Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

New Excelsior 673 chromatic

75 views
Skip to first unread message

Russ Gray

unread,
Oct 9, 2007, 6:37:00 PM10/9/07
to
Would someone knowledgeable about the new excelsiors please explicate
on their current reputation and the positive and negatives to look out
for when buying a new excelsior accordion.

the reason I ask:

I have been looking for a small 72 bass, 3 treble reed chromatic C
system. I have checked:
Pigini, Beltrami, Fisitalia, Bafettti, Gabanelli, Allesandrini,
Victoria, Fratelli Crossio, Beltuna, Petosa and some others - none
build a 72 bass CBA with 3 reeds - 72 bass with 2 reeds are common,
and 3 and sometimes 4 reed 96 bass are not too hard too find.

Excelsior makes one! The model 673 - I have not got a solid price on
one yet but it is the design I am looking for.

Another question - why is it hard to find a 72 bass 3 treble reed CBA
when every company makes these models in a PA?

A final question: Does anyone know of another company making a model
like this?

thanks
russ

Krazy Kanuck

unread,
Oct 10, 2007, 12:20:05 AM10/10/07
to
Hi....I've got a Castiglione "gold" 72 bass PA that is basicly an Excelsior
that was "branded" for Castiglione accordions in Detroit....It's a pretty
good quality instrument from anything I can tell....at least an 8 out of
10....I'd say probably as good as anything made these days and maybe not as
good as the ones made in the heyday....
Len

--
....Order the "Accordion Evolution" documentary of the Las Vegas
International Accordion Convention from my website:
http://users.accesscomm.ca/limbery/
...Del Sur Al Norte...Regina Sk. Canada Latin and South American Folk dance
band:
www.DelSurAlNorte.info
"Russ Gray" <russ...@cs.com> wrote in message
news:1191969420.9...@k79g2000hse.googlegroups.com...

ike milligan

unread,
Oct 10, 2007, 12:00:59 PM10/10/07
to

"Russ Gray" <russ...@cs.com> wrote in message
news:1191969420.9...@k79g2000hse.googlegroups.com...

Excelsior is now made by Pigini. Not worth consideration unless you can get
a credible firm commitment for custom reeds. That will cost more of course.
I have seen the reeds in the new Excelsiors made by Pigini and didn't like
them much.
It would be very difficult or impossible to find a used accordion in that
configuration. One reason is import restrictions on chromatic accordions in
a misguided attempt to protect the Louisiana Cajun accordion makers. Also
the Italian industry was making a lot more PA's due to the vast accordion
schoolk racket in the 1950's.
There were some antique 80 bass with 2/5 reed sets by Dallape. I have a C
chromatic 80 bass made in Germany in the 1920's with Koch reeds and new
bellows. Would consider selling it for $2500.


David Haimson

unread,
Oct 10, 2007, 12:25:49 PM10/10/07
to
This spring, I ordered an accordion from Fisitalia. I wanted something
like what you're asking about, but a piano accordion. I bought their
34.34 model (which normally has 72 basses), but I had them build it
with 96 basses and hand-made reeds. They had no problem with my
special requests, the price was very reasonable, and they were a
pleasure to do business with. The instrument is excellent quality, it
weighs about 17 lbs, and I am completely delighted with it.

I would think you could get a Compact-49 with 72 basses, if that's
what you want. But why not just get it with the standard 96 basses?
Don't you ever need that C#?

I have no experience with the recent Excelsiors, but postings to this
group indicate that current production is, to be charitable, not as
good as it used to be.

David Haimson

On Oct 9, 4:37 pm, Russ Gray <russe...@cs.com> wrote:
> A final question: Does anyone know of another company making a model
> like this?

> russ

Len Killick

unread,
Oct 11, 2007, 3:58:34 AM10/11/07
to
On Oct 10, 6:00 pm, "ike milligan" <accordion...@mindspring.com>
wrote:
> "Russ Gray" <russe...@cs.com> wrote in message

You have to be a bit careful with Excelsior now, the instruments are
not made by Pigini directly as such, the company is owned by Pigini.
The potential problem with Excelsior is that some of the instruments
are made in Italy and some in Rumania (I think, at least - somewhere
over that way). However, the split is on a model basis (so one model
will not have mixed origin) and your dealer should know which models
are made in Italy and which are not. The only non-Italian one I've had
in my hand so far was a 3-row diatonic, and I must say I put it down
again rather quickly, whereas their 2-row diatonic (Bretagne) was very
clearly Italian and excellent. I think, but not sure, all the PA and
CBAs are still italian at the moment, but as I said your dealer should
know - the company does not keep it secret but doesn't shout about it
either!

Russ Gray

unread,
Oct 12, 2007, 7:41:27 PM10/12/07
to
thanks everyone for your response. - the 80 bass sounds nice but I am
looking for at least 3 reeds on the treble side. I have looked at the
compact 49 and I am considering it. I currently have a Fisitalia
46.45-TC with tone chamber, midi and mics - but it is full size and I
am looking for something a little smaller. So a 96 bass might be the
way to go. I am going to sell it to get the money for my smaller
accordion. I am now going to research 96 bass with 3 and 4 reed
combos - definitely easier to find. sounds like the 673 is built in
Italy and can be ordered with handmades.
thanks
russ


ike milligan

unread,
Oct 12, 2007, 9:03:48 PM10/12/07
to

"Len Killick" <l...@killick.de> wrote in message
news:1192089514.8...@v3g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...
I would still personally not buy one.


ike milligan

unread,
Oct 15, 2007, 9:11:31 AM10/15/07
to

"Russ Gray" <russ...@cs.com> wrote in message
news:1192232487....@q5g2000prf.googlegroups.com...
The reeds will not be hand made. Just better than the crap they usually put
in there.
>


Russ Gray

unread,
Oct 15, 2007, 5:43:17 PM10/15/07
to
On Oct 15, 9:11 am, "ike milligan" <accordion...@mindspring.com>

wrote:
> "Russ Gray" <russe...@cs.com> wrote in message
sounds like the 673 is built in Italy and can be ordered with
handmades.
> thanks russ
>
> The reeds will not be hand made. Just better than the crap they usually put
> in there.

thanks Ike
I also found 72 bass 3 reed models made by Polverini and Excalibur.

