I presume they start out in the chorus (I'm specifically referring to the
Met, which has a good sized children's chorus) and are picked out of the
crowd for various roles, but what happens when they grow up? Have some of
them become known as opera singers as adults?
Since they're already professionals to some degree as kids, one would think
it would be a logical path for many of them to pursue operatic careers as
adults, but I don't think I've ever heard of any adult opera singers who
started out in e.g. the Met Children's Chorus?
Any thoughts on this? Thanks,
Lis
Cecilia Bartoli reportedly sang the role of the Shepherd in _Tosca_ when
she was nine years old.
David Hemmings, who recorded the role of (I think) Miles in Britten's _Turn
of the Screw_ (not sure if he sang the premiere, but I'm pretty sure he did
the recording) moved on to a notable career as actor on stage, in film, and
on television.
Aled Jones, a notable boy soprano of a couple of decades ago, apparently
has made a modest career as a singer.
I think there have been a few notable Austrian male opera and Lieder
singers who performed as children in the Wienerknabenchor.
In other words, it has been known to happen. It does not appear to be a
particularly common or predictable career path, however. And those who
perform with bad technique (such as jaw-wobbling) probably cash out early.
--
Matthew B. Tepper: WWW, science fiction, classical music, ducks!
My personal home page -- http://home.earthlink.net/~oy/index.html
My main music page --- http://home.earthlink.net/~oy/berlioz.html
To write to me, do for my address what Androcles did for the lion
Top 3 worst UK exports: Mad-cow; Hoof-and-mouth; Charlotte Church
Best,
Ed
Best,
Ed
Best,
Ed
Best,
Ed
>One child singer that did pursue a career was none other than Jose
>Carreras. He sang child roles in and around Barcelona from about age 8.
>I have seen a program of La Boheme from Barcelona in 1958, starring
>Renata Tebaldi and Gianni Raimondi, where Carreras sings the part of the
>boy in act 2. He has told me how well he recalls that Tebaldi was
>extremely nice to all the children in the chorus.
I greatly enjoyed reading that!
> Cecilia Bartoli reportedly sang the role of the Shepherd in _Tosca_ when
> she was nine years old.
>
> David Hemmings, who recorded the role of (I think) Miles in Britten's _Turn
> of the Screw_ (not sure if he sang the premiere, but I'm pretty sure he did
> the recording) moved on to a notable career as actor on stage, in film, and
> on television.
>
> Aled Jones, a notable boy soprano of a couple of decades ago, apparently
> has made a modest career as a singer.
>
> I think there have been a few notable Austrian male opera and Lieder
> singers who performed as children in the Wienerknabenchor.
>
> In other words, it has been known to happen. It does not appear to be a
> particularly common or predictable career path, however. And those who
> perform with bad technique (such as jaw-wobbling) probably cash out early.
Another example is the Swedish baritone Urban Malmberg, who can be seen as one
of the three boys in the Bergman film of the Magic Flute. I believe he has a
busy career in Europe -- certainly in the late 80's he was a regular at the
Hamburg State Opera. We had him in Vancouver in 1989 as Malatesta in Don
Pasquale and he proved to be a fine singer, but with a voice a little too small
for the cavernous North American auditoriums.
One rather good example is the British actor, David Hemmings (many films). He
began his performing career aged 12 as Miles in the premiere of Britten's opera
"The Turn of the Screw"
NICK/London
Benjo Maso
"Lis K. Froding" <too...@ix.netcom.com@ix.netcom.com> schreef in bericht
news:9ab0ua$6vr$1...@slb7.atl.mindspring.net...
If only he'd sung the Boy to James McCracken's Parpignol ...
Hans Lick
> Is Yniold written for a boy soprano? It's done by a woman
> in drag, on my video of it. ...And I think women are often
> used in "Flute", too, aren't they? (I know Menotti
> specifically WROTE Amahl for a "boy soprano", but I've heard
> that done by women, too.)
All of those roles are written for boy soprano, but of course you have to
cast the best person you can. A boy is preferable, but if no decent one is
available (as is often the case) then you have to look elsewhere.
mdl
KM
=====
My NEIL SHICOFF Website:
http://www.radix.net/~dalila/shicoff/shicoff.html
My Website:
http://www.radix.net/~dalila/index.html
-----
We're sitting in the opera house;
We're waiting for the curtain to arise
With wonders for our eyes,
A feeling of expectancy,
A certain kind of ecstasy,
Expectancy and ecstasy....Sh's's's.
