I don't think Holiday, although a full-throated
presentation, does not sing with 100% of her heart and soul CONVICTION
the way she sings (or would sing, later, if you will) something like
her classic "Lover Man" from late 1944. Oh she's more than
competent, but the full conviction like she would have with certain
other (choice) recordings in not there.
Artie Shaw also had a fine version - you can YT it here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Xkyg46LHwE
Artie's tone poem does capture the wistful, semi-dreamy lonely feeling
of the song, and Roy Eldridge's belting riffs are a REAL nice touch,
but the whole thing is almost a little too downbeat, the same way
Holiday's was too sanguine. Ergo, Bechet captures the ESSENTIAL
FEELING of the song as I believe Gershwin originally intended it.
Shaw's ain't definitive, but it is mighty beautiful nonetheless. You
should hear it.
Meanwhile, over at the Jazz Standards web-site, a much more hip and
defintive place to find your opinions on "the Standards" than what
Scarlotti (or even Bruce, much less Dean) attempts to purport, you can
find their recommendations as follows in this order for "Summertime":
http://www.jazzstandards.com/compositions-0/summertime.htm
Sidney Bechet (in the lead-off number one spot)
followed by:
Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong
Duke Ellington in a 1961 version
John Coltrane (from "My Favorite Things")
Sonny Rollins w/Colemand Hawkins from 1963
Gil Evans w/Ted Dunbar (1973)
Herbie Hancock
Lambert, Hendricks and Ross (a jazz vocal trio from 1959)
Ray Brown Trio
Miles Davis (from Porgy & Bess, 1958)
Art Blakey Quartet
(saxophonist) Joshua Redman, with some Latin tinges
and of course, sound samples of all at your ready.
Glenn Miller? a top version? Tell that to a dead horse and it'll
kick your brains out.
Of course, the problem with Scarlotti is this total pretender to
hipness will never be such, because he can't think outside the box,
whether that be the box that holds his music collection, or house, or
even his own thick, twisted skull.
Best-selling doesn't make the version. Most popular doesn't make the
best version either, or the most definitive. Did Bing Crosby ALWAYS
make the best of the best of the best version of any particular song
during his 1927 - 1952 heyday? No, of course not. Neither was
Miller's version of any hit or popular song for a band or orchestra
always the definitive or best version of any song of that era,
irregardless of how confident he may sound as he holds forth.
Scarlotti simply not capable of thinking or entertaining a thought
outside the limits of his own imagination, or moreover, his current
record or CD or MP3 collection.
Myself, honestly, my tastes do devolve into cusp or borderlands
between the jazz and popular music boundary extremes or black or
"white" musical creative frontiers, so the versions of Bechet (first
and foremost), and Holiday, Shaw and Stewart's "Summertime" usually
"do" it for me, most days. That said,
"Summertime" by Stewart could never be definitive...it isn't even half
as good or as vital as his own "I Do Love You" (mono-single) or
"Sitting In the Park", and yet the song (not the version) Summertime
is without a doubt in my mind, greater (read: more charismatic, more
mysterious, more alluring, and more everything...etc.) song than
either I Do Love You or Sitting In the Park, which is PROBABLY (you
think?) why more people have covered or remade Summertime than SIITP
or IDLY, notwithstanding Summertime's head start). When Stewart,
therefore, has had greater songs (for himself), how could his
Summertime EVER be seen as definitive? It's nice, it's fun once in
awhile, but it would never make my own top 100 or even top 200 Soul
list (although one or two of his other records might). Maybe Otis
Redding really did do the best version of Try A Little Tenderness, but
Stewart is really not in the argument for a definitive version of
Summertime.
Nick Kosloff
(from memory)
"Happy ending,
nice and easy.
It's a rule I
learned in school.
Get your money
every Friday.
Happy endings
are the rule.
So divide up
those in darkness
from the ones who
walk in light.
Light 'em up, boys.
