Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Rienzi as a fascist dictator

3 views
Skip to first unread message

Dave U. Random

unread,
Feb 11, 2010, 1:35:43 PM2/11/10
to
(AP) - Wagner's early opera "Rienzi" has a history of
arousing strong emotions.

The composer himself came to despise it and banned it from
performance at his Bayreuth shrine. But it was the favorite
opera of no less a Wagner fanatic than Adolf Hitler, who
owned the original manuscript and may have had it by his
side when he died in his bunker in the closing days of
World War II.

It's unlikely Der Fuehrer would look kindly on the new
production of "Rienzi" that's playing at the Deutsche Oper
of Berlin. Director Philipp Stoelzl has turned the title
character from a 14th-century Roman tribune into a 20th-
century fascist demagogue in an Alpine country that could
easily be Germany.

In case the point isn't clear, Stoelzl plays extensive film
footage of Rienzi haranguing the adoring populace; invents
a swastika-like flag emblazoned with the letter "R," and
even provides a bunker for Rienzi to hide in with his
sister, Irene. Oh, and she has blond hair like Eva Braun
and exchanges long kisses with her brother that are far
more than sisterly.

This is all too much for some of the hometown audience. At
Wednesday night's performance, the fourth in the run of
six, boos mixed with cheers both at the first-act curtain
and at the conclusion...

Continued: http://tr.im/NMpx

kjbk Wallin

unread,
Feb 11, 2010, 3:24:33 PM2/11/10
to
On Feb 11, 1:35 pm, Dave U. Random <anonym...@anonymitaet-im-

Yet again, huh. The link didn't work for me, but after some googling I
found it. Well, there's no point in getting upset about these things,
though some of the pictures suggest they've gone farther this time
than in most other recent productions. Nothing to be surprised about,
really. The Germans construct for themselves a Wagner they can be
happy with -- just as they have always done. It does prompt the
question, though, of why they just can't get it over with: clearly,
what they want to see on stage are awe-inspiring SS-soldiers,
swastikas aplenty, killing and rape. So why not just do it? They're
all hankering after it, they're all moving slowly in that direction.
Just do it -- seriously, what's the problem, with today's technology
it should be an easy thing to have Parsifal wear a mask making him
looking like Reinhard Heydrich, and I'm sure there are plenty of
swastika flags they could borrow from the Babelsberg film studio.
What's up with all this beating about the bush? If you want the SS
then fucking give yourself the SS, and stop pestering the rest of us
with your laughable Vergangenheitsbewältigung.

I'm linking an article from the FAZ below, which repeats the claim
made in the above piece, that 'Rienzi was Hitler's favorite opera.' Oh
yeah? Funny, isn't it, how these people can prate so much of how
they're dealing with their dark history, and then go on saying things
about that mass murderer that we do not know if they are true, and
which are quite possibly false. I know the story of H and Rienzi, as
it appears in Kubizeck's book, etc. However, there's no solid factual
basis for the claim that it was H's favorite opera. We just don't
know, and in fact, I don't think it's very likely (just because he may
have had a powerful experience of it early in his life obviously
doesn't mean it remained his favorite) But screw that, right, those
are all details: Hauptsache ist, we can watch the SS marching yet
again. Geil.

The gentleman from FAZ is generally rather positive. Quite palpably,
he is a man of very limited intellectual powers. At one point he
writes: 'Wenn schon nicht totaler Sieg, dann totale Vernichtung,
Hauptsache: total! Das ist Wagner durch und durch, Kumulation bis zum
Äußersten: ob nun Liebestod oder Walhall-Brand.' Whatever.

Finally, I wonder how accurate the claim is that Wagner came to
'despise' his early opera. Not accurate at all, I believe. The writer
also claims that Rienzi 'is far from a masterpiece' -- perhaps not
relative to Wagner's other operas, but it was a huge hit, right. I
think that Liszt knew right away after hearing Rienzi (or am I
mistaken in this) that already this was the manifestation of a musical
genius of the first order. It's pretty bombastic, I guess, but surely
there's much music of great beauty in it?

http://www.faz.net/s/Rub4D7EDEFA6BB3438E85981C05ED63D788/Doc~E95D7917CF98F4C748FF09AF6343A7994~ATpl~Ecommon~Scontent.html

kjbk Wallin

unread,
Feb 11, 2010, 4:00:13 PM2/11/10
to
A video trailer for the production can be found at:

http://www.deutscheoperberlin.de/?page=spielplandetail&id_event_date=4606127&language=en_EN

(or look around a little at the deutscheoperberlin.de if the link
doesn't work)

Giuseppe Sottotetti

unread,
Feb 11, 2010, 5:17:44 PM2/11/10
to
kjbk Wallin ha scritto:
>

Rienzi 'is far from a masterpiece' -- perhaps not
> relative to Wagner's other operas, but it was a huge hit, right. I
> think that Liszt knew right away after hearing Rienzi (or am I
> mistaken in this) that already this was the manifestation of a musical
> genius of the first order. It's pretty bombastic, I guess, but surely
> there's much music of great beauty in it?