- Charles Ives
dft
==============
Karen Mercedes wrote:
-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 80,000 Newsgroups - 16 Different Servers! =-----
Regards,
Ximena
Right. And wasn't Kurt Equilux a Vienna Choirboy?
R.
The Met has a young boy in the role. This season and last season it
was James Danner, who was very very good, btw.
Lis
Why would that be? Why would not a much larger percentage pursue a
career in something they've already embarked on? It is the "been there,
done that" syndrome, or does a good voice as a child not necessarily
mean a good voice as an adult? Or have they been scared away by seeing
what the business of being an opera singer is "really" like? Or just
bored with it?
There are probably many reasons, but it still puzzles me that so
relatively few pursue the career as an adult.
Any other explanations why?
Lis
I can think of a few:
The "stakes" are higher and the competition is tough.
They prefer to pursue other careers.
The voice changes at puberty and is no longer as interesting.
Odious influences of peer pressure and the media dun them with messages
that classical music and opera are bad, and they fall for this crap.
Xise <xi...@aol.com> wrote in message
news:20010403112632...@ng-cm1.aol.com...
<<It seems from the responses so far that there are a few child singers
who go on to having an operatic career as adults, but not very many,
perhaps only slightly more than the population as a whole.
Why would that be?>>
My guess is that the general reasons might be similar to the reasons why so few
child film stars make successful transitions to adult stardom.
Speaking from personal anecdotal experience, as an undergraduate music student
I worked with a baritone who had appeared on the stage of the Met as a child
singer. His adult voice, however, was of no particular distinction, sadly.
It varies from case to case. When I was in high school, I had a friend
who had sung the title role in "Oliver!" (professionally), and who still
had a remarkable voice even after it changed. He didn't continue as a
professional because he just didn't enjoy the parts of being a professional
singer that didn't actually involve singing. As others have pointed out,
there's no guarantee when a boy's voice changes that it will be as good
as it was when he was a soprano.
-----
Richard Schultz sch...@mail.biu.ac.il
Department of Chemistry, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan, Israel
Opinions expressed are mine alone, and not those of Bar-Ilan University
-----
"You go on playing Bach your way, and I'll go on playing him *his* way."
-- Wanda Landowska
>In article <9adkiu$r4h$1...@slb7.atl.mindspring.net>, Lis K. Froding
<too...@ix.netcom.com@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
>
>: Why would that be? Why would not a much larger percentage pursue a
>: career in something they've already embarked on? It is the "been there,
>: done that" syndrome, or does a good voice as a child not necessarily
>: mean a good voice as an adult? Or have they been scared away by seeing
>: what the business of being an opera singer is "really" like? Or just
>: bored with it?
>
>It varies from case to case. When I was in high school, I had a friend
>who had sung the title role in "Oliver!" (professionally), and who still
>had a remarkable voice even after it changed. He didn't continue as a
>professional because he just didn't enjoy the parts of being a professional
>singer that didn't actually involve singing. As others have pointed out,
>there's no guarantee when a boy's voice changes that it will be as good
>as it was when he was a soprano.
>
>-----
>Richard Schultz
It's interesting that the responses here have all referred to the voice
changing. Though I mentioned some boys' roles in my initial post, I didn't
intend to limit the discussion to boys. The girls sing too --- what about
their voices?
Lis
: It's interesting that the responses here have all referred to the voice
: changing. Though I mentioned some boys' roles in my initial post, I didn't
: intend to limit the discussion to boys. The girls sing too --- what about
: their voices?
Well, if you think about it, there isn't nearly as much music that calls
for a girl soprano solo as there is that calls for a boy soprano. So
you wouldn't expect too many girls (Charlotte Church being the exception
that proves the rule) making a living as singers in the first place. The
only girl I know personally who had that good of a voice (and is now a
moderately successful opera singer) was already in high school when I
knew her, so I don't know if that counts as a "child" opera singer.
> One child singer who had an exceptional voice was Beverly Sills.>
Sills? She should have stayed in the chorus. Sills is no Charlotte Church,
Beav.
romain wrote:
ah, sir bart, now you're in for it. if you thought gaaaaaaby [and his
reincarnations] worshipped the water frau strudel walks on, you ain't seen
nuthin' yet.
dft
Really? C.C. is a very quick study. The hardest part would be pushing you
out of the way, eh?
R.
