Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

When Sunny Gets Blue by Marvin Fisher

294 views
Skip to first unread message

Marco Leonardi

unread,
Jul 6, 2005, 2:16:09 PM7/6/05
to
I am exploring the functional harmony of "When Sunny Gets Blue" by Marvin
Fisher:

G- C7 / Bb- Eb7 / FMaj7 G- / A- D7b9 / Bm7b5 Bb- / A-Ab° / G- C7 /Am7b5 D7+9
/

G- C7 / Bb- Eb7 / FMaj7 G- / A- D7b9 / Bm7b5 Bb- / A-Ab° / G- C7 / E- A7 /

BRIDGE

DMaj7 E- / F#- B7 / E- A7 / DMaj7 / D- G7 / CMaj7 A- / D- G7 / G- C7 /

G- A- / Bb- Eb7 / FMaj7 G- / A- D7b9 / Bm7b5 Bb- / A- Ab° / G- C7+9 / FMaj7

The song is in Fmaj7. I kind ask to the genius musician (Joey Goldstein,
Mark Sabatella, etc.) to have a look and kindly let me know if this analysis
is acceptable or not, in particular I wonder what is going-on on / A- D7b9 /
Bm7b5 Bb- / A-Ab° /.

This is my analysis:

G- C7 = ii V

Bb- Eb7 = iv bVII minor plagal cadences

FMaj7 G- = I ii

A- D7b9 = ii/ii V/ii

Bm7b5 Bb- = vii°/V and again minor plagal cadence (correct ?)

A-Ab° = iii #ii°

G- C7 = ii V

Am7b5 D7+9 = vii°/IV V/ii

G- C7 = ii V

Bb- Eb7 = iv bVII minor plagal cadences

FMaj7 G- = I ii

A- D7b9 = ii/ii V/ii

Bm7b5 Bb- = vii°/V and again minor plagal cadence

A-Ab° = iii #ii°

G- C7 = ii V

E- A7 = ii V

BRIDGE

DMaj7 E- = I ii

F#- B7 = ii/ii V/ii

E- A7 = ii V

DMaj7 = I

D- G7 = ii V

CMaj7 A- = I vi

D- G7 = ii V

G- C7 = ii V

G- A- = ii iii

Bb- Eb7 = iv bVII

FMaj7 G- = I ii

A- D7b9 = ii/ii V/ii

Bm7b5 Bb- = vii/V iv

A- Ab° = iii #ii°

G- C7+9 = ii V

FMaj7 = I

THANKS

Marco Leonardi


Rick Stone

unread,
Jul 6, 2005, 6:33:32 PM7/6/05
to
Marco,

Basically right but a few notes (which I included inline with your orignal
message below.

Musically Yours,
Rick Stone
website: http://www.rickstone.com
Listen to clips from my new CD "Samba de Novembro" with Tardo Hammer, Yosuke
Inoue and Matt Wilson at http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/rickstone
And drummer Al Ashley's CD "These Are Them" featuring Dave Leibman, Rick
Stone and Oliver Von Essen at http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/alashley

"Marco Leonardi" <m.leo...@tin.it> wrote in message
news:JdVye.124371$75.53...@news4.tin.it...


> This is my analysis:
>
> G- C7 = ii V
>
> Bb- Eb7 = iv bVII minor plagal cadences
>
> FMaj7 G- = I ii
>
> A- D7b9 = ii/ii V/ii

The A- D7b9 forms a "ii V7" type progression, but that can easily be seen.
I would still think of A- as the "iii" chord. At Berklee we used a system
where we just made a bracket over the "ii V7" and then analyzed it using the
standard roman numeral (but we did acknowledge the secondary dominants).

> Bm7b5 Bb- = vii°/V and again minor plagal cadence (correct ?)

It's really the vi-6 chord in 3rd inversion (Bm7b5 is really a Dm chord with
its 6th in the bass) going to iv-. Not sure where you got this viio/V. Of
course a diminished can often be a leading tone chord, but then it would
HAVE to resolve up (this one doesn't). And again, it's a "half-diminished"
not really a diminished chord (the two don't behave the same way).

> A-Ab° = iii #ii°

Abo is the biiio not the #iio. Big difference since #iio resolves up to
iii, but this chord resolves down to ii.

>
> G- C7 = ii V
>
> Am7b5 D7+9 = vii°/IV V/ii

Again, half diminished chords are not really diminished chords, just a minor
with the 6th in the bass. The progression here is really simple (like a iv
V7 moving the the Gm). Just bracket it, and label the D7 V7/ii and it makes
more sense.

> G- C7 = ii V
>
> Bb- Eb7 = iv bVII minor plagal cadences
>
> FMaj7 G- = I ii
>
> A- D7b9 = ii/ii V/ii
>
> Bm7b5 Bb- = vii°/V and again minor plagal cadence

Other things I saw were just other instances of the same thinking on other
chords in the bridge.

Marco Leonardi

unread,
Jul 7, 2005, 2:25:15 AM7/7/05
to
THANKS RICK ! VERY KIND TO HELP ME.

MARCO

"Rick Stone" <rick...@rickstone.com> ha scritto nel messaggio
news:0%Yye.9741$vE5.8396@trndny07...

0 new messages