There's your picture.
Drop the shadows
out
of
sight."
By the time I got to see the show, which ran a very long time, Orbach was
playing the part of Mack The Knife himself. I don't remember who played the
Street Singer--or anyone else. It was probably in 1961.
DianeE
Let's see what the group thinks. Here's how each version did in
Roger's contests:
Louis Armstrong - 1955 - # 83
Bobby Darin - 1959 - # 23
Ella Fitzgerald - 1960 - # 313
Looks like the group does not agree with you.
The real original performance dates back to 1927 in Berlin, and I'm
pretty sure there is no soundtrack of it. I actually had the
long-running American "original" version in mind since it was the
source for Armstrong. But, of course, it's even better in German. :-)
Did you agree with the group when "Mona Lisa" was voted the #1 song of
1950? Nope. and that's a lot higher than 83, 23 or 313, no?
Yet you mocked the group for making it the winner.
If you voted for it at all, in which round did you stop?
So if I was not in the majority when it came to MTF, you were further
out of the loop when it came to "Mona Lisa".
In article <14429-4C5...@storefull-3113.bay.webtv.net>, F R
<espo...@webtv.net> wrote:
You can't say "fair enough" to Diane after telling me my point was
irrelevant since she was merely expanding on my point. My point had
nothing at all to do with chart positions. And you can't argue that
"Summertime" versions should be measured against the original operatic
version without applying the same criterion to "Mack the Knife."
Darin's version is just as distant from the original as Stewart's
"Summertime." I happen to like Darin, Armstrong, the American cast
version and several German versions of "Mack the Knife." I also like
both Billie Holiday's "Summertime" and Stewart's. I see nothing wrong
with liking both apples and oranges.
---------------------------------------------
Frank is just trying to set up a "logical" scenario in which he can find
someone whom he can convince to agree with him - when usually there is no
logical reason why one favors a particular version -- unless your name is
Scarlotti or Sharx.
Nick Neil Kosloff knows it (see his post, above). :-)
I've got the slow version.
Thanks much for the info. I had been under the impression that it was
the original as well.
The uptempo version you posted the link too is good (certainly better
than the Stewart), but I definitely prefer the slower remake.
I couldn't have expressed it better!
As a compromise, let's say that they hold more appeal for Pop fans,
whereas the orig... wait a minute ... Baker's version was also a cover!
Baker's version of which song?
She did the original "Tweedle Dee" and the original "Tra La La."
I like Darin's "Artificial Flowers" a lot, but have mentioned it was not
how it was sung in the original show as the lyrics, IMO, do not call for
an uptempo version, as you might agree. That's how I feel about BS'
"Summertime." However, that aside, and forgetting the lyrics for a
moment, I do like Darin's arrangement but don't care for Stewart's.
Whichever version of MTK one likes better, has nothing to do with how
the group voted or which version was a bigger hit. I'll stick with that.
Bruce, however showed that the group liked Darin's version better, yet
belittled the group for voting "Mona Lisa" as their top song of 1950,
claiming their and maybe your "whiteness" was showing. So his using the
group results to back up one point, is also contradictory, since
apparently it was OK to cite for MTK, but not OK for ML.
> You can't say "fair enough" to Diane after telling me my point was
> irrelevant since she was merely expanding on my point. My point had
> nothing at all to do with chart positions. And you can't argue that
> "Summertime" versions should be measured against the original operatic
> version without applying the same criterion to "Mack the Knife." Darin's
> version is just as distant from the original as Stewart's "Summertime."
> I happen to like Darin, Armstrong, the American cast version and several
> German versions of "Mack the Knife." I also like both Billie Holiday's
> "Summertime" and Stewart's. I see nothing wrong with liking both apples
> and oranges.
> --
> --md
> _________
> And I will say "Fair enough" to you as well Mark...but as I said, I so
> disliked Stewart's version, I compared it to Vito and the Salutations'
> recording of "Unchained Melody". Just my opinion.