> One child singer who had an exceptional voice was Beverly Sills.<
As a neck whistler she was in a class all by herself, eh?
R.
Skip wrote:
> OH please Danny-poo, get over yourself.
skippikens is plainly in search of a men's room wall. volunteer providers,
please line up on the right. bring your "rinso white" recordings with you.
"daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
news:3ACB634E...@bway.net...
"daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
news:3ACB634E...@bway.net...
Skip wrote:
> Now you would know about men's room walls.......
where else would i read your collected writings?
romain <jeanchr...@mindspring.com> wrote in message
news:9afab2$e8d$1...@nntp9.atl.mindspring.net...
> There are probably many reasons, but it still puzzles me that so
> relatively few pursue the career as an adult.
That's odd. I drew an entirely different conclusion. I suppose
"relatively few" cannot be quantified except in relation to what one
intuitively expects. To me it seemed like the examples we gave here showed
a relatively high correlation.
Consider that the number of professional opera singers in the world is such
a small group to begin with (well under 0.1% of the population), and the
number of children who sing at the professional level is smaller yet. If
there were zero correlation, then the incidence of individuals who sang
opera both as child and adult would be the product of those two
percentages, which is to say virtually non-existent.
Instead, we have about a dozen examples cited here already -- and that's
only including the ones who are famous enough that someone here has heard
about their career at both ages. If you expand to include anyone who has
sung a little bit of opera at each level, then there will be a lot more. I
know five or six singers who have middling careers at the lower levels who
did some sort of classical singing as prepubescents. (I also once knew a
conductor who had been a boy soprano.)
mdl
Don't you EVER pick up a cat by the tail again!
>In article <9aego8$kic$1...@slb4.atl.mindspring.net>, Lis K. Froding
<too...@ix.netcom.com@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
>
>: It's interesting that the responses here have all referred to the voice
>: changing. Though I mentioned some boys' roles in my initial post, I didn't
>: intend to limit the discussion to boys. The girls sing too --- what about
>: their voices?
>
>Well, if you think about it, there isn't nearly as much music that calls
>for a girl soprano solo as there is that calls for a boy soprano.
Yes, I have thought about that, but there are plenty of girls in the chorus.
They sing and perform too and grow up as well.
Lis
She was just another neck whistler, heavily promoted from childhood. Believe
me, she's no Charlotte Church.
R.
Robert Sapolsky?
Four boy sopranos who later made it big:
Franz Joseph Haydn
Franz Schubert
Gaetano Donizetti
Enrico Caruso
I leave the castrati out of this, not to make an "empty" argument.
I believe Peter Mark, CEO of the Virginia Opera, sang boy soprano roles at
the Met. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Valfer
"Ed Rosen" <custo...@earthlink.net> wrote in message
news:3AC911C8...@earthlink.net...
> One child singer that did pursue a career was none other than Jose
Carreras. He
> sang child roles in and around Barcelona from about age 8. I have seen a
> program of La Boheme from Barcelona in 1958, starring Renata Tebaldi and
Gianni
> Raimondi, where Carreras sings the part of the boy in act 2. He has told
me how
> well he recalls that Tebaldi was extremely nice to all the children in the
> chorus.
>
> Best,
> Ed
>
> Best,
> Ed
>
> "Lis K. Froding" wrote:
>
> > I've often wondered what happens to kids who sing small or perhaps not
so
> > small roles in opera. For example Yniold in Pelleas et Melisande and
the
> > three boys in the Magic Flute. Those aren't roles where the kids just
have
> > to be there, they have to act and sing, in other words do what the adult
> > singers have to do.
> >
> > I presume they start out in the chorus (I'm specifically referring to
the
> > Met, which has a good sized children's chorus) and are picked out of the
> > crowd for various roles, but what happens when they grow up? Have some
of
> > them become known as opera singers as adults?
> >
> > Since they're already professionals to some degree as kids, one would
think
> > it would be a logical path for many of them to pursue operatic careers
as
> > adults, but I don't think I've ever heard of any adult opera singers who
> > started out in e.g. the Met Children's Chorus?
> >
> > Any thoughts on this? Thanks,
> > Lis
>
Skip wrote:
> Danny Dearest,
> I think you're confusing me with your sister Ball less Bollman (alias
> ancona/alias 10+ others)
> "daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
> news:3ACB72FE...@bway.net...
> >
> >
> > Skip wrote:
> >
> > > Now you would know about men's room walls.......
> >
> > where else would i read your collected writings?