I believe that Rienzi is very interesting. It contains some awful music
(the second act ballet, or the Santo spirito cavaliere) but the last two
acts are really good stuff: Act IV, with its dark atmosphere and the
processional music scored just for wind instruments predates Lohengrin.
The sepulcral "Vae tibi maledicto" chorus has a ghostly flavour
revealing that Wagner has already rediscovered Weber. And act V is very
nice too, the dramatic climax of the first scene, how it melts in the
finale where for the first time we have real development of leit-motivs
at Rienzi's last appearance. The finale of Rienzi seems to me much more
mature than the Flying Dutchman's.


--
Giuseppe Sottotetti
gso...@alice.it
http://SottotettiGiuseppe.ilcannocchiale.it/

Derrick Everett

unread,
Feb 12, 2010, 2:01:30 PM2/12/10
to
On Thu, 11 Feb 2010 19:35:43 +0100, Dave U. Random wrote:

> (AP) - Wagner's early opera "Rienzi" has a history of arousing strong
> emotions.
>
> The composer himself came to despise it and banned it from performance
> at his Bayreuth shrine. But it was the favorite opera of no less a
> Wagner fanatic than Adolf Hitler,

I never knew until now that Hitler liked Meyerbeer.

--
Derrick Everett
====== Writing from 59°54'N 10°37'E =======
http://www.monsalvat.no/index.htm
http://www.monsalvat.no/wagnerfaq.htm

CHSIII

unread,
Feb 12, 2010, 3:52:09 PM2/12/10
to
I notice in the cast list for Rienzi, Cardinal Orvieto is sung by Lenus
Carlson. Is this the Lenus Carlson of so many secondo baritone roles at the
Met thirty or forty years ago? I think he stopped singing at the Met quite
a while back, maybe 1990.


"Derrick Everett" <sparafu...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:4b75a58a$1...@news.broadpark.no...

edo...@gmail.com

unread,
Feb 12, 2010, 5:34:16 PM2/12/10
to
On Feb 12, 12:52 pm, "CHSIII" <chs...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> I notice in the cast list for Rienzi, Cardinal Orvieto is sung by Lenus
> Carlson.  Is this the Lenus Carlson of so many secondo baritone roles at the
> Met thirty or forty years ago?  I think he stopped singing at the Met quite
> a while back, maybe 1990.
>
> "Derrick Everett" <sparafucile1...@yahoo.com> wrote in message

>
> news:4b75a58a$1...@news.broadpark.no...
>
>
>
> > On Thu, 11 Feb 2010 19:35:43 +0100, Dave U. Random wrote:
>
> >> (AP) - Wagner's early opera "Rienzi" has a history of arousing strong
> >> emotions.
>
> >> The composer himself came to despise it and banned it from performance
> >> at his Bayreuth shrine. But it was the favorite opera of no less a
> >> Wagner fanatic than Adolf Hitler,
>
> > I never knew until now that Hitler liked Meyerbeer.
>
> > --
> > Derrick Everett
> > ====== Writing from 59°54'N 10°37'E =======
> >http://www.monsalvat.no/index.htm
> >http://www.monsalvat.no/wagnerfaq.htm- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

I don't know, but it's doubtful if there are two opera baritones with
that name. I remember Carlson from 1974 at the Met. He was the Silvio
in Tucker's eight Pagliacci performances that fall, which proved to be
Tucker's final Met appearances. Carlson was the only other singer in
the cast who was good!

Ed

Hans Christian Hoff

unread,
Feb 15, 2010, 2:50:20 PM2/15/10
to

In that case his career has been uncommonly long ! I think this Lenus
Carlson is still active, primarily at the Deutsche Oper Berlin, jf
http://www.operabase.com/listart.cgi?name=Lenus+[Carlson]&acts=+Schedule+.

He seems to be a bass rather than a baritone; he was Fritz Kothner in
the performance of Meistersinger at the Deutsche Oper Berlin, released
on DVD (Fr�hbeck de Burgos,Brendel,Winbergh,Schulte et al.)

Regards

Hans


0 new messages