Al Hibbler's "Unchained Melody" is probably my favorite pop song of the
50s and I share your dislike for the Vito/Salutations version.
>
> I like Darin's "Artificial Flowers" a lot, but have mentioned it was not
> how it was sung in the original show as the lyrics, IMO, do not call for
> an uptempo version, as you might agree.
I think Darin was trying to wring the soppiness out of the song and
didn't succeed.
> That's how I feel about BS'
> "Summertime." However, that aside, and forgetting the lyrics for a
> moment, I do like Darin's arrangement but don't care for Stewart's.
Never heard Darin's version. Maybe if you can forget what song he's
taking flight from, you can give Stewart's wondrous vocal acrobatics
another try.
> You can't say "fair enough" to Diane after telling me my point was
> irrelevant since she was merely expanding on my point. My point had
> nothing at all to do with chart positions. And you can't argue that
> "Summertime" versions should be measured against the original operatic
> version without applying the same criterion to "Mack the Knife." Darin's
> version is just as distant from the original as Stewart's "Summertime."
> I happen to like Darin, Armstrong, the American cast version and several
> German versions of "Mack the Knife." I also like both Billie Holiday's
> "Summertime" and Stewart's. I see nothing wrong with liking both apples
> and oranges.
> --
> --md
> _________
> Yes, I admit I made contradictory remarks, and unlike some others I
> acknowledge it.
>
> Whichever version of MTK one likes better, has nothing to do with how
> the group voted or which version was a bigger hit. I'll stick with that.
Bruce thinks the voting here has some kind of actual meaning, and
that's one of the things about which we disagree.
>
> Bruce, however showed that the group liked Darin's version better, yet
> belittled the group for voting "Mona Lisa" as their top song of 1950,
> claiming their and maybe your "whiteness" was showing. So his using the
> group results to back up one point, is also contradictory, since
> apparently it was OK to cite for MTK, but not OK for ML.
Bruce is sometimes a fucking jackass. (But he is not a full-time one,
and for that we can be grateful.)
Since I don't care about lyrics and because I see each record as a
separate entity, I loke both the Hibbler and the Vito as well as the
Righteous Brothers version of the song. I don't like the Roy Hamilton
version so much though. Does it really matter what words that Vito and
the boys were singing? If you like or dislike the Vito record it's
based upon whether or not you like that type of radical uptempo doo
wop sound. The fact that the song happened to be done as a ballad
earlier should not affect your opinion. If you like "Never Let You Go"
by the Five Discs you should also like "Unchained Melody" by Vito.
> > I like Darin's "Artificial Flowers" a lot, but have mentioned it was not
> > how it was sung in the original show as the lyrics, IMO, do not call for
> > an uptempo version, as you might agree.
>
> I think Darin was trying to wring the soppiness out of the song and
> didn't succeed.
I think he succeeded, and so does the public as his version was a big
hit.
> > That's how I feel about BS'
> > "Summertime." However, that aside, and forgetting the lyrics for a
> > moment, I do like Darin's arrangement but don't care for Stewart's.
>
> Never heard Darin's version. Maybe if you can forget what song he's
> taking flight from, you can give Stewart's wondrous vocal acrobatics
> another try.
You never heard Darin's version of "Artificial Flowers?"
It certainly has more actual meaning than you and Frank giving us your
personal opinions.
It gives us a barometer of taste that goes beyond that of you two
jackasses.
On the other hand, I don't like Stewart's handling of "Summertime". Sam
Cooke's version is quite good and he too strayed from how it was
originally sung.
It certainly has more actual meaning than you and Frank giving us your
personal opinions.
-----------------------
Everyone's opinion is "personal"
It gives us a barometer of taste that goes beyond that of you two
jackasses.
---------------------
So you were glad "Mona Lisa" won the 1950 contest? It gave us a
barometer of the group's taste for that particular year.