> >
> > dft
no skippikens, illiteracy speaks for itself, and yours is identifiable at
a glance, an emetic of giant proportions.
Skip wrote:
> Danny Dearest,
> I think you're confusing me with your sister Ball less Bollman (alias
> ancona/alias 10+ others)
> "daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
> news:3ACB72FE...@bway.net...
> >
> >
> > Skip wrote:
> >
> > > Now you would know about men's room walls.......
> >
> > where else would i read your collected writings?
> >
> > dft
no skippikens, illiteracy speaks for itself, and yours is identifiable at
a glance, an emetic of giant proportions.
Skip wrote:
> Danny Dearest,
> I think you're confusing me with your sister Ball less Bollman (alias
> ancona/alias 10+ others)
> "daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
> news:3ACB72FE...@bway.net...
> >
> >
> > Skip wrote:
> >
> > > Now you would know about men's room walls.......
> >
> > where else would i read your collected writings?
> >
> > dft
no skippikens, illiteracy speaks for itself, and yours is identifiable at
a glance, an emetic of giant proportions.
dft
romain wrote:
-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
Haydn's soprano voice was so good that certain people wanted to, well, keep
it that way. Fortunately he escaped with everything still in place.
val...@msn.com (Valfer) wrote in <#mJ5SSHvAHA.300@cpmsnbbsa07>:
>I also have heard from several sources how nice Tebaldi was to children
>in the cast and to the children of her colleagues.
>
>Four boy sopranos who later made it big:
>Franz Joseph Haydn
>Franz Schubert
>Gaetano Donizetti
>Enrico Caruso
>
>I leave the castrati out of this, not to make an "empty" argument.
>
>I believe Peter Mark, CEO of the Virginia Opera, sang boy soprano roles
>at the Met. Correct me if I'm wrong.
>
>
>Valfer
>
>
>"Ed Rosen" <custo...@earthlink.net> wrote in message
>news:3AC911C8...@earthlink.net...
>> One child singer that did pursue a career was none other than Jose
>> Carreras. He sang child roles in and around Barcelona from about age 8.
>> I have seen a program of La Boheme from Barcelona in 1958, starring
>> Renata Tebaldi and Gianni Raimondi, where Carreras sings the part of the
>> boy in act 2. He has told me how well he recalls that Tebaldi was
>> extremely nice to all the children in the chorus.
>>
>> Best,
>> Ed
>>
>> "Lis K. Froding" wrote:
>>
>> > I've often wondered what happens to kids who sing small or perhaps not
>> > so small roles in opera. For example Yniold in Pelleas et Melisande
>> > and the three boys in the Magic Flute. Those aren't roles where the
>> > kids just have to be there, they have to act and sing, in other words
>> > do what the adult singers have to do.
>> >
>> > I presume they start out in the chorus (I'm specifically referring to
>> > the Met, which has a good sized children's chorus) and are picked out
>> > of the crowd for various roles, but what happens when they grow up?
>> > Have some of them become known as opera singers as adults?
>> >
>> > Since they're already professionals to some degree as kids, one would
>> > think it would be a logical path for many of them to pursue operatic
>> > careers as adults, but I don't think I've ever heard of any adult
>> > opera singers who started out in e.g. the Met Children's Chorus?
>> >
>> > Any thoughts on this? Thanks,
>> > Lis
--
Skip wrote:
> So sorry the viagra isn't working, maybe you should try a pump, don't worry,
> they make them is smaller sizes.
i assume you're offering yours.
sorry, i think that a rather unsanitary [and rather nauseating] suggestion.
now go back behind the barn and resume playing with yourself.
P.S. I wouldn't offer you shit if you were starving...........or maybe I
would, after all, it's a taste you're used to.
"daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
news:3ACC937A...@bway.net...
Skip wrote:
> At least I play with myself, and not the sheep like you did on your
> farm..............
>
> P.S. I wouldn't offer you shit if you were starving...........or maybe I
> would, after all, it's a taste you're used to.
gee skippy, that's a pity. no, i have long been on a restricted diet, and you
now suggest that you will now have a surplus. but i'm sure you'll be
delighted to eat it yourself, a diet with which you appear long familiar. and
remember, coloring it green, as you seem to enjoy, will not hide the reality;
even your sheep know that. you have not acquainted yourself with my
biography. i have always been a resident of large cities. my sexual activity,
to your consternation, has always been confined to conventional acts with
female persons. it may be that such practice, as most societal conduct, has
escaped your ken.