But most importantly I found a 72 bass 3 treble reed made by
weltmeister - I like the sound of their accordions, and the
weltmeister is about a third of the price of the excelsior. the model
number is 60/72/III/5. If I go the 72 bass model this is the one I
will get. If I get a second job for the holidays i might be able to
swing this.

For my main accordion am still thinking of a 4 reed 96 bass. Comments
on any of the following accordions or companies will be appreciated:
Vignoni - the Philarmonic 30, although I could do without the tone
chamber.
Beltrami - the C3 and C105
Cooperfisa-the super cesare 705
Fantini SCR/12/S
International Music Company (IMC) - The super gala
Beltuna and Victoria are probably out of my price range but both have
4 reed 96 bass models.

This is a more long term savings as it requires me selling my
Fisitalia.

when they say cassoto mussette or DO what does that mean?

thanks
russ

dewitas...@neuf.fr

unread,
Dec 5, 2007, 3:58:23 AM12/5/07
to
On 15 oct, 14:11, "ike milligan" <accordion...@mindspring.com> wrote:
> "Russ Gray" <russe...@cs.com> wrote in message
> - Masquer le texte des messages précédents -
>
> - Afficher le texte des messages précédents -

Hello,

I am new on this forum and quite new in the accordeon wolrd. i have
been learning this wonderful instrument for three monthes and have a
lot of fun;
I mainly like jazz, swing and king of gipsy swing.
I have the opportunity to buy from a friend a Fisitalia Compact 49
from a friend for around 3000 Euros.
What do you think of this instrument ? Is that a good one , Could i
have a better one at this price ?
Is that appropriate for playong jazz (it seems to be tunes in a swing
way)
Thank you very much for your answer. i nedd it because i am a bit lost
regarding the range of accordions.
Paul

Russ Gray

unread,
Dec 5, 2007, 6:09:27 PM12/5/07
to

I would email fisitalia and find out what price they are going for new
and then decide if 3 thousand euros is a good price.
they will respond to you very quickly with a quote.
russ

Gholamreza

unread,
Dec 6, 2007, 8:15:29 AM12/6/07
to
> Paul- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

Dear Paul,
Public price for Compact 49 is 4200.00 Euros without any options.
So if it is like new I suppose you have bought it at a resonable
price.
Fisitalia is really a good brand.I have one 41-45 TC piano with midi
and as an accordiopn collector I love it and it is my best instrument
in collection.
Gholamreza Seyed Hasani,
Nardin Gallery,
www.nardingallery.blogspot.com

Russ Gray

unread,
Dec 7, 2007, 8:13:06 PM12/7/07
to

Hi Paul,
I am also selling my chromatic, a fisitalia 46-45 TC It has 4 treble
reeds (LMMH) handmade of course with 2 of the reeds: a treble reed and
a basson reed in cassotto - very nice for jazz. 120 bass 5 reeds in
the bass with 7 bass switches. Midi and microphones. It is a full
size accordion and I mean full size. I love the sound but I am
getting older and it is too big for me. 4500 US dollars plus shipping
and I will have it gone over in the shop before I send it to you. to
buy this accordion new from fisitalia I was quoted 7200 US dollars in
October the midi w and microphones were quoted at 1900 dollars more
(my midi is an older model so not worth as much as the newer ones, but
it is still a decent midi and can be upgraded), if you are interested
email me. Russ...@cs.com

Joe Regina also was selling his fisitalia 4 treble reed (LMMH) 120
bass for 3000 I think, no mics or midi but a great accordion as well
with handmade reeds also. I don't know if he sold it or not.

joer...@sbcglobal.net

unread,
Dec 8, 2007, 9:38:38 AM12/8/07
to
Hi Russ,

I have tentatively sold my Fisitalia to a man in Muskegon, MI. His
family bought it for him as a Christmas gift so it's going to be a
surprise to him. He has until January 2nd to decide if he wants to
keep it or return it to me. There is always the possibilty that he may
not like it.

It sold on eBay for $3,000 plus shipping and insurance ($94.05). There
was only one bidder, so the demand for accordions is far lower then
the supply and the price reflects that. I believe he got a bargain,
but the conforting thought is that it has found a good home that will
cherish it.

Best Chrsitmas wishes to all and Happy Holiday wishes to our non-
christian friends.

Kindest regards,

Joe Regina

Russ Gray

unread,
Dec 8, 2007, 9:56:45 PM12/8/07
to
Great I am glad to hear you sold your accordion - it is hard to sell
chromatics, at least in the states as there is such a small market.

If the guy who is getting it is a chromatic player, I can see no
reason he would want to send that accordion back, If he wants a 120
bass C system chromatic How could he not like it? He got a good deal
and an excellent accordion

I am not in a real rush to sell mine - I do want a smaller one, 96
bass, but I do love my snow queen. I will have to save up a couple of
grand more after I sell it to get the 96 bass I want 4 reed LMMH with
tone chambers and mics, no midi though.
russ

On Dec 8, 9:38 am, "joereg...@sbcglobal.net" <joereg...@sbcglobal.net>
wrote:

0 new messages