> > Al Hibbler's "Unchained Melody" is probably my favorite pop song of the
> > 50s and I share your dislike for the Vito/Salutations version.
>
> Since I don't care about lyrics and because I see each record as a
> separate entity, I loke both the Hibbler and the Vito as well as the
> Righteous Brothers version of the song. I don't like the Roy Hamilton
> version so much though. Does it really matter what words that Vito and
> the boys were singing? If you like or dislike the Vito record it's
> based upon whether or not you like that type of radical uptempo doo
> wop sound.
I stated two opinions without making a connection between them. I
dislike the overly frantic sound of Vito's record, and the really
radical thing that was happening to uptempo doo wop at the time was
taking place in Brian Wilson's control booth.
> The fact that the song happened to be done as a ballad
> earlier should not affect your opinion.
I don't disagree with that.
The group thinks "Mona Lisa" is great. I don't.
What about "Never Let You Go" by the Five Discs?
> and the really
> radical thing that was happening to uptempo doo wop at the time was
> taking place in Brian Wilson's control booth.
What are you babbling about? The Beach Boys are not doo wop.
I like "Blue Moon" byt the Marcels and it was surely a radical
interpretation.
But while "Blue Moon" is probably part of the "American Songbook",
"Summertime" as sung the way Gershwin wrote it, is one of the classics
of all classics and should be very near page 1 in the mythical American
Songbook. IMO, of course.
BULLSHIT.
If it was that much of a classic it would have been a huge hit by
somebody, if not by many artists, like "Blue Moon" was.
"Mark Dintenfass" <mdint...@xxnew.rr.com> wrote in message
news:060820101305385048%mdint...@xxnew.rr.com...
99% of the time, though.
"Trollberg" <Sav...@aol.com> wrote in message
news:d04e2bd3-ea04-40ba...@j8g2000yqd.googlegroups.com...
Barometer of taste? For about a dozen FUCKED-UP, tone-deaf WHACK jobs?
>
>
>
> On Aug 6, 5:13 pm, Mark Dintenfass <mdintenf...@xxnew.rr.com> wrote:
> > In article
> > <5d96dd6d-84d3-4d09-9459-9298b5415...@i31g2000yqm.googlegroups.com>,
> >
> > Trollberg <Savo...@aol.com> wrote:
> > > > Al Hibbler's "Unchained Melody" is probably my favorite pop song of the
> > > > 50s and I share your dislike for the Vito/Salutations version.
> >
> > > Since I don't care about lyrics and because I see each record as a
> > > separate entity, I loke both the Hibbler and the Vito as well as the
> > > Righteous Brothers version of the song. I don't like the Roy Hamilton
> > > version so much though. Does it really matter what words that Vito and
> > > the boys were singing? If you like or dislike the Vito record it's
> > > based upon whether or not you like that type of radical uptempo doo
> > > wop sound.
> >
> > I stated two opinions without making a connection between them. I
> > dislike the overly frantic sound of Vito's record,
>
> What about "Never Let You Go" by the Five Discs?
You can dance to it. I'll give it a 76. (There is some good 60s doo
wop, but I mostly prefer earlier stuff. Compared to the Clovers or the
Drifters, the Five Discs are pretty weak.)
>
> > and the really
> > radical thing that was happening to uptempo doo wop at the time was
> > taking place in Brian Wilson's control booth.
>
> What are you babbling about? The Beach Boys are not doo wop.
They took vocal group harmony and made something radically new, which
is what I said. "I Get Around" is as much a child of 50s doowop as
Vito's thing, and a lot better.
I'm with Bruce on this point, Frank. Your veneration of "Summertime"
seems excessive.
A lot better, yes, but nowhere near as much doo wop.
"Sincerely" by the Moonglows is, I believe, one of the most popular
doo-wop standards ever.
It would be any compilation of the greatest Doo Wop ballads.
How many times did a doo-wop version of "Sincerely" chart?
The measuring stick of a standard goes deeper than if it charted and
how many times.
Bruce>
If it was that much of a classic it would have been a huge hit by
somebody, if not by many artists, like "Blue Moon" was.
--------------------------------
Gee, maybe because it was a "black" song and "Blue Moon" was a white
song?
--------------------
Are you serious?
No one is denying that it's a standard, jackass.
We are saying that it's just not "one of the classic of all classics"
as you claimed.
"F R" wrote in message
news:1557-4C5C...@storefull-3111.bay.webtv.net...
Whose version in your opinion is the classic of all classics?
I like the faithful to Gershwin renditions best, sung as an operatic
piece which is how it was written
But the melody is so pretty that it was very popular amongst jazz
musicians.
It is said that Bob Crosby recorded the first "POP' version in 1935, but
it was Billie Holliday's different take on it that made the song a big
hit. It reached #12 btw.
For pop/jazz, I like Ella's version...the one without Satchmo.
How many songs can you name that were recorded over 2000 times?
Abbie Mitchell. She’s the one who originally sang it in the 1935 opera
Porgy and Bess.
>Here's a list of those who recorded "Summertime". Most are probably
>unfamiliar to you guys too, but there are several dozen artists who
>were/are well-known and thought enough of it to make a record of it.
>It's a long list, maybe over 1000 acts, but if you have the patience to
>scroll down all the way, you'll recognize tons of names. Now that's a
>Standard!!
>---------------------------
You forgot to list Teddy & The Rough Riders. :)
Jim Colegrove
http://www.thecoolgroove.com
According to Joel Whitburn, from 1890 to 1954 "Summertime" was the 5th
most recorded song. Am trying to find a list for the whole 20th century.
I'd guess maybe "Yesterday" is the all-time #1, and a seasonal song like
"White Christmas" or even a novelty like "Rudolph the Red Nosed
Reindeer" are both very high on a "Most Recorded Song of All Time" list.
You're starting to develop a real fixation with animal feces, Bruce.
> If it was that much of a classic it would have been a huge hit by
> somebody, if not by many artists, like "Blue Moon" was.
I've always thought that what made a song a "standard" or part of the
"Great American Songbook" was that it doesn't "belong" to any one
artist, but exists apart from any particular hit version.
And I second Frank here: Summertime is one of the leading entries in
the "Songbook" -- both in terms of quality and enduring appeal.
It's also a child of the Hi-Los and the Four Freshmen.
I heard that one once, and like it a *lot* as well.
Unfortunately I'm only comparing versions I have (and can listen to
back-to-back) ... along with an occasional version that I had on lp
and can remember well enough to accurately appraise.
Scarlottishit
Whoa! Down boy! I've got a restraining order that forbids you to
come within 500 yards of my bathroom.
How is this version?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A27FF2T2z2k
----------------------
Her studio version is better.
How about J. Frank Wilson? --
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QTdYfsHGf3M
>Gershwin is lucky he died before hearing Stewart's rendition. It would
>have killed him.
>
>It's in the same class as Vito and the Salutations' "interpretation" of
>"Unchained Melody"
>
>Porgy & Bess was written as an opera, and "Summertime", as sung by
>Leontyne Price is how it should be sung.
Amongst others I like the Gene Vincent version.
Robert Crazy Legs Boyne.
--
Robert J. Boyne.Tradewinds Real Estate.North Vancouver/British Columbia.Cell.604-644-6973.
***************************************************************************************
" I have the good sense to know that unheard songs are often sweeter".
Email - rjb...@shaw.ca
Home page - www.2realtyguys.com
Indescribably horrid.
I sat through the overly long instrumental intro, but had to turn it
off once that putrid voice kicked in.
Much better.
The lite upbeat tempo trivializes the song a mite, but it's still a
highly enjoyable version.
For once we are in total agreement. She sounds like a dying fucking
cow or something.