Skip wrote:
> At least I play with myself, and not the sheep like you did on your
> farm..............
>
> P.S. I wouldn't offer you shit if you were starving...........or maybe I
> would, after all, it's a taste you're used to.
gee skippy, that's a pity. no, i have long been on a restricted diet, and you
now suggest that you will now have a surplus. but i'm sure you'll be
delighted to eat it yourself, a diet with which you appear long familiar. and
remember, coloring it green, as you seem to enjoy, will not hide the reality;
even your sheep know that. you have not acquainted yourself with my
biography. i have always been a resident of large cities. my sexual activity,
to your consternation, has always been confined to conventional acts with
female persons. it may be that such practice, as most societal conduct, has
escaped your ken.
Skip wrote:
> At least I play with myself, and not the sheep like you did on your
> farm..............
>
> P.S. I wouldn't offer you shit if you were starving...........or maybe I
> would, after all, it's a taste you're used to.
gee skippy, that's a pity. no, i have long been on a restricted diet, and you
now suggest that you will now have a surplus. but i'm sure you'll be
delighted to eat it yourself, a diet with which you appear long familiar. and
remember, coloring it green, as you seem to enjoy, will not hide the reality;
even your sheep know that. you have not acquainted yourself with my
biography. i have always been a resident of large cities. my sexual activity,
to your consternation, has always been confined to conventional acts with
female persons. it may be that such practice, as most societal conduct, has
escaped your ken.
Now back to the mens room, and find something to eat.
"daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
news:3ACCA0E5...@bway.net...
skippy, wipe your nose.
dft
===========
Skip vomited [and we all agreed he had good cause]:
"daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
news:3ACCBDEE...@bway.net...
Skip wrote:
> Please don't flatter yourself, invite you to the men's room?
> Please I'd rather invite rita...........
>
and as a lady of good manners and good taste [strangers to hapless and
illiterate little skippy], the notion is nauseating beyond endurance. leave us.
you smell.
Skip wrote:
> Cackling? What does rita do, crow?
> "daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
no, has the happy circumstance of never having known bubbles' sycophantic
cesspool-dwelling little skippy. let's keep it that way. she also has the good
sense not to make a fool of herself in public. try it, if you can.
"daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
news:3ACCC13D...@bway.net...
"daniel f. tritter" <dtri...@bway.net> wrote in message
news:3ACCC1D5...@bway.net...
romain <jeanchr...@mindspring.com> wrote in message
news:9aht26$dd4$1...@slb3.atl.mindspring.net...
>
> "REG" > Romain - Why don't you like Sills? . . . snip>
>
> She was just another neck whistler, heavily promoted from childhood.
Believe
> me, she's no Charlotte Church.
> R.
>
>
Skip <!sk...@nospam.com.nyc.rr.com> wrote in message
news:B14z6.70$l5....@typhoon.nyc.rr.com...
Well done, Skip! I hope you receive an appropriate response from Dan.
Best regards,
Paul
>blessed are the peacemakers...
>
>dft
Does that extend to all manufacturers of dairy products?
-Anthony
"Matthew B. Tepper" wrote:
>
> dtri...@bway.net (dtritter) wrote in <3ACD3BB7...@bway.net>:
>
> >blessed are the peacemakers...
> >
> >dft
>
> Does that extend to all manufacturers of dairy products?
>
>
o, blessed child, may i touch you?
not during passover or holy week.
Wewease Bwian!
"He has a wife, you know. Do you know what she's called?"
Anconicus
><< Wewease Bwian! >>
>
>"He has a wife, you know. Do you know what she's called?"
>
>Anconicus
Incontinentia Buttocks?
Matthew B. Tepper <oy兀earthlink.net> wrote in message
news:mRnz6.9593$Kr1.7...@newsread1.prod.itd.earthlink.net...
I've always found the funniest name in the movie to be Nortius Maximus, the
fake name that Brian's father used so he couldn't be traced later. Sillius
Soddus is another.
Rich...@hotmail.com (REG) wrote in
<Qzsz6.651$l5.2...@typhoon.nyc.rr.com>:
>Does anyone remember "La Piccolissima"?
Was she anything like Lena Zavaroni?
Best, LT
"Actions may speak louder than words---BUT are they saying what we
THINK they're saying?" "And furthermore, how's a fella supposed to
handle problems one at a time - when they REFUSE to get